“Dinner to the Hon. Mr. McGee”, Montreal Witness (18 November, 1865)


Document Information

Date: 1865-11-18
By: Montreal Witness
Citation: “Dinner to the Hon. Mr. McGee”, Montreal Witness (18 November, 1865)
Other formats: TBA


DINNER TO THE HON. MR. MCGEE.

Last night, a complimentary dinner was given to Mr. McGee in the St. Lawrence Hall. The room was decorated with flags, and the tables were arranged in a semicircle, the principal chair being in the centre. Walter McFarlane, Esq., occupied the chair, the Vice-chairmen being Wm. Workman and A. M. Delisle, Esqs.

Letters of apology were read from the following gentlemen, who were prevented from attending:—The Hon. W. McDougall, Provincial Secretary; His Honor Mr. Recorder O’Reilly, Kingston; the O’Connor Don, the Hon. N. F. Belleau, the Hon. J. C. Chapais, Commissioner of Public Works, and the Hon. Mr. Langevin, Solicitor General East.

The toasts of the Queen, the Prince and Princess of Wales, his Excellency the Administrator of the Government, the Army, Navy, and Volunteers having been given and responded to that of the army by Major Cassidy, and that of the volunteers by Col. Dyde,

The Chairman in a few suitable remarks introduced the toast of the evening, “Our hon. friend Thomas D’Arcy McGee, Minister of Agriculture and Emigration.”

The toast was received with immense enthusiasm.

