“No title”, True Witness (14 April, 1865)
Document Information
Date: 1865-04-14
By: True Witness
Citation: “No title”, True Witness (14 April, 1865)
Other formats: TBA
The Courrier du Canada will, we hope, pardon us for endeavoring to set him right as to the opinions and policy of the TRUE WITNESS which it seems to us that he misapprehends, since he speaks of us as having opposed to the death, combattu, a l’outrance — the project of Confederation. This is incorrect.
We have, on the contrary, always been careful to pronounce no opinion on the question of Confederation, further than this: That it might very likely be the best arrangement possible; but that so long as we remained Provinces, subject to Great Britain, “Confederation” in the true sense of the word, was impossible, and unnecessary. What we have opposed then is not Confederation, which means a political partnership betwixt sovereign and independent States; but the plan and the details of a scheme of Union, adopted first by the Quebec delegates, and subsequently by our Provincial Parliament. These we have opposed; and in so doing we have but done what—before the results of the Quebec conference were made known—all the French Ministerial press, the Journal de Quebec, the Canadien, the Minerve, formally pledged themselves to do, should the Ministerial plan of Union be what it actually is.
For instance, the Journal de Quebec, of the 6th September last, and whilst all was yet uncertain as to the details of the Ministerial plan, except in so far as through his organ, the Globe, the President of the Council had been pleased to divulge these plans—the Journal de Quebec, we say, assured us: first, that the plan which the Ministry intended to bring forward and lay before the Provincial Legislature would be submitted also to the electoral body, before being sent to England for approval by the Imperial Government. The Italics are our own.
“If they—the Chambers—accept it, it will have necessarily to undergo another trial before the Electoral body, and then if it comes forth victorious from this second trial, it will be sent to London to receive Imperial sanction.”
In the second place, the Journal de Quebec solemnly pledged itself to oppose the Ministerial measure of Union, should it appear that thereby sovereign control would be given to the central over the local legislatures. Here are the words of our contemporary :—
“Were we compelled to select, we would prefer a single legislature to a central parliament and local parliaments, in case the former should have sovereign control over the others; we should be spared at least the inconvenience of an expensive tyranny. It might be despotism, but at all events it would be cheap despotism, whilst the other whilst oppressing would beggar us.”—Journal de Quebec, 6th Sept. 1864.
Now the project of Union actually laid before our Legislature by the Brown-Cartier Ministry does give sovereign control to the central, over the local legislatures; in that every act of the latter is thereby made subject to the veto of the central government, which will of course always represent the majority for the time being in the central parliament. We therefore have opposed that project, as “a despotism which whilst oppressing would beggar us;” and if by so doing we have erred, our error consists in holding to-day the same political opinions which, only six months ago, we and the Journal de Quebec held in common. We know not what arguments may have been laid before the latter to induce it to support that which it had solemnly pledged itself to resist as a “ruinous despotism;” but in that these arguments have never been made public, in that they have never reached our ears, we may, we trust, be pardoned if we have not been thereby converted.
So also the Canadien of the 26th of August, “protested energetically” against the theories of the Globe and the Gazette, which these journals, alas! only too accurately informed on the subject—assured us formed the basis of the plan agreed upon by the Brown-Cartier Ministry: and thus defining Confederation, the Canadien affirmed its resolve to oppose, even as the TRUE WITNESS has opposed, such a scheme of Union as was actually laid before our Canadian Legislature:—
“In order that there be a Confederation there must be a certain number of sovereign independent States delegating to a central government a definite portion of their rights and their power: if this order be inverted, if Sovereignty be transferred from the States, to the central authority, the independence of the one is suppressed, and the omnipotence of the other established. The local governments will become mere extended municipalities at the mercy of the central power, without any real freedom in their own affairs, and destitute of influence upon their general destinies.”—Canadien, 26th August, 1864.
What more than this has the TRUE WITNESS ever said against a scheme of Union in which Sovereignty is vested in the central authority; and by which not a definite, but an indefinite, and therefore in practice an unlimited, power is conferred upon the same central government. If in our opposition to the Ministerial scheme we have erred, we beg of the Courrier du Canada in charity to remember that it is only because we have always maintained unswerving fidelity to our principles; to the principles which but about seven months ago, we still professed in common with the Canadien and the Journal de Quebec.
Again the Minerve—not then anticipating what the Ministerial scheme would actually turn out to be—thus committed itself on the 30th of September last. The Italics are our own:—
“We are for a Confederation in which the Federal principle shall be carried out to the fullest extent.
