“Legislative Assembly”, The Montreal Herald (23 June, 1864)
Document Information
Date: 1864-06-23
By: Montreal Gazette
Citation: “Legislative Assembly”, Montreal Gazette (23 June, 1864)
Other formats: TBA
LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY.
Quebec, June 22.
The Speaker took the chair at 3 o’clock.
None of the Ministry being at that hour in their places,
Hon. Mr. BROWN said that Ministerial explanations would be made here very shortly, that Ministers would be in their seats for that purpose at four o’clock, and to ask that the Speaker do leave the chair till that hour.
Hon. Mr. HOLTON thought that it was desirable that the explanation which would be given and discussions which followed, should not be separated by the six o’clock adjournment, and he considered, therefore, it would be better to adjourn till half past seven. (Cries of No, No.)
Hon. Mr. CARTER supported Mr. Holton’s view.
After a short discussion, Mr. Brown’s request was agreed to, and the Speaker left the chair till four.
The Speaker resumed the chair at 4 o’clock.
Atty.-Gen. McDONALD moved that during the remainder of the session on Thursday, Saturday and Monday there be two sittings, from 3 to 5 and from 7 till adjournment, and on every Government day two sittings, from 1 to 5, and from 7 till adjournment. Carried.
Atty.-Gen. McDONALD then said that on behalf of himself and his colleagues, he desired to lay before the House a full statement of the negotiations which, as the House was well aware, had been going on ever since the defeat of the Government on Tuesday week. To avoid misconception or mistake, a record of the proceedings, day by day, had been carefully prepared. This he proposed to read as follows:
Immediately after the defeat of the Government on Tuesday night, 14th, and on the following morning, Mr. Brown spoke to several supporters of the Administration, strongly urging that the present crisis should be utilized in settling forever the constitutional difficulties between Upper and Lower Canada, and assuring them that he was prepared to co-operate with the existing or any other Administration that would deal with this question promptly and fairly with a view to its final settlement. Messrs. Morris and Pope asked and obtained leave to communicate these conversations to Messrs. John A. McDonald and Galt. On Thursday, at 3 P.M., just before the Speaker took the chair, Mr. John A. McDonald said to Mr. Brown, while standing in the centre of the Assembly room, that he had been informed of what he, Mr. Brown, had stated. And he wished to know if he, Mr. Brown, had any objection to meet Mr. Galt, and discuss the matter with him. He replied, certainly not. Mr. Morris accordingly arranged an interview with Mr. Brown, and on Friday, 17th instant, about 1 P.M., Messrs. McDonald and Galt called on Mr. Brown at the St. Louis Hotel. Mr. Brown stated that nothing but the extreme urgency of the present crisis and the hope of settling the sectional troubles of the Province forever, could, in his opinion, justify their meeting together, with a view to common political action. Messrs. Macdonald and Galt were equally impressed with this, and stated that on that footing alone the present meeting had been invited. Mr. Brown asked in what position these gentlemen came to him, whether as deputed by the Administration, or simply as leading members of the Ministerial party. They replied they were charged by their colleagues formally to invite him and strengthening the administration, for the settlement of the sectional difficulties of Upper and Lower Canada. Mr. Brown then stated that on grounds purely personal it was quite impossible that he could be a member of any administration at present, and that even had this been otherwise, he would have conceived it highly objectionable, that parties who had been so long and so strongly opposed to each other as he and some members of the administration had been, should enter the same Cabinet. He thought the public mind would be shocked by such an arrangement, but he felt very strongly that the present crisis presented an opportunity of dealing with this question that might never occur again; both political parties had tried in turn to govern the country, but without success, and the general election only arrayed sectional majorities against each other more strongly than before. Another general election at this moment presented little hope of a much altered result, and he believed that both parties were much better prepared than they had ever been before to look the true cause of all the difficulty firmly in the face, and endeavor to settle the representation question on an equitable and permanent basis. Mr. Brown added that if the administration were prepared to do this, and would pledge themselves, clearly and publicly, to bring in a measure next Session that would be acceptable to Upper Canada, the basis to be now settled and announced to Parliament, he would heartily co-operate with them, and try to induce his friends to do so, in which he hoped to be successful to sustain them until they had an opportunity of presenting their measures next session. Mr. Macdonald replied that he considered it would be essential that Mr. Brown himself should become a member of the Cabinet, with a view to give guarantees to the Opposition and to the country, for the earnestness of the Government. Mr. Brown rejoined that other men of the Opposition could, equally with himself, give that guarantee to their party and the country, by entering the government in the event of a satisfactory basis being arrived at. He felt that his position had been such for many years as to place a greater bar in the way of his entering the government than in that