Hon. Mr. McGee, on rising to respond to this toast, was received with loud and continued cheering; and after some introductory remarks, he said:—You have given my health as Minister of Agriculture and Emigration: as Minister of Agriculture, my duties as at present defined are, to see the administration of the agricultural and patent laws, as they stand on the statute books—which, I believe, the Department does promptly and efficiently; but the sphere of the Minister’s duty, whether I occupy it or another, would bear, I think, a considerable enlargement. As the Minister charged with immigration affairs, all that I can do, at present, is rather discretionary than defined, and, therefore, the more a matter of anxiety. It is satisfactory to be able to say on this head, that the number of immigrants using our route in 1865, was rather over than under the average of late years; but it is the reverse of satisfactory to see the larger half of the arrivals, allured by the reported high wages, but uninformed as to the equally high cost of living, making their way to the United States. (Hear hear.) I think we ought, and I believe we shall, liberalize our system of disposing of the public lands; I think we ought to have some substitute for the Homestead law, which attracts so many settlers to the States; but, so far as the tide of new labor is concerned, I confess I can discover no prospect of seriously diminishing this annual efflux, until we see begun or about to begin, these great works of public utility which we all expect to accompany the advent of a closer union of the Provinces. (Cheers.) In reference to the official toast, Mr. Chairman, let me also say that I can heartily reciprocate the satisfaction you have expressed at the result of the Canadian representation at the Dublin Exhibition. Although we had very little time for preparation, and only a thousand pounds sterling to start with, I think it ought to gratify those who took a much larger share in the preparation than I did—my indefatigable Deputy, Mr. Taché, the two Boards of Arts and Agriculture, and Dr. Hunt, of the Geological Survey, acting in the absence of Sir Wm. Logan,—to know that Canada attained so honorable a place—the ninth place among all nations—at that Exhibition. (Cheers.) We were honored in our Department there, with the presence of many thousands of visitors, from His Royal Highness the Prince of Wales, (cheers), and the Viceroy of Ireland, down to the intending emigrant laborer,—and, so far as I could learn, from the press on the spot and from private report, the impression left on all our visitors was favorable to this Province, its prospects, and resources. If, however, we are to be represented at Paris in 1867, as we hope to be, and if I should have anything officially to say to the arrangements, I should endeavor to get time enough and money enough to put the country in the best possible point of view before the myriads who will flock to that Exhibition. (Hear, Hear.) I feel, Mr. Chairman, in the presence of so many gentlemen to whom we hope to listen, that I ought to reiterate my thanks and resume my seat; but there is a subject which has occupied a good deal of public attention, with which my name has been much mixed up, at home and abroad, and upon which, I hope, you will allow me to be, as these times demand, explicit and emphatic. If this be your will, gentlemen, you will grant me the latitude Montreal has always allowed me and I will endeavor not to abuse your indulgence. As to the usefulness of the speeches made at London or at Wexford, I can have nothing to say; I thought it necessary to show my countrymen the reverse of the American medal always glistening before their eyes; I endeavored to set the truth clearly before my own mind, and equally so before them; my intentions were the best, whatever the result. (Cheers.) It was not a pleasant report for me to make, or for a Mother Country to hear, that for so many of her emigrants democracy and degeneracy had proved identical terms. It was not a pleasant subject to sketch those seaport demagogues, native and Irish, who have made themselves the masters of the passions of so many of the Irish in the United States, who are at this moment coining their prejudices if not into gold, certainly in greenbacks, to the astonishment and derision of all sensible men. But I was careful not to permit the impression that this degenerate class, though unfortunately too numerous, included all my countrymen in the United States; I was careful to do justice both to the domestic and public virtues of a very different class (cheers), against whom the worst reproach we can make is, that they fail in a robust resistance to the demagogues and their dupes; that they allow the lowest and least worthy among them to speak for all; that, content with avoiding the contamination themselves, they make no concerted effort to keep their less intelligent compatriots out of the jaws of those who daily devour them as their prey. If any justification were needed by any one of the severity with which I spoke of the Yankee-Irish demagogues, they may find it in the shameful farce now played before our eyes under the title of “Irish Republic.” (Laughter.) We have had on the Boards before “the Irish Ambassador” and “King O’Neil”; but their performances are eclipsed by “the Irish Republic” and President O’Mahoney. (Laughter.) An Irish Republic on Manhattan Island, with Senators from Tennessee and Senators from Massachusetts, with a President taken from the Lunatic Asylum, and, in “a concatenation accordingly,” Mr. Train—if there really be such a