“The Federal power shall be sovereign no doubt, but its functions will extend only over certain general questions strictly determined in the Constitution . . . “Such is the only plan of Confederation that Lower Canada will accept . . . “For no consideration will we modify our opinions upon this subject, and to sustain them we will put forth all the strength at our disposal.”—Minerve, 30th August, 1864.
Now no one will pretend that in the scheme of Union laid before the Legislature, the Federal principle is carried out or applied to its fullest extent—dans toute son etendue; seeing that an impartial critic of that scheme, like the Edinburgh Review, praises it for its strong centralising tendencies, and for the very subordinate position which it assigns to the Provincial or local governments:—
“In order to centralise authority, and to reduce as far as may be to a municipal level the local legislatures, all matters of a general character are, in addition to those enumerated in the Resolutions placed under the control of the Federal Government.”—Edinburgh Review.
Neither will any one pretend that, according to the Ministerial project of Union, the functions of the Federal Government would extend “only over certain general questions strictly determined—bien determines;” seeing that by that scheme it is provided that all matters of a general character “not especially and exclusively reserved” for the control of the local governments should be held to be subject to the central authority; or in other words, that the powers and functions of the said central government be indefinite, and undetermined, so as to embrace everything not expressly given to the local governments, which may be deemed to be of a “general character,” the central government being the judge.
If therefore the TRUE WITNESS has opposed the Ministerial plan of Union laid before the Legislature, it has but done what only six months ago the Minerve (Ministerial) pledged itself solemnly to do, with all the strength at its disposal. We may have erred; but if so, we have erred only in this: that we have been true to our principles; true to our pledged word; that we are not like a weather-cock blown about by every passing breeze; and that faithful to the promises made by the Minerve, we have refused to “modify our opinions for any consideration.”
If we recall these things it is not to condemn others, but to justify ourselves; but to show that opposition to the details of the Ministerial scheme of Union—details which when first announced to the public through the columns of the Toronto Globe and the Ministerial Gazette provoked a general cry of indignation and pledges of opposition thereunto, from the French Ministerial press—does not at all imply opposition to Confederation, or a league of sovereign and independent States, delegating to a central authority by them created, a limited and strictly defined portion of their several sovereign rights. We have not committed ourselves on the question of Confederation, but this we have done.— We have expressed a decided opinion against the details of the measure submitted by the Ministry to our Legislature, and by the latter adopted; and because that measure is in all its chief details, the very opposite or contradictory of Confederation. It is no small matter of congratulation to us that, in this hostile opinion to the Ministerial scheme, we find ourselves in perfect accord with a publicist so competent to form an intelligent opinion, so competent from his position to form an honest and independent opinion, as M. Rameau, from whom we might almost be suspected of having plagiarised, so identical with his, in every respect, are our views on the great question of the day.
And we might cite as in our favor M. de Montalembert as well as M. Rameau. According to the former, the great danger to liberty at the present day proceeds from the centralising tendencies of democracy. Wherever there is a movement towards centralisation, there, no matter what the formulas may be with which the thing is covered, there we may trace the influence and the march of the accursed spirit of democracy. And again, wherever democratic principles are in the ascendant, there there is to be seen a movement towards centralisation; so that he who is the opponent of the one, must be necessarily the opponent of the latter. Now the manifest centralising tendencies of the Ministerial scheme of Union for the British North American Provinces are insisted upon, as its most characteristic feature, by the Edinburgh Review, the great organ of the Liberal party in Great Britain; and we therefore conclude from the presence of these centralising tendencies to the essentially democratic character of the scheme itself. Hence our opposition to it; for to-day, it is neither from the monarchical nor from the aristocratic element that danger to liberty is to be apprehended, but from the preponderance of the democratic element, and the triumph of Liberalism. As we are not ashamed of our Conservatism, or ultra-Toryism if our opponents please to call it so, so neither do we in the least regret that opposition with which the Courrier du Canada reproaches us, to a scheme which had Mr. George Brown for its author, and of which the political godfathers and godmothers were the Clear-Grits of Upper Canada, and the Rouges of Lower Canada. The bantling may have been subsequently adopted by others who call themselves Conservatives; but to those who remember the terms of the Brown-Dorion Coalition it must be manifest that the real parents of the measure were as we have stated, the “Clear-Grits” and the “Rouges.”