of any other member of the opposition. Mr. Macdonald then said that he thought that it would be necessary that Mr. Brown himself should, in any case, be identified with the negotiations that would necessarily have to take place, and that if he did not himself enter the Cabinet, he might undertake a mission to the Lower Provinces or to England, or both, in order to identify himself with the action of the Canadian Government in carrying out the measure agreed on. It was then suggested by Mr. Brown, and agreed to, that all questions of a personal character and the necessary guarantees should be waived for the present, and the discussion conducted with the view of ascertaining if a satisfactory solution of the sectional difficulty could be agreed upon. Mr. Brown asked what the government proposed as a remedy for the injustice complained of by Upper Canada, and as a settlement of the sectional trouble? Mr. Macdonald and Mr. Galt replied that their remedy was a federal union of all the British North American Provinces, local matters being committed, and bodies and matters common to all, to a general Legislature, constituted on the well understood principals of a Federal Government. Mr. Brown rejoined that this would not be acceptable to the people of U. C., as a remedy for existing evils; that he believed that the federation of the Provinces ought to come and would come about ere long, but it had not been thoroughly considered by the people, and even were this otherwise, there were so many parties to be consulted that its adoption was uncertain and remote. Mr. Brown was then asked what his remedy was, when he stated that the measure acceptable to Upper Canada would be parliamentary reform, based on population, without regard to a separating line between Upper and Lower Canada. To this both Mr. Macdonald and Mr. Galt stated that it was impossible for them to accede, or for any government to carry such a measure, and unless a basis could be found in the federation principle suggested by the report of Mr. Brown’s committee, it did not appear to them likely that anything could be settled. After much discussion on both sides, it was found that a compromise might probably be had in the adoption of the federal principle, either for all the British North American Provinces as the larger question, or for Canada alone, with provisions for the admission of the Northern Provinces and North-Western Territory, when they should express the desire. Mr. Brown contended that the Canadian Federation should be constituted first, in order that such securities might be taken in regard to the position of Upper Canada, as would satisfy that section of the country, that in the negotiations with the Lower Canada Provinces, the interests of Upper Canada would in no case be overlooked. Further conversation ensued, but as the house for the meeting of the House had nearly arrived, an understanding was come to that the statement of negotiations was such as to warrant the hope of an ultimate understanding, and it agreed that the fact become known to Parliament, and an adjournment until Monday asked for. On Friday evening Messrs. Galt and Brown arranged for the interview next evening, at which Sir E. Tache wand Mr. Cartier would be present. On Saturday at 10 a.m., other engagements, requiring a change in the hour appointed, Messrs. McDonald and Galt called on Mr. Brown, and after further discussion then a second appointment was made for 1 P.M., when the gentlemen [named?] with Mr. Cartier met in the Provincial Secretary’s room, Sir E.P. Tache being out of town. The consideration of the steps most advisable for the final settlement of sectional difficulties was then entered up fully, and a general accord seemed to exist that as the views of Upper Canada could not be met under our present system, the remedy mush be sought in the adoption of the federal principle. Mr. Brown then requested to have the view of the Administration as expressed to him reduced to writing, for the purpose of being submitted confidentially to his friends. The following memorandum was then proposed, and having to be submitted to the Cabinet and Governor General. Mr. Brown accordingly waited on the Governor General, and on his return the memorandum approved by the Council and by the Governor General was handed to him, and another interview appointed for 6 p.m. Mr. Brown stating that he did not feel at liberty either to accept or reject the proposal without consulting with his friends:—
Confidential Memorandum.—The Government are prepared to state that immediately after the prorogation they will address themselves in the most earnest manner to the negotiation for a confederation of all B. N. A. provinces. That failing a successful issue to such negotiations, they are prepared to pledge themselves to legislation during the next session of Parliament, for the purpose of remedying existing difficulties by introducing the federal principle for Canada alone, coupled with such provisions as will permit the Maritime Provinces and the North West Territory to be hereafter incorporated in the Canadian system. That for the purpose of carrying on the negotiations and settling the details of promised legislation, a Royal Commission shall be issued composed of three members of the Government and three members of the Opposition, of whom Mr. Brown shall be one; and the Government pledge themselves to give all the influence of the Administration to secure to the said Commission the means of advancing the great object in view. That, subject to the House permitting the Government to carry through the public business, no dissolution of Parliament shall take place, but the Administration will again meet in the present House.
