“Quebec Correspondence of the Montreal Herald”, The Montreal Herald (25 June, 1864)


Document Information

Date: 1864-06-25
By: The Montreal Herald
Citation: “Quebec Correspondence of the Montreal Herald”, The Montreal Herald (25 June, 1864)
Other formats: TBA


QUEBEC CORRESPONDENCE OF THE MONTREAL HERALD.

Quebec, June 23, 1864.

Last evening after Mr. Brown had done speaking Messrs. Holton and Dorion addressed the House. I regret that I am unable to-day to send anything like a report of their remarks; but in brief I may say that they altogether disclaimed any pretension that the settlement of a difficulty so considerable as that which had long existed between the two sections of the Province should be prevented or postponed by any consideration of personal friendship or even past political relations. Mr. Holton especially said that he should be glad if the present arrangements should be found to answer the proposed purpose. Both gentlemen made some remarks upon the project submitted to the House; pointing ont the possible inconveniences of certain arrangements which might arise if it were carried out in its largest sense, or even with certain modifications.

There was not much speaking beside; but Mr. John Hillyard Cameron expressed his dislike to all coalitions as immoral in principle. He believed that the measure to be carried would have been more properly and constitutionally prepared, if it had been done by the Ministry as existing, or by a Ministry formed from the opposition and of a homogeneous party character. He also condemned the position of Mr. Brown as one not consistent with constitutional principle. Mr. Brown had in fact accepted an office in the Government, and he ought, according to the provisions of the constitution, to be out of that House and seeking re-election from his constituents. As it was he was really part of the Ministry, consulted by them, and aiding them with his assistance, and it was most anomalous and improper that he should not have the full responsibility of the position he occupied, and should not be bound to seek re-election.

There is another and perhaps graver breach of constitutional usage involved in the confidential memorandum submitted to the House and which is said in the same paper to have been sanctioned by the Governor-General. One of the paragraphs in this agreement binds the Governor-General, so far as his sanction to it can do so, not to dissolve the House, until the present Ministry should have met Parliament again. It is very plain that any such agreement as this, so far as it can be operative at all, binds the Crown in advance as to the mode in which it shall exercise or shall not exercise the prerogative. Now as we are still living under the British Constitution, and as we expect to live under it still in some shape or other, even after we have adopted the well understood federal system, we think it will be quite as well still to conform to the rules of that Constitution. Coalitions appear to be excellent methods of effacing all memories of the past; but it is not necessary that they should also efface the rules of the constitution, by bargains between the representative of the sovereign and his advisers.

Leave a Reply