Site icon PrimaryDocuments.ca

“Mazzini and the Montreal Herald on Education”, True Witness (13 January, 1865)


Document Information

Date: 1865-01-13
By: True Witness
Citation: “Mazzini and the Montreal ‘Herald’ on Education”, True Witness (13 January, 1865)
Other formats: TBA


MAZZINI AND THE MONTREAL “HERALD” ON EDUCATION.

—Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles? From the lips of a Mazzini, the Apostle of Assassination, the high priest of “the dagger,” can we learn virtue, or obtain a lesson how mankind should be educated? Yes! for Mazzini has written upon Education, insisting well and forcibly upon its necessity, and its nature. It is only by Education, but only by the Education of the heart as well as of the head, of the will as well as of the reason, by a religious Education in short, that Society can be saved from destruction. This is the theory of a liberal like Mazzini, and we therefore commend it seriously to the attention of the Montreal Herald which declares itself altogether in favor of irreligious or purely secular State-Schoolism. We copy from a late issue of the Herald:—

We have often contended, and shall always contend, that public schools paid for by the State ought to be bona fide secular schools, in spirit as well as in letter: * * * * * *
We have also contended that the Separate School system was an evil, only to be tolerated because the more rational plan could not be carried out.—Montreal Herald.

This may be the doctrine or theory of our Canadian contemporary; but even amongst those who profess it, but few consistently adhere to in practice; and we doubt much if the writer would accept for his child in particular, the system of education which he proposes for all Canadian children in general. From Mazzini, whose lucubrations on the same subject appeared some time ago in the Herald, our contemporary might have learned a better doctrine than that of a mere secular education: for even Mazzini recognises that the great end of education is to enable men to distinguish the right from the wrong, and to do their duty. Education therefore must be moral as well as secular; and a morality without God, is as inconceivable as a solar system without a sun. “Rights and duties” must be the subject of all education worth paying for.

Mazzini says this, and in this Mazzini says well: though upon this point he must be at issue with all the advocates of a purely secular and “non-sectarian” education as the one thing needful. It is for this reason that we as Catholics gladly quote Mazzini on the Education question as an authority against whom Protestants can raise no objections as a reactionist, as the victim of priestcraft, or the opponent of progress. The theory of Mazzini on Education is this:—

“The sole origin of every Right is in a Duty fulfilled.”

To teach men their Duty therefore, in order that by its fulfilment they may attain to the enjoyment of their Rights is the one legitimate end of all Education. This is the principle laid down by Mazzini in a work published by him under the title the “Duties of Man” about two years ago, and of which a notice appeared in the Montreal Herald some short time since together with extracts from the work itself. But how is man to be taught his Duty? from whom is to be learn its extent and its limits? above all, from what source is he to derive strength to perform it?—

“By means” asks Mazzini—”of the prison or the executioner?” And he thus continues:—

“Every Society that has existed hitherto has employed these means.

“But this is a state of war, and we need peace, that is tyrannical repression and we need education.

“Education I have said, and my whole doctrine is included and summed up in this grand word. The vital question in agitation at the present day, is a question of Education. * * * * *

“We have therefore to seek a Principle of Education superior to any theory.

“This Principle is Duty. We must convince men that they are all sons of one sole God, and bound to fulfill and execute one sole law here on earth:—that each of them is bound to live, not for himself, but for others;—that the aim of existence is not to be more or less happy, but to make themselves and others more virtuous.”

But—and here comes the question—by whom, and how is this principle of “Duty” to be inculcated? and having learnt their Duty, whence are men to derive the strength necessary to enable them to fulfill it? For it is not enough that we should know, or have sublime theories of our Duty, unless we reduce those theories to practice. Not every one that saith Lord! Lord! but he only that doeth the will of God shall enter into His Kingdom. We require therefore, according to the Mazzinian theory of Education, a teacher competent, not only to teach us our Duty, but to furnish us with means or strength to perform that Duty when it shall have been taught to us.

Now this teacher must be a teacher in the supernatural order, for all the history of the human race shows that the natural teacher has hitherto failed to teach men their Duty; and that left to himself, and destitute of supernatural aid, man in all ages, and under all circumstances, has also always failed in the performance of his Duty. The very idea of Duty implies God, for without the idea of God as the supreme lawgiver, it is impossible to conceive of any Duty of man towards man. This Mazzini admits; for he contends that neither in the individual, nor in Society is there to be found any Right of man over man; and thus he recognises that without God there can be no Duty of man towards man. He says:—

“The Rights of each individual are equal: the fact of living together in Society does not create a single one. Society has greater power, not greater rights than the individual.”