person as Mr. Train—as its orator. I say if there really be such a person, for I always suspected that Train was a work of fiction like Orpheus C. Kerr or Bird-o’-Freedom Sawin. (Great laughter.) As an extravaganza on American oratory the character is not badly sustained,—a little too improbable perhaps; but if there be really such a person, and if he really made the mad speech he is reported to have made, “in lavender-colored gloves,” to the Fenian Congress at Philadelphia, only fancy what a Congress it must have been! (Laughter.) Only fancy the Congress that sat nearly a century ago at Philadelphia—grave men conscious of their work—invited to listen to some earlier Train, in the midst of their deliberations! What would have been their disgust? and what must be the disgust of every sensible man, who has heard or read of these saviours of their country showing their capacity for their work by shouting themselves hoarse at the crazy periods of poor Mr. Train! Mr. Chairman, as I have already referred to this subject, which not indirectly concerns ourselves, perhaps, you will further bear with me, if I say something additional in relation to the attitude of the Irish at home and abroad to the Empire under which much the larger half of them still live, including, in that Empire, these Provinces, of course. This late exhibition of mingled knavery and folly at Philadelphia, I admit, is chiefly calculated to inspire disgust; but it also excites commiseration for the dupes, and indignation against the demagogues concerned in it. When we see how delusion at this side the Atlantic begets delusion at the other; how the astute “organizers” profit by the plunder of the confiding ignorant; when we see how the dupes who really run risks are “egged” on in Ireland to their ruin by knaves who lie up in clover on Manhattan Island; when we see Irish misery paying for a palace in Union Square; when we see the treachery that betrays the sworn brother to the outraged law,—what else can we feel but indignation against the authors of such madness, and misery, and infamy? (Cheers.) The authors of a liberation of Ireland. They liberate Ireland! Why don’t they liberate the Ireland at their own doors, from the poisonous and murderous surroundings of the tenement houses of New York and Boston. (Cheers.) Why don’t they liberate their own young Ireland from sanitary destruction—that Ireland in America, which, according to the New York Times, contributes 88 per cent. of the deaths of children, on the whole number of deaths in that great city? They liberate Ireland! Why don’t they liberate those children of a larger growth, more than fatherless, who are swept daily from among them to the far West, there to undergo the fate of changelings and apostates, among an alien people? (Cheers.) The New York Protectory, established by sane and good men to diminish the swollen volume of Irish vagrancy and juvenile crime, has asked the other day for $28,000 to carry on their work—there is a chance to liberate a part of Ireland at all events. (Cheers.) Why don’t these insatiate patriots lend a hand there where they can be of use? Why don’t they try to liberate the Irish laborers in New England, where they rank in the social scale below the negro, and hardly above the beasts they drive for their Yankee bosses? There is a work for them to do if they were only honest, and if they only tried; but I admit there is one objection to it, inseparable to the Fenian mind; it is practicable, it is possible; therefore it is avoided and despised. (Loud cheers.) “To the Banks” would be the cry of one set; “to the Convents” of the other. The hate of Cain, and the cupidity of Judas, and the lust of Belial, would be the fell inspiration of these well-sorted allies; for the objects of both would be plunder, and of all outrage. Who for a moment supposes that any man dwelling among us, buying, selling, and mingling freely with his fellow-citizens, would lend himself to such villainy? (Cheers.) I repeat for the Irish inhabitants of this section of Canada that there are no grounds for so foul a slander, and I am happy in this respect to echo the declaration of our national Society at its last monthly meeting, in the resolution proposed by our Secretary, Mr. Clarke, and seconded by Mr.—, “That the Irish Catholics of this Province, in the event of any emergency requiring their assistance, will be found in the future, as they have been in the past, ever ready and willing to defend the cause of law and order.” There was not a dissentient to that resolution, and there would not have been had it been put to the whole of the people represented by the Society. (Loud cheers.) It is well the true state of feeling should be known; nothing ought and nothing can (if the acts alone are heeded) shake our mutual confidence in each other. Let no man attempt to embody us, at any time, by sect, or class, or race, or society. (cheers). Such distinctions will and must exist, but in the presence of those who speculate on our divided interests,—of those who would be the only gainers by such divisions—let all such distinctions be buried and forgotten. (Loud cheers.) The care of Canada is no-man’s monopoly, but every man’s equal and bounden duty. In the discharge of that duty, if called upon actively to discharge it, we shall know, till it is over, neither Orangemen nor Catholics—(cheers)—nor any other distinction but one, who are, and who are not, ready to defend their country. (Enthusiastic cheers.) The Fenians in the United States, feeling in their hearts, for all their fustian about the glorious republic, that they are not, really