“Federation”, True Witness (19 August, 1864)


Document Information

Date: 1864-08-19
By: True Witness
Citation: “The ‘Globe’ on the Federation”, True Witness (19 August, 1864)
Other formats: TBA


THE “GLOBE” ON FEDERATION.

— The Lower Canadian section of the Ministerial press is very reserved on the question of Federation. Approving of the proposed measure in general, it professes to know nothing of the particulars or of the principles upon which it is to be based ; and it contents itself with deprecating hostility to the Ministerial project, until such time at least as its details shall have been made public.

The Upper Canadian section of the Ministerial press is, on the contrary, very free spoken on the same subject. Not only does it profess to be fully acquainted with the designs of the Ministry, but these designs it proclaims to its readers, with the view of securing their sympathy for, and approbation of, the measure shortly to be laid before Parliament. We are thus somewhat confused by the contradictory and indeed irreconcilable statements laid before us by these two sections of the Ministerial press, respectively. If we are to believe the assertions of our French Canadian contemporaries supposed to express the views and sentiments of the Ministry, nothing definite as to the details or principle of the proposed constitutional changes has as yet been agreed upon ; if, on the contrary, we are to accept the utterances of the Globe upon the same subject as worthy of credit, the chief features of the Federation scheme have been already settled and mutually agreed upon by the members of the Brown-Cartier Cabinet. There is evidently an intention to deceive, on one side or the other; but we hope, and till the contrary shall have been proved we will believe, that the Lower Canadian supporters of the Ministry are the duped, and not the deceivers; that they themselves have been fooled, and are not knowingly playing the part of traitors to their country and to their Church.

For, we say it deliberately, and after mature consideration of the case—if the Globe speaks the truth, or approximates even to the truth in its enunciation of the Ministerial policy, then the Ministry, then the French Canadian members of a Cabinet that has accepted that policy, are our enemies; worthy of every epithet that has been heaped upon them by the opposition press, and their names should for ever be held in scorn and execration by Catholics, and by all who love and would fain preserve the autonomy of Lower Canada. But we hope that the Globe lies ; we trust that, to suit its own party purposes, to sustain the popularity of Mr. George Brown in Upper Canada, and to secure the sympathies of the Clear-Grits for the Coalition, it speaks, not only without authority, but in direct contradiction to facts, and to the actual sentiments of the Lower Canadian section of the Coalition Cabinet. We will not, we cannot, without proof to the contrary, and something more reliable than the mere assertions of the Globe, bring ourselves to believe that men like Sir E. Tache, and Cartier have assented to a scheme of Federation which if realised would degrade Lower Canada to the level of a mere paltry municipality : and which by leaving her subject to a government in which the enemies of her laws, her language and her religion would be omnipotent, would place her and her institutions at the mercy of men from whom it would be the height of folly to expect either mercy or justice.

We speak from memory; but if our memory fails us not, Sir E. Tache when making his Ministerial explanations in the Legislative Council, and when announcing the fact that the newly formed Cabinet had agreed upon an attempt at Federation, either of the two Canadas, or of the British North American Provinces,—assured the country that the projected Federation was to be based upon the “well understood” or “well known” principles of Federal Governments; thus naturally referring us to our neighbors of the United States, or to some existing and well known form of Federation, as a model, and giving us, indirectly, to understand, that the scheme which he and his Lower Canadian colleagues had agreed to countenance would be as favorable to the autonomy of Lower Canada, as was the Federal Union of the great American Republic to the autonomy of the several States of which it was composed. This was the natural or obvious interpretation to be put upon the words of Sir E. Tache; and from the honorable antecedents of that gentleman we are satisfied that he, at least, had no arriere pensee, and but gave honest expression to his own opinions as to the nature of the projected changes.

The Globe, however, which we may accept as the mouth-piece of Mr. George Brown, and which speaks in the name of the Ministry, as one having authority, puts the matter in a very different light. Not only is the Federation of the Canadas NOT to be based upon “well-known” or “well understood” Federal principles—such for instance as those that inspired and gave its essential character to the American Federal Union—but it is to be based upon principles directly the opposite or contradictory; and in the case of a Federation of the two Canadas, or of a Confederation of all the British North American Provinces, the system of our Southern neighbors is not only not to be followed, but is to be reversed. And this, says the Globe, is the scheme which the Ministry have mutually agreed to, and determined upon! For the sake of Lower Canada, for the honor of our public men, we do hope that the Globe‘s assertions are void of truth. Here, however, is what it says upon the subject; and earnestly, do we entreat our French Canadian contemporaries, and all who have the honor and interests of Lower Canada at heart, to carefully read, and seriously meditate upon the meaning of the passages which we are about to transcribe.

The first is from the Globe of the 1st instant, wherein the writer treats of “The Essential Difference” betwixt the American Federation, and that which according to the Globe the Brown-Cartier Administration proposes to impose upon Lower Canada. The Italics are our own :—

“The idea of t be United States constitution is that the central Government is a delegated Government, deriving its powers from the ‘sovereign’ States which go to make up the Union. The constitution provides that the President and Congress, shall have certain powers which the States have covenanted to give up to it. All others are vested in the States.”

“As we understand it, the policy of those who have taken in hand to apply the federal principle in this country is directly the reverse of that adopted by the framers of the United States constitution. They propose that the local governments shall be the delegated governments, and that the ‘sovereign’ power shall be vested in the general or Federal Government.”