Shortly after 6 p. m., the same parties met at the same place, when Mr. Brown stated that without communicating the contents of the confidential paper entrusted to him he had seen a sufficient number of his friends to warrant him in expressing the belief that the bulk of his friends would as a compromise accept a measure for the federative union of Canada, with provisions for the future admission of the maritime Provinces and the North West territory. To this it was replied that the Administration could not consent to waive the larger question, but after considerable discussion an amendment to the original proposal was agreed to in the following terms subject to the approval on Monday of the Cabinet and His Excellency;
” The Government are prepared to pledge themselves to bring in a measure next session for the purpose of removing existing existing difficulties, by introducing the federal principle into Canada, coupled with each provision as will permit the maritime Provinces and the North West territory to be incorporated in the same system of Government, end the Government will seek by sending representatives to the Lower Provinces, and to England, to secure the assent of those interests which are beyond the control of our own Legislature, to such a measure as may all British North America to be united under a general Legislature based upon the federal Provinces.
Mr. Brown then stated that having answer at a basis which he believed would be generally acceptable to the great mass of his political friends, he had to add that as the proposition was so general in its terms and the measure depended so entirely on details that might finally be adopted. It was the very general feeling of his friends that securities must be given for the fairness of those details, and the good faith with which the whole movement should be [prospected?], by the introduction into the Cabinet of a fair representation of his political friends. Mr. Brown stated that he had not put this question directly to his friends, but that he perceived very clearly that this was the strong opinion of a large majority of them, and that his own personal opinion on this point to which he still adhered, was participated in by a small number. Messrs. Macdonald, Cartier and Galt replied that they had of course understood, in proposing, that Mr. Brown should enter the Government; that be would not come alone; but that the number of seats at his disposal had not been considered by their collegues. Mr. Brown was asked to state his views on this point, and he replied that the opposition were half the house, and ought to have an equal influence in the government. Messrs. Macdonald, Cartier and Galt said this was impossible, but they would see their collegues and state their views on Monday. On Monday, at 10:30 a.m., Messrs. Macdonald, Cartier and Galt called on Mr. Brown at the St. Louis Hotel, and stated that Sir E. Tache had returned to town. Mr. Brown accompanied them to the Provincial Secretary’s room, where Mr. brown having been asked to explain how he proposed to arrange equal representation n the Cabinet, replied that he desired to be understood as meaning 4 members for Upper Canada and 2 for Lower Canada, to be chosen by the opposition. In reply, Messrs. Cartier and Galt stated, that so far as related to the constitution of the cabinet for Lower Canada, they believed it already affords ample guarantee for their sincerity, and that a change in the personnel would be more likely to produce embarrassment than assistance, as the majority of the people of L. C., both French Canadian and English, had implicit confidence in their leaders, which it would not be desirable to shake in any way; that in approaching the important question of settling the sectional difficulties, it appeared to them essential that the party led by Sir E. P. Tache could have ample assurance that their interests would be protected, which, it was feared, would not be. Strengthened by the introduction into the cabinet of the Lower Canada opposition, Mr. Macdonald stated that as regards Upper Canada in his opinion the reduction to two of the number of gentlemen in the Cabinet, who represented Upper Canada would involve the withdrawal of those who now support them in the House of Assembly, but that he would be prepared for the admission into the Cabinet of three gentlemen of the Opposition, and it being ascertained that they would bring with them a support equalled to that now employed from U. C. Mr. Brown asked in what manner it was proposed should be selected, Was each party to have a carte blanche in suggesting to the head of the Government the names to be chosen, to which Mr. Macdonald replied that, as a matter of course he expected Mr. Brown to be himself a member of the administration, as affording the best, if not the only guarantee for the adhesion of his friends. That Mr. Macdonald on Mr. Brown’s giving his consent would confer with him as to the selection of Upper Canada colleagues, from both sides, who would be most acceptable to their respective friends and most likely to work harmoniously for the great
