“No title”, True Witness (13 September, 1864)
Document Information
Date: 1864-09-13
By: True Witness
Citation: “No title”, True Witness (13 September, 1864)
Other formats: TBA
The Toronto Globe of the 5th inst., does us the honor of addressing itself particularly to us, and as our contemporary raises an issue of fact, we will do ourselves the pleasure of replying thereunto.
The Globe, admitting the consistency of the TRUE WITNESS—which is but an act of bare justice to us—asserts that for our opposition to the proposed “constitutional changes” as defined by the Globe, and—as according to the organ of the President of the Council—agreed to by the Ministry, the TRUE WITNESS has,—
“never condescended to give particulars or to show reasons.”
To this assertion we will confine our remarks for the present; and as politely as it is possible to do so, we give the Globe to understand that his assertion is not true, and that our contemporary must know that it is not true. Unable to refute our arguments, afraid therefore to reproduce them in its columns, the Globe finds it convenient simply to deny that we have ever offered any “reasons” at all for our opposition and hostility to its measure. Our contemporary may pretend that our reasons are futile; but if so, why does he not reproduce them, and by exposing their futility, expose at the same time the TRUE WITNESS to well-merited ridicule.
But are our arguments futile? We have argued that the proposed “constitutional changes” if carried on would impose on us a Government cumbrous, unnecessary so long as we retain our dependent position, on Great Britain, and menacing to the autonomy of Lower Canada. These reasons may be very futile: but for all that, we find them urged against the plan of “Colonial Federation” by men who certainly have enjoyed in their day a reputation for statesmanship, and the power of arguing.
For instance, a person of whom perhaps Mr. George Brown may have heard, known in Canadian history as Lord Durham, thus gave his opinion of “Colonial Federation,” in his famous Report of 1839:—
“I was fully aware that a Federal Union would, in many cases produce a weak and rather cumbrous government”—Lord Durham’s Report.
The TRUE WITNESS says in its issue of the 9th instant:—
“A Federation, so long as Canada remains a British Province, would be at best useless, expensive, and cumbersome.”—True Witness, 9th Sept.
Again in his Report Lord Durham objects that in a Colony, a Federal Government would have scarce any functions to perform; since the chief functions of such a Government are, and must be performed by the Imperial authorities:
“A Colonial Federation must have, in fact, little legitimate authority or business, the greater part of the ordinary functions of a federation falling within the scope of the Imperial Legislature and Executive.”—Lord Durham’s Report.
The TRUE WITNESS arguing against the necessity of a Federal government for a Colony says:—
“In short, the Imperial Government actually discharges for us all the legitimate functions of a Federal Government.”—True Witness, 9th Sept.
Lord Durham argues against a Federal Union of Colonies because, in their case, the chief inducement, or reason for such a form of government, must, because of their dependent position, be wanting:—
“The main inducement to federation, which is the necessity of conciliating the pretentions of independent states to the maintenance of their own sovereignty, could not exist in the case of Colonial dependencies.”—Lord Durham’s Report.
The TRUE WITNESS thus argues against Federation, not in the abstract, but as applied to our particular condition, that of a British Colony or Dependency:—
“The True Witness looks upon the federation of Upper and Lower Canada at the present moment and under our actual circumstances—i.e. whilst a British Province, and whilst bound together in Legislative Union as one Province—as undesirable and indeed as morally impossible.”—True Witness, 9th inst.
One whom perhaps the Globe looks upon as a more clear sighted politician than Lord Durham, only a few years ago expressed precisely the same opinions, and used the same arguments against a federation or “central government” for British Colonies, as those expressed and used by Lord Durham in his Report of 1839, and by the TRUE WITNESS in 1864. This person, to whom we trust that the Globe will lend an attentive ear, is known in Canada as Mr. George Brown, and in 1853 this person thus expressed himself:—
“In a country which has no foreign affairs to control, it would be seen that one Legislature ought to suffice. To give Congress merely control of the tariff and post office would make it a nullity; and if the management of legal affairs, and questions pertaining to public morality were committed to it, there would be no need for local legislatures.”—Toronto Globe as quoted in Montreal Gazette of 15th instant.
Here again we find a perfect coincidence betwixt the views of the TRUE WITNESS, and those of Mr. George Brown upon the functions and necessity for a “central government,” or congress in a federation of British colonies. If then the Globe condemns our arguments as futile, or inconclusive, it passes sentence upon the President of the Council, as well as upon Lord Durham. Nor upon these merely: for other members of the actual Cabinet have also declared themselves against Colonial Federation, giving their reasons for their opposition to a joint or “central government.” The gentleman whom we are next about to quote is known as Mr. J. A. Macdonald, and in a speech delivered at London in 1860, and quoted in the Montreal Gazette of the 15th inst. he thus expressed himself:—
“If we ask ourselves what this joint authority is, we shall see how crude the idea is. Is it a legislature, or is it a bench of bishops? If it means anything, it means that Canada is to be divided into two, that there are to be two separate legislatures, but a central power. Now if the joint authority which is to govern all Canada is to legislate on all points affecting Eastern and Western Canada, why, that is what we have just now. The only difference would be that under the proposed system we would have three Parliaments, any amount of speakers, any amount of maces, one central power, and two wings, not doing anything however, because the central power if it was entrusted with real power, would do every thing. But if the real power was to be in the local government, the central one would be of no use whatever; it would be a mere figure head.” (The italics are our own.)
Our arguments may be very weak, so weak as to be no arguments at all: but to refute them, the Globe will have to refute, not merely the humble and obscure editor of the TRUE WITNESS, but Lord Durham, but Mr. J. A. Macdonald, but Mr. George Brown himself.
And the Globe will please bear in mind that the arguments of the latter against federation of Colonies are based, not upon something in the condition of the Canadas which time has changed or modified; but upon facts that are as actual and as potent to-day as they were in ’39, in ’53, and in ’60—upon the facts—1st. that the Canadas are a British Colony or Dependency; and 2nd. that the federal principle cannot be profitably applied to any such Colonies or Dependencies. There are the facts which we cite as our reasons for opposition to the scheme of “constitutional change” as defined by the Globe: and we therefore, without having the vanity to pretend that our reasons are conclusive, or indeed worth anything, insist that they are worthy of serious consideration because of the eminent men by whom they have at different times been urged—and whom we have quoted above.
One other incorrect statement of the Globe of the 5th instant we will indicate. It pretends that the opposition of the TRUE WITNESS is based upon hostility to Mr. George Brown, which is not the fact. True, Mr. G. Brown has been for years the slanderer of our Bishops, our Clergy and our Religious Sisterhoods: for years he was the uncompromising opponent of Free Education, using all his influence to maintain an unjust and immoral system of State Schoolism. True also that he, by his applause of every act of robbery and tyranny perpetrated by the Liberal Government of Piedmont against the Catholic Church approves himself to be at heart to-day what he was years ago—the enemy of that Church, of the Immaculate Spouse of Our Lord Jesus Christ. But not for this do we reject any particular measure which he advocates. No. We estimate it by its intrinsic merits, and on these alone do we condemn it.