Duty of man, therefore, towards man, whether considered as the individual, or as Society, must have Duty towards God as its principle; and to learn that Duty we must have the aid of Revelation, or a supernatural teacher; no matter whether that teacher assume the form of an infallible Church, or a divinely inspired Book. By mere natural reason alone, men never as yet have been able to convince themselves that they are “all sons of one sole God;” and even when through the Christian Revelation they have attained to the knowledge of that truth, never by their mere natural strength have they been able to reduce their theory to practice. The attempt was made indeed in France in the last century. Philosophers who had discarded the Gospel and the use of the Sacraments, discoursed learnedly of the Brotherhood of the entire Human Race, and waxed eloquent upon Fraternity and Philanthropy. We all know that these nice theories culminated in the Reign of Terror; as they will culminate again should men ever again attempt to carry them out as the products of human reason, and without those supernatural aids given to us in the Sacraments.

Only through the Christian Revelation have men actually learnt their Duty towards their fellow men; only by the grace of God imparted through the Church have men ever been able to fulfill that Duty even when it had been pointed out to them. The Education therefore, for which Mazzini pleads as alone able to save Society, is a Christian Education; an Education which a supernatural teacher alone is able to impart; because an education without the supernatural aids of which the Church is the guardian and dispenser, would still remain practically useless. But this teacher, these supernatural aids, Mazzini ignores and discards, and an Education of which “Duty is the Principle” thus becomes to him an impossibility. Why! the chief thing that Mazzini proposes to teach, as the basis of those relations which he would establish betwixt man and man, is “that they are all sons of one sole God,” in other words he would establish the unity of the human race. We should like to see how the Mazzinian pedagogues would attempt to establish even this little fact without the aid of revelation. Assuredly the philosophers of the pre-Christian world were, intellectually, the equals of the philosophers of the XIX century; and yet the idea of the brotherhood and unity of the human race was neither acted upon, nor entertained in the most humane and enlightened of Pagan countries. What the human reason is, of itself, capable of may be a matter of dispute; what in the brightest days of the non-Christian world it had actually attained to, what were its teachings of the Duties of man to man, and to Society, we know from history. Man is much the same to-day that he was two thousand years ago; and but for the Church or his supernatural teacher, would have progressed in degeneracy, and would long ago have fallen far below the moral level of the heathen contemporaries of Saint Paul. Without this same supernatural teacher at the present day man would rapidly revert to the same filthy and brutalised condition as that from which Christianity, and the Sacraments, not natural reason, redeemed him.

Mazzini is right therefore in insisting upon the necessity of Education as the great want of the age. Not such an education merely as is usually contended for, and is given in Common Schools—an education in arithmetic, mathematics, or book-keeping, whether by single or double entry. These things will not save Society from dissolution, for this can be affected only by an Education which shall teach men their duty, which shall have its “principle in duty.” So far we agree with Mazzini; but in that he fails to indicate how and by whom that Principle of Duty is to be inculcated; in that he discards all supernatural teaching, and trusts to reason and nature alone to do the work of revelation and grace, his scheme also must fail again, as it has already failed whenever or wherever tried. He speaks brave words, as do all our modern philanthropists, all our friends of enlightenment and progress; but when we ask for something more substantial than words, we find that we have been but mocked and made fools of by a miserable repetition of the absurd theories propounded in the XVIII century for the renovation of society.

Mazzini’s testimony, however, is valuable in the Education controversy, in so far as it shows that in the opinion of such a leading revolutionist, education is valuable only in so far as it acts upon and affects the will and the conscience; in so far as it is moral rather than intellectual, and only in so far as it has for its principle the idea of Duty. But this idea implies religion, or the relation of man towards God, since it is only because of his duties towards God that man has, or can be conceived of as having any duties whatever towards man or society; and this again leads to the conclusion that though Education is essential, yet Religious Education alone can be of any service to, or prevent the dissolution of, society. And thus though Catholics and Protestants may disagree about the religious teacher, whether it shall be the Church, or a Book, yet, if with Mazzini they make Duty the principle of their Education, they must both invoke the aid of the religious or supernatural teacher as the great want of the age.

Exit mobile version