This is clear and concise enough in all conscience; and shows that the Federation, or new form of Government which Mr. George Brown expects with the help of MM. Tache and Cartier to impose on us, is to be based, not upon the well-known principles of the American, or any other Federal Union, but upon principles the very reverse. With regard to the extent of the “delegated” functions which it is proposed to leave to the several local governments—(until such time at least as the “Sovereign” central government shall see fit to absorb those functions)—the Globe explicitly declares that “they”—the local governments:—

“will possess no implied power. That will attach rather to the general government.”

In other words, whilst according to the theory of the United States Constitution all powers or functions not expressly conceded to the Federal Government are reserved to the States, in the projected Canadian Federation all powers not expressly delegated to the local Government are to be understood as reserved to the central authority—an authority in which hostile Upper Canada would omnipotent. The Globe continues:—

“The list of the local powers may be long, or it may be short, but it will be complete in the sense of covering the whole extent of the local authority.—In that sense Federation will no more tend to weaken the general Government than does the existence of our municipal institutions. The township or village council has certain definite authority delegated to it; the county council in its turn has certain larger powers—quite as definite however, delegated to it. These exist subordinate to the Provincial Government, and do it an immense service in relieving it from duties which it would not be possible for it to perform properly. Why should harm arise from the extention of the same system—from the application of the service to a higher class of local questions, so to speak, which it is found that the general legislature does not manage satisfactorily.—Ib.

Whether the list of powers “delegated” to the local and subordinate Governments be long or short is a matter of no moment; for in that such powers would be merely “delegated” powers, they might, and of course in time would, be resumed in whole, or in part, by the authority delegating. But the point to which we wish to call the reader’s attention is this—That the Federation, as defined by the Globe, and according to the same authority, agreed to by the Ministry, is no Federation at all, but merely an “extension of the same system” as that under which we actually live with Representation by Population granted to U. Canada : that the principle to be applied to the local, or Provincial Governments would be, not the Federal principle at all, but the same principle as that which under our actual highly centralised form of Government is applied to those county councils, township and village councils, to which the Globe compares the future Provincial Governments, and to whose level the Ministerial scheme would reduce them. In that the system, which according to the Globe is to be applied to the local Governments of the Federated Provinces, is but “an extension of the same system” as that under which we actually have our county, township, and village councils; in that the principle to be applied to the Federation is the “same principle” as that which is applied to our existing municipal institutions—it is evident, we say, that the term Federation or Confederation is a misnomer as applied to those constitutional changes which the Globe advocates, and to which, according to the organ of Mr. George Brown, his Lower Canadian colleagues have given their assent. It is Unification, not Federation, that our enemies are preparing for us; because—and this point cannot be too often or too strongly insisted upon—the essential difference betwixt a Federal and a non-Federal or Centralised Government consists, not in the extent, but in the origin of the powers or functions exercised by the several State or local Governments. Under the Federal form, all powers exercised by the latter are inherent, not derived or delegated; but the idea of delegation from a central authority, to the local authorities, is contraditory to, and destructive of, the fundamental idea of a Federation, league, or Foedus.

Leaving this out of sight for the moment, important though it is as showing that the Ministerial Federation scheme embraces no Federation at all, but its very opposite, let us continue our quotations from Mr. Brown’s organ and mouthpiece:—

“We believe that those who have in hand the task of maturing a measure to apply the Federal principle in our country, will easily avoid the mistake which has so often been made in framing Federal constitutions. Besides having so much evidence before them of the evil of belittling the central power, they have the advantage of being under little temptation to make such a mistake. The leagues of the old world were often leagues of states which did not really want to be one country, and only united the better to resist foreign aggression. All parties in this country have been taught to regard those Provinces as destined to form one country, and will earnestly desire that any constitutional changes which may be made shall proceed upon that idea.”

This again is certainly false, in so far as Lower Canada is concerned. The wish, the determination, of every honest French Canadian is to preserve his distinctive nationality to the last; and he detests, heart and soul, that idea of fusion, or unification, upon which the entire policy of the Brown-Cartier Cabinet, as enunciated by the Globe, is based. But to continue; and here is the important passage. Having at full length explained its views of the proposed constitutional changes, the Globe declares these to be the views of the entire Ministry:—

“The Ministerial policy is to make the Federative Government the Sovereign one, and the local Government the delegated power—and there is nothing whatever to render a change from that policy necessary.”—Globe, Aug. 8th.

Now what we want to know, is this. “Are these statements of the Globe true, or false?—Is the Ministerial policy what the Globe represents it to be?” To these questions the French Canadian section of the Ministerial press, if they have any regard for the interests of their patrons, for their own honor, and the welfare of their country, are bound to give immediate, and straightforward answers. If they unfortunately keep silent, judgment must go against them by default; and we shall be compelled, however unwillingly, to believe that they are privy and consenting to the infamous scheme of the Globe for destroying the autonomy of Lower Canada; and that they and their Ministerial patrons, do most richly deserve all, and far more than all, the opprobrious epithets heaped upon them by their political opponents.

We will return to the subject as one of transcendent importance. In the meantime we hope that L’Ordre, La Presse, and other French Canadian journals will force the Ministerial press to give a clear explicit answer to the question—”Is the Ministerial policy, as stated in the Globe, that which the French Canadian members of the Coalition Ministry have agreed to CARRY OUT? Yes? or No? Is it really part of the Ministerial programme that Lower Canada, for instance, as one of the States of the projected Federation shall exercise only ‘delegated’ functions?” To these questions we insist upon a straightforward answer—Yes or No. By that answer our attitude—the attitude of every patriotic French Canadian towards the Ministry will be determined.

Leave a Reply