Document Information
Date: 1864-10-14
By: True Witness
Citation: “No title”, True Witness (14 October, 1864)
Other formats: TBA
Our neighbor, the Montreal Gazette, boasts we think prematurely, of having convicted the TRUE WITNESS of inconsistency, in that the last named journal is of opinion that in Canada, and indeed in British North America, we have not the “social elements” of Great Britain, “and are therefore unable to reproduce the peculiar political system” of the latter—especially its hereditary monarchy; and in that we also express an opinion, a strong opinion, against the system of an elective executive such as obtains in the United States. Wherein, we ask the Gazette, is there any inconsistency betwixt those two opinions?
First we state a fact; that we have not in North America the social system of Great Britain. We have not got the latter’s landed gentry, or its law or custom of primogeniture, to which the existence of a wealthy and political influential class of British society is due. Is this statement true, or is it false?
In the second place we conclude from the facts or premises—1st, that our social system, or social life, is not as is that of Great Britain—and, 2nd, that the political system of a people must be in harmony with its social system, or else revolution is inevitable,—that it is in vain to attempt to reproduce in British North America the peculiar political system of Great Britain; since the result would be a want of harmony betwixt our political and social systems. Is not this conclusion a logical deduction from our premises? If it is not, we are open to correction.
Again we express our opinion that the Yankee democratic system of an elective executive should be held in abhorrence by the loyal subject of Queen Victoria, by every man who loves liberty and order. An “elective” executive,” we have said, and we repeat it, is in our opinion a curse, an evil to be avoided, rather than a blessing to be courted. Is there in this expression of opinion anything unbecoming a loyal British subject, or incompatible with the opinion that we cannot reproduce in British North America the peculiar political system which obtains in Great Britain? If so, we are open to correction.
If indeed the TRUE WITNESS advocated the separation of these Provinces from Great Britain, if the TRUE WITNESS had in any manner advocated a course of policy which by tending to assimilate our institutions to those of the States must tend to precipitate the evil, but we fear inevitable, hour when the tie which binds us to Victoria’s Empire shall be severed—then indeed we might be taunted with inconsistency.—But as the ever recurring burden of our song is “let us do all in our power to maintain and prolong our connection with the Mother Country; let us use all means in our power to put off or delay, even if we cannot avert, the calamity that menaces us”—we can see in the passages which the Gazette cites against us, but proof of our aversion to the impending constitutional changes; which we fear can but have the effect of assimilating our institutions to those Yankee institutions which we abhor, and therefore of precipitating the evil day when in default of an hereditary sovereign we shall be compelled to fall back upon an elective executive.
The Gazette takes further exception to our comments upon the evils of an elective executive, in that we have failed to take account of the fact that, in case of what it ludicrously calls a “Confederation” of the British North American Colonies, the Governors of the several States or Provinces members of that Confederation, might be appointed by the Federal or central government. This is certainly true; for it never entered into our imagination that any one would be so foolish as to apply the term “Confederation” to a system such as that anticipated, and hinted at, by the Montreal Gazette. What is the possible use of keeping up the farce any longer? No one is deceived by it. The Gazette knows, the advocates of the proposed “constitutional changes” know, that the result thereof cannot bear the most distant resemblance to a Confederation, or to any Federal system of Government that has ever existed since the days of the Amphictyons to those of Abe Lincoln and Jeff Davis. We, in our article which the Gazette criticises, considered the inevitable consequences of a real Federation upon the several Provinces; and we therefore, of course, assumed that all executive offices or appointments within the several States or members of that Federation, would be perfectly independent of the central or Federal Government; for to give to the latter any the slightest power of interference with the internal affairs of its several component parts would be destructive of the Federal principle. The Governor of a State is not only head of the executive, but is necessarily one of the branches of the legislature, since he exercises legislative as well as executive functions. What then would remain of the Federal principle, were the central government to be invested with the right of appointing or nominating one of the branches of the legislature of the several States? what vestige under such circumstances would remain of State Rights, and Provincial autonomy? And yet the only reason that can be assigned for preferring a Federal to a Legislative, or Incorporating Union is this: That under the former the Rights of the several States and their autonomy would be secured. Therefore again we say that we would infinitely prefer a Legislative or Incorporating Union of the several British North American Colonies, to the mongrel Union which the Gazette advocates, and which would entail on us all the expences, all the inconveniences, and all the cumber of a Federal Union, without a single one of its compensating advantages in the shape of security to our local institutions.
The farce of Colonial Federation is pretty nigh played out. The mask that its advocates have hitherto worn in the vain hopes of concealing their features is too transparent; it is so flimsy that every one not stone blind can see through it. No one is imposed on by it any longer. There is no one so simple, or so dull of intellect as not to perceive that the scheme in contemplation, and traced out by the Globe and the Gazette, is neither more nor less than a Legislative Union of the British North American Provinces, with Representation by Population; and that the terms “Federation” and “Confederation” are only made use of to gull simpletons as are the sugar and molasses with which nurses try to deceive and coax the peevish child making wry faces at the obnoxious dose of physic. The Gazette knows as well as we do, that it is the rankest humbug to apply the term “Confederation” to such a Union as that which it contemplates; and the sheerest hypocrisy to pretend that therein is to be found any the slightest guarantee for the local and peculiar institutions of any one of the several Provinces, should unfortunately those institutions be obnoxious to the national or religious prejudices of the majority of the central government. Drop then the useless mask with which in vain you attempt to conceal your true features; and do cease your nauseating cant about Federation, and a Federal Union of the Colonies. You deceive nobody except those who from party motives are determined to be deceived; who having eyes see not, and who having ears yet cannot hear. The sham has been long enough kept up; amusing perhaps at first, it is now simply tiresome to the spectators, and degrading to those who take active part therein.