at home there; feeling that they have not conquered for themselves a new country in the New World, may try to solace themselves with a conspiracy in lieu of a country; but the Irish in Canada, who (looking back to their small beginnings a few years ago) have already acquired so much property,—who already exercise by common consent so large a share of legitimate influence,—they have a position to guard, and guard it they will with national ardor and impetuosity. (Loud cheers.) Mr. Chairman, in holding this language I am morally certain I speak for 999 out of a thousand of all my countrymen in Canada; for all the old and known residents; for all but a handful of those who are known as skedaddlers—runaways from the first and second American draft, who would not fight for the United States when they were in it, and who would be satisfied nowhere, under any form of government that required duties to be discharged in return for rights conceded. If there are any Fenian sympathizers among us they are altogether of this class, and the Americans ought to know by this time what reliance to place upon them and their reports. (Hear, hear.) But with all due respect for our American neighbors, I think it must be admitted that the levity with which so many of their leading men have spoken of letting loose this lawless element upon these Provinces is little to their honor. (Hear, hear.) No doubt something is allowable to the exuberance of spirits consequent on escape from civil war; something, too, for the feeling that English neutrality was not fairly or fully observed on the high seas. Putting aside—but not for a moment admitting that allegation—(hear, hear)—what possible complaint can they have against Canada? Has not their government officially acknowledged the bona fide efforts of our government to enforce the laws of good neighborhood, and to prevent raids across the frontier? We know that, and they know it, and the truth is, that although so many of their leading men and organs hold the language to which we object, if the Fenians were to violate the Neutrality Act to-morrow by any public move, the United States authorities would, for their own sakes, pounce upon them at once. (Hear, hear.) It is unfair, then, I say, to us, it is unworthy of themselves, and it is cruel to those foolish Fenians as well, to hold a language they would be obliged to abandon to coquet with questions of peace and war, which they will find time enough to take up seriously when they have reconstructed their Union, and readjusted their finances. (Cheers.)— Having looked so long across the line, let me now look across the water. In the month of May last I took the liberty of explaining in Ireland the true relation of the Irish at home to Republican and Colonial America, as I had learned to know it, after twenty years’ experience. Those who hold contrary opinions, and acted on them, have had reason lately to remember, as they may yet have still greater reason to remember, my well-meant warning. I told them reliance on American national sympathy was all an idle and distempered dream, and have they not found it so? The Yankee laughs in his sleeve at all these mock Senators and Presidents and Generalissimos, fabricated in New York; he does not conceal his contempt of the whole farcial affair from his English correspondents, and precisely because he despises Irish intelligence and Irish position, he laughs and lets it go on. But let it imperil to the extent of one per cent. American credit, and see how mercilessly he will pounce down on these Irish disturbers of his commercial and political relations! But some of my good friends in Ireland and Canada, and in the United States too, who detest Fenianism as candidly as I do, are of opinion that I should have balanced the severity of my strictures at Wexford by a strenuous statement of Irish grievances, and a loud call for their redress. Now, I will be frank in saying that I recognize the existence of certain grievances as fully as they do, and I hold that they are remediable by the action of Government, and that it is to the shame of successive Imperial administrations that they have never been honestly grappled with. Ireland, at the opening of this century, coming for the first time directly under the laws of England, ought always to have been regarded and treated as a peculiar field of legislation. Some great and salutary acts in abrogation of old abuses, such as the Catholic Relief Bill of 1829, have, indeed, been passed; but except within the sphere of the corporate towns, there has been little or no reconstructive legislation applied to Ireland. Franchises were taken away from whole classes, and new franchises were bestowed on them; the Irish tariffs were assimilated to the Imperial; but the interests created under the old state of the law were neither considered nor indemnified. The Catholic Church had quasi recognition, as at Maynooth, but another Church remained the sole “established” religion, according to law; a system of education was introduced, nominally national, because in spirit, essentially anti-national; the old agrarian ulcer was neither treated nor touched; in short, a half-completed work of emancipation has left Ireland—the land of anomalies, unsettlement, and disturbance, which we still find it is in the 65th year of the Union. So far as the University question is concerned, I am glad to see that what seems at this distance a fair and reasonable proposition has been, the other day, made by Government to the Catholic Bishops,—a proposition which, for all sakes, it is to be hoped may be adopted. (Cheers.) But