Cartier and Galt stated, that so far as related to the constitution of the cabinet for Lower Canada, they believed it already affords ample guarantee for their sincerity, and that a change in the personnel would be more likely to produce embarrassment than assistance, as the majority of the people of L. C., both French Canadian and English, had implicit confidence in their leaders, which it would not be desirable to shake in any way; that in approaching the important question of settling the sectional difficulties, it appeared to them essential that the party led by Sir E. P. Tache could have ample assurance that their interests would be protected, which, it was feared, would not be. Strengthened by the introduction into the cabinet of the Lower Canada opposition, Mr. Macdonald stated that as regards Upper Canada in his opinion the reduction to two of the number of gentlemen in the Cabinet, who represented Upper Canada would involve the withdrawal of those who now support them in the House of Assembly, but that he would be prepared for the admission into the Cabinet of three gentlemen of the Opposition, and it being ascertained that they would bring with them a support equalled to that now employed from U. C. Mr. Brown asked in what manner it was proposed should be selected, Was each party [co?] have a carte blanche in suggesting to the head of the Government the names to be chosen, to which Mr. Macdonald replied that, as a matter of course he expected Mr. Brown to be himself a member of the administration, as affording the best, if not the only guarantee for the adhesion of his friends. That Mr. Macdonald on Mr. Brown’s giving his consent would confer with him as to the selection of Upper Canada colleagues, from both sides, who would be most acceptable to their respective friends and most likely to work harmoniously for the great object, which alone could justify the arrangement proposed. Mr, Brown ten enquired what Mr. Macdonald proposed in in regard to the Upper Canada leadership. Mr. Macdonald said that as far as he was concerned he could not with propriety or without diminishing his usefulness alter his position but that he was as he had been for some time anxious to retire from this Government and would be quite ready to facilitate arrangements by doing so, of course he could not retire from the Government without Sir Etienne Tache’s consent. Mr. Brown stated that without discussing the propriety or reasonableness of the proposition, he would consult his friends and give an early reply. Tuesday the respective parties being occupied during the afternoon in consulting their friends a meeting was held at two p.m. at which were present Sir E.P. Tache, Mr. Macdonald, Mr. Cartier, Mr. Galt and Mr. Brown. Mr. Brown stated that his friends had held a meeting and approved of the course he had pursued and the basis arrived at, and authorizes him to continue the negotiations. Mr. Macdonald and Cartier also said they had received satisfactory assurances from their friends. Mr. Brown then stated that it was now for him to consider what course he should pursue. Entertaining as he will, did the strongest repugnance to accepting office. A further meeting was appointed for half-past 8 p.m., at which the details of the arrangements, [in?] case Mr. Brown and his friends accepted office, were discussed at much length. Mr- Brown contended strongly that the Government should concede a larger representation to the cabinet than 3 members. To which it was replied that the Administration believes it was quite unprobable to satisfy their own friends with a different arrangement. Mr. Brown then asked whether he could be sworn in as an Executive Councillor without department or salary. In addition to the 3 departments, offices to be filled by his friends, Mr. Macdonald replied that the principle of equality would in this case be destroyed, and he was satisfied it could not be done. Mr. Brown asked whether it was sine qua non that he should himself enter the Cabinet? To which it was replied that to secure a successful issue to the attempt to settle the sectional difficulties, it was considered that Mr. Brown’s exceptance of office was indispensable. A meeting was then appointed for the following day. On Wednesday a little after one, the same parties met, when Mr. Brown stated as his final decision that he would consent to the reconstruction of the Cabinet as proposed, but was much in doubt, as he did not wish to assume the responsibily of the Government business before the House; he preferred to leave till after the prorogation. The consideration of the acceptance of office by himself and and the two gentlemen who might be ultimately selected to enter the Administration with him. Sir E. P. Tache and Mr. McDonald thereon stated that after the prorogation they would be prepared to place three seats in the Cabinet at the disposal of Mr. Brown. (Signed,) E. P. Tache, George Brown, J. A. Macdonald, G. E. Cartier, A. T. Galt.
Atty-General CARTIER, then read a French version of the above document, and a discussion followed, which was proceeding when our report left.