Site icon PrimaryDocuments.ca

“No title”, True Witness (13 January, 1865)


Document Information

Date: 1865-01-13
By: True Witness
Citation: “No title”, True Witness (13 January, 1865)
Other formats: TBA


The London Times discusses at much length the terms of the proposed Union of the British North American Provinces as drawn up by the delegates at Quebec. On the whole the Times approves of them, and applauds the idea of union, seeing therein the probability of soon getting rid of a perfectly useless, and in case of war, of a very troublesome incumbrance. Anything that tends—as does the scheme now in contemplation—to bring about an amicable separation of the North American Colonies of Great Britain from the mother country, will be gladly hailed by the people of the latter. It is for this reason, and not because it sees therein any good for Lower Canada, or guarantee for its religious and social institutions, that the Times approves of the Union scheme; it looks upon us as big enough and old enough, to set up in business for ourselves; and thinks that the time has arrived when we should cease to be a burden upon the head of the family.

The Times is therefore no unfriendly critic of the Quebec scheme, but it is not blind to its defects, as for instance the plan for constituting a second chamber for the Central Legislature.—But this is a mere matter of detail in which we take no interest, seeing that in the said second chamber, the States will not be represented at all, since its members will be the mere nominees, or puppets of the central government. Another objection however urged by the Times strikes at the very root of the matter, and is identical in substance with the objections urged by the TRUE WITNESS against any such scheme of Union as that which Mr. George Brown and the Clear Grits of Upper Canada would consent to accept as a settlement of their exhorbitant claims on this Province. Writing in June last on the subject of a Federal Union of Colonies or States, not severally sovereign and independent, we pointed out one inherent difficulty, which it was impossible for human ingenuity to overcome, and which of itself, was an all conclusive reason against a Federation of subject Provinces:—

“The all important question presents itself who is to determine what matters are of common interest and therefore to be legislated for by the Federal legislature, * * and what matters are of separate and local interest, and therefore the subject of State legislation? If the settlement of this question be left to the Federal legislation the autonomy of the Province with the smaller population is destroyed, and its local interests placed at the mercy of a hostile majority.! * * If it be left to the State legislatures to determine what matters fall within their province the Federal authority is naught, and a Federal government would be as useless an incumbrance as the traditional fifth wheel of a coach.”—True Witness, 24th June, 1864.

Of course, no matter how elaborately the respective attributes of the two governments or legislatures may be defined, the whole ground cannot be thereby covered; cases will be constantly arising, not provided for or covered by the said terms, and disputes as to the respective limits of their functions between the Federal legislature and the State legislatures are inevitable. If in these disputes the former is to be judge in its own cause, its authority is absolute and unlimited, and local legislatures as barriers against aggression, are but a farce, and may well be dispensed with; if the latter or local legislatures are to adjudicate, the Federal or central legislature is practically useless. This was the argument of the TRUE WITNESS, based on the moral impossibility of clearly defining the respective limits of central and local functions; how far events have justified our predictions may be seen from the following comments of the London Times on the abortive attempt of the Quebec delegates to assign to each—to Central Legislature and Local Legislature — the respective limits beyond which neither shall be able to pass. No doubt the delegates did their best; but according to such a favorable critic as the Times their best is but a bundle of absurdities:

“But the most important clause”—(all important the True Witness called it in June last)—”in the whole Resolutions, and unfortunately, by no means the easiest to understand, is the one which defines the powers of the central federal legislature.”—London Times.

This unintelligibility is due, not to the delegates, but to the subject with which they had to deal. In attempting to “define the powers” of a government intentionally armed with indefinite power, they attempted the impossible and therefore failed. They were no luckier when they attempted to define the powers of the local legislatures according to the Times:—

“It is exceedingly difficult to construe these provisions. First, general powers of legislation are given in the widest terms to the General Parliament; then a power is given especially to make laws on thirty-seven subjects, one of those being all matters of a general character not exclusively reserved to the Local Legislatures. Nothing is exclusively reserved to the Local Legislatures; and it would seem, therefore, that the effect of this clause is to cut the power of central legislation down to matters of a general character—a most vague and unsatisfactory definition, and one sure, if it be retained, to produce conflict and confusion. In the same way, what are matters of a private and local nature not assigned to the General Parliament? We have failed to discover any matters of a private and local nature which are so assigned, and therefore the power will be limited by the words ‘private’ and ‘local:’ so that the effect of these clauses will be that, beyond the subjects attributed to each, the Central Legislature will have jurisdiction over general matters, whatever they are, and the Local Legisture over local matters, whatever they are; while it is in the highest degree doubtful what the Courts would consider general and what local, and whether the Central Legislature has any concurrant jurisdiction over private and local matters or no.”—Times.

If the Times sees the difficulty, the Globe indicates the way out of it. Its idea, which is simply the idea of Mr. George Brown, and the Liberal party generally, is that as the Central Government will always be strong enough to overpower the local governments, and will not fail to exercise that power, there is no danger to be apprehended from the conflicting pretensions of two rival authorities. The local governments, under the proposed constitution, will be too weak, too paltry, and too much under the absolute control of the central government to offer any serious obstacles to the latter. This is how the Globe, Mr. George Brown’s organ, answers the objections: —

“The London Times, in discussing the resolutions of the Quebec Conference, raises the objection that they leave a chance for collision between the general and local Governments.

“It would be very difficult to specify every possible subject for either general or local legislation. If ever so long a list were made, we would be sure to find after a while that something had been omitted.

“Should such a contest as the Times anticipates arise once in a number of years, the veto vested in the general Government would fully enable it to prevent any of the local Governments from encroaching upon its powers.”—Globe.

Exit mobile version