three or four other questions—social rather than purely political—remain to be solved, and call for some firm Minister’s hand, like Sir Robert Peel, when he undertook to repeal the Corn Laws, or to throw into market the encumberer Irish estates. As upon these other grievances, there have been abundance of Parliamentary Committees granted, but no really earnest attempt to embody into law the remedies which were recommended. I say this state of things is a reproach to the Empire, and if any of my friends can devise any national, constitutional effort, by which we can help to impress the necessity of reconstructive and remedial legislation for Ireland on the Ministers or people of the Empire at large, I will go as far as any man amongst them for that object, by those means. I would willingly be one, for instance, to lay any proper representation on behalf of Ireland, from her Majesty’s loyal subjects in British America, at the foot of the throne; and [illegible] were thought inconsistent with my official [illegible] in Canada to do so, I declare here, in the presence of my colleagues and constituents, that I would not allow that impediment to stand in the way twenty-four hours. [Loud cheers.] This, or any other common-sense course, I will be found always ready to take; but just as ready will I always be to oppose the mad and cruel councils of those who teach a misguided portion of the Irish people at home and abroad to cultivate no other politics but “undying hatred to England.” Apart from the anti-Christian blindness and guiltiness of such a popular creed, its folly alone ought to condemn it. It is dashing the earthen pot against the pot of iron; it is the weak defying the strong; it is the powerless challenging the powerful. To English reason and justice and policy, I would appeal; and there is no man living more open to reason, if you do not first provoke his pride, than the Englishman. [Cheers.] But I know full well that a rich Empire will not be bullied by a poor people; that from a first-rate power even first-rate abuse will extort nothing. I speak these words in sober earnestness to my contemporaries in Ireland and in America who have been sitting in judgment and condemning my own course, sometimes with very slender knowledge of the facts which have determined its direction. (Hear, hear.) God, He knows, the Ireland I loved in my youth is near and dear to my heart; she was a fair and radiant vision, full of the poetry and self-sacrifice of the elder time; but this Billingsgate Bellona, reeling out all dishevelled from the purlieus of New York, with blasphemy on her lips, and all uncleanness in her breast,—this shameless impostor, I resist with detestation and scorn. (Cheers.) Her manners and her morals were unknown to our fathers, and long may they remain odious and unknown in the land of our fathers. I return now, Mr. Chairman, from Irish affairs, on which I might enlarge if the occasion was proper, to conclude with the consideration of our own situation; I return to conclude with a subject which I have never lost an occasion to serve,—I mean the closer union of the British American Provinces. Only six weeks ago, Mr. Chairman, we entertained in this room above 100 of our fellow-subjects from the Maritime Provinces, who had, thanks to Mr. Ferrier and Mr. Brydges, more or less opportunity of seeing what Canada was like—what she produced—how her people lived—and how they really felt as to upholding their institutions. Among that hundred, some were new acquaintances to myself and others, but all were hailed as honored guests among us. (Cheers.) What Irishman would not regret (speaking only of the Irish portion of these visitors) not to be able to call Lynch of Halifax, and Mr. Parks of St. John, by the dear name of countrymen, in every meaning of the word? (Cheers.) I say I was proud on every account to see such men among our guests, and not less so to welcome the Donaldsons and Macfarlanes, and men of other origins who were of that party! But I was particularly pleased and proud to see the Irish of the Maritime Provinces so well represented here, because I was aware that appeals had been made to them—which ought never to have been made—to enlist all their feelings against British American Union. The Orangeism of Western Canada has been held up to them as a bugbear; the crimes and errors of the Irish Union had been artfully placed before them as a sample of what they might expect in a union with Canada. If, Mr. Chairman, those inflammatory and unfounded appeals to their hereditary prejudices had taken root, the Irish of the Maritime Provinces would at this moment have been as hostile to their fellow-countrymen in Canada as the demented Fenians of New York. But the intelligence of the Tobins and Lynches, the eloquence both of voice and pen of such men as Mr. Whelan, dissipated these clouds of prejudice, and I have every hope that that portion of the Lower Province people will be found as ready as any other to consider the merits, and to approve, on consideration, the plan of Union now before these Colonies. (Loud cheers.) Since the Maritime visitors were here, a cheering omen has reached us, in the triumphant election of Mr. Fisher for the County of York, in New Brunswick. (Cheers.) Surely, if ever, now is the time, when all British subjects in these Provinces should resolve to draw more closely the bonds of Colonial Union, so as to defeat the machinations of conspirators against us, and to demonstrate the hopelessness of attempting to force us into Annexation, either by commercial coercion, or by more violent means. (Cheers.)

