“HAVE WE A DICTATOR?”, Montreal Herald (16 August, 1866)


Document Information

Date: 1866-08-16
By: Montreal Herald
Citation: “HAVE WE A DICTATOR?” Montreal Herald (16 August, 1866)
Other formats: TBA


HAVE WE A DICTATOR?

—The tone assumed by the Attorney General East during the whole of the past Session, has been something very unusual in a free assembly of the representatives of the people. The unconstitutional measure permitting the Legislative Councillors to retain their seats, after their term of office has expired, is only of a piece with other acts of a like nature. Mr. Cartier’s language to men who, from their position, are certainly his equal, might not be wondered at under a despotism in which representation is but a name, but under responsible government it does excite astonishment that it was tolerated for a moment. It is evident that the Attorney General knew the material with which he had to deal, and felt that, Van Amburgh like, he had only to stamp his foot and hold up his whip and his lions—some of them to be sure being only so as far as the hide was concerned—would crouch submissively at his feet. It is not the first time a Prime Minister has had a complete ascendancy over a Parliament, obtained by means more or less discreditable, as in the case of Walpole, who held the maxim that every man has his price, and whose success appeared to prove that his belief was correct as applied to his own times at least. But this is the first time, we believe, that such audacity has been shown in openly claiming the power, and expressing the intention to use it, so as to force Parliament to pass measures, whether they wished to do so or not. Nor has Mr. Cartier confined his openly expressed contempt for the representatives of the people to the Lower House. From his seat he declared that he would compel the Upper House also to pass such measures as he condescended to bring before it. The royal boast “L’etat c’est moi,” seems to have been adopted by Mr. Cartier as his motto, and the most astounding part of the whole is, that the Upper Canadian members, to whom in former days he was the bete noire, the very incarnation of Lower Canada domination and priestly intolerance, have by their votes confirmed him in this belief. Nor did his defeat on the Lower Canada Education bill—if it was a defeat, in the sense of being contrary to his real feelings—abate his tone of arrogance. Measures neglected to the last moment, upon which there was no time left for discussion, the right of petition, the constitutional means by which the people may bring their wishes before the Legislature practically abolished, by measures being brought in and disposed of before any hint had reached the country that they were to be proposed, all these things have been done by this ultra constitutional Minister, who compelled the House to obey him by telling the members that if he kept them a month they must remain and pass all the government bills. Nay, so sure is he of his ascendancy in the new local legislature, that he pledges himself that notwithstanding the withdrawal of the Lower Canada School bill, which the Ministry could not pass even with Upper Canadian votes, it will be taken up and passed in an Assembly composed nearly altogether of those who denounced it as gross injustice. How this is to be brought about is not explained, but Mr. Cartier’s words are explicit. “As to the Lower Canada School bill,” he says, “the Protestants of Lower Canada have my word, and the same pledges given in this House will be carried out in another House. So long as I am a public man, or a political man, my word will be kept.” If he have such power, the question naturally arises, why was it not exerted to carry out in this Parliament, the pledges given so solemnly? Why did he suffer the bill to be withdrawn, so long promised, so tardily brought forward? How are we to believe that the pledge so solemnly renewed will be kept more faithfully than the original obligation, in a Parliament which will certainly not, to say the least, be more favourably inclined to the passage of such a measure. Is it already fixed that Mr. Cartier is to be the Lieutenant-Governor of Lower Canada, and does he believe that the new position will give him greater powers than he now possesses? Or does he simply mean to renew his solemn pledge, for the purpose of averting any opposition on the part of the British population of Lower Canada to his appointment? In the meantime vacant offices remaining unfilled and held out as a bait for votes, the prospect of new offices to be created under Confederation, have been skilfully made use of to preserve a majority obtained by the abnegation of the principles of a life time on the part of public men. A general election would show that the people and their representatives are not at one in their views on public matters. The late raids and the threats of further attempts have diverted public attention to a great extent from the dangerous innovations introduced in the Parliament just closed, but this has been taken advantage of in a way which will be remembered by constituencies when they shall again be appealed to.

Leave a Reply