Now is the time—of all others—for these Provinces to take a step in advance, in order to meet the express wishes of our Sovereign, and to avert, by a timely unanimity, all possible dangers. The text of Union is taken up for us not so much by men as by events; every thrill of the telegraphic wire gives us a reminder not to delay our Union. I speak on this subject without exaggeration when I say that in my deliberate, settled opinion, the question before all British Americans at this moment is, “Will you unite, or will you give up your country to another people and another form of government?” [Cheers.] I impeach no man’s motives who differs from us in this conviction, but while I see our situation so clearly as I do, I cannot cease to cry out, unite, unite, unite! I have been charged by anti-Unionists with saying that the late negotiations in England had brought these Provinces “to the threshold of independence” Well sir, I did use that term, in a [certain?] sense, which I explained at the moment which I used it, but which the anti-unionists have found as convenient not to take as part of the quotation. I was speaking with reference to that delegation to England last summer which resulted so much to the honor of my friend Doctor McDonald and any other honorable colleagues who are present, —and to that of Mr. Brown, whose presence from the Province to-day I sincerely regret, for I know he wished to be with us. [Cheers] I said the Queen’s Imperial Government had treated with us as a power ; that they had impressed upon us our own duties and obligations, as if we stood on the threshold of independence. And if we were ripe for that [illegible] likelihood of our repeating here at the north the experience of Texas at the South,—premature independence followed by inevitable annexation,—I do not think, if we were really anxious to go alone, that there would be any decided hostility to our doing so shown in England. But that these great Provinces should be wrested or filched from the Empire, only to be added to the extent and resources of the Republic,—only to obliterate England from this colony,—only to hasten the establishment of an exclusive continental system of trade,—this is what, I think, no patriot of any party here or “at home” cares to contemplate as the future of these Provinces. (Cheers.) There are now three North American powers (four if we include Mexico), the United States, England, and Russia. England holds still, notwithstanding all her former losses, the second place as an American power, and Russia the third. It is for the statesmen of the Empire to say whether—notwithstanding that by their net, not ours, we have ceased to be peculiarly advantageous to them—whether there are not strong motives of political strategy felt at St. Petersburg and Washington, and not unfelt at London, why they should cling to the connection for England’s sake, as well as we for ours. (Cheers.) We all desire to maintain on our side that connexion—to do our part manfully by it; but that we should do so with the best possible effect, it is essential, it seems to me, that these provinces should be placed under one general government. Without Union we cannot have the Intercolonial road, and without the road we cannot have direct intercourse with the mother country, and, without both, we are at the mercy of another government and another people. (Hear, hear.) I repeat again, all events address this question: “Will you unite, or will you give up your country to another government and another people?” Will you consider your situation and the proposed Union, not from any sectional or sectarian point of view, but, weighing all the arguments, decide for the general good?” (Hear, hear, and cheers.) The issue is made up: the question is, do we prefer, for ourselves and our children, British Connexion or Annexation: do we prefer the British system, purged of every traditional abuse; do we prefer our ample self-government, Ministerial responsibility, judicial independence, and executive stability, over and above indissoluble administrations, elective judges, and a chief magistracy turned out of that wheel of fortune called a Convention, every fourth year? (Cheers.) These are the alternatives from which it is the high and solemn privilege of this generation to choose for themselves; and I cannot for a moment conceive how any man can hesitate as to the choice he should make. Let us unite, then, to meet the express wish of our Sovereign; that we may extinguish the wild hopes of those who count on finding us a divided people, let us unite. Let us unite to draw to ourselves a larger share of the attention and the productive labor of the Old World. Let us unite, that, by the enhanced credit Union alone can give, we may undertake those enterprises which will help to keep our native population of both sexes prosperously employed at home. (Cheers.) Union has no terrors, but for bigotry and mediocrity. For the upright and true of heart it is full of promise and inspiration. [Loud cheers.] Mr. Chairman—one final word. You have dwelt in what you so generously said of me, on the good feeling and good faith which we all flatter ourselves characterize this community, and some share of which you have been good enough to accredit to me. I say sincerely that I can pretend to none but a very humble part, in that happily existing state of things. But that it may be lasting among us,—as I am sure we all heartily desire,—that it may become proverbial of all Canada, and of all British America, let each of us, in his own subdivision of society, do what is possible that the reign of mutual tolerance may be firmly established among us. Men are born divided by nations and by creeds; far be it from me to affect indifference to these natural and necessary distinctions; but surely a man may be earnest without being offensive, and honest without being overbearing. For the great and general society of which we are all members, we sacrifice something of our liberties, and something of our self-will; if, also, we sacrificed something of the passion to introduce our opinions on others, which, long indulged, hardens into intolerance, we need not on that account be the worse members of our own, particular denominations. Such, I know, are your convictions, Mr. Chairman; and such, you know to be mine; and therefore we agree so well together. If this, in your opinion, is the service in which I can be of most use to the community, all I will promise is, that never did Canadian Volunteer go more cheerfully to the front than I shall be ready to go, whenever principles may require my presence.

Hon. Messrs. JOHN A. MACDONALD, CARTIER, and GALT, replied to the toast of “Her Majesty’s Ministers”; Messrs. R. W. Scott, ex-M.P.P., J. G. [illegible], of Brantford, to that of “Our friends from a distance”; Mr. Brydges, president of “Canadian Enterprise and Progress”; and His Worship Mayor [illegible], to “The Mayor and Corporation.” [illegible] afterwards proposed the health of the Chairman, and the meeting broke up shortly before two o’clock.

Leave a Reply