“Should the State Teach Religion?”, True Witness (28 December, 1866)
Document Information
Date: 1866-12-28
By: True Witness
Citation: “Should the State Teach Religion?”, True Witness (28 December, 1866)
Other formats: TBA
SHOULD THE STATE TEACH RELIGION?
—That of all men, the editor of the Toronto Globe, the organ of Mr. George Brown, should answer this question in the affirmative may, at first sight seem strange, but it is true, nevertheless. Strong indeed must be the logic of facts when such a conclusion is forced upon such a man; and yet to this conclusion is the advocate of pure secularism in the public schools impelled, by the immense and daily increasing mass of petty vice, and rowdyism in Toronto.
“Any observant and intelligent man”—says the Toronto Globe of the 19th inst.,—“who has occasion to frequent the Police Court, must be forcibly struck with the existence in the city of a large class who are not eminently vicious, or who have not force of character enough to lead them to commit daring or serious crimes; but who yet are given up to the indulgence of their passions, who are so indolent and improvident, and whose moral sense is so blunted, that they are quite unfit to take care, either of themselves, or those dependent upon them, or to remain at liberty consistently with the peace and welfare of society.”
Somewhat similar is the argument of the Southern planters, who contend that, too generally, the lately emancipated negroes, even though free from “daring or serious crimes,” are so given up to the indulgence of their passions, are so indolent and improvident, and are so blunted as to their moral sense, that they are quite unfit to take care of themselves, and those dependent upon them, or to remain at liberty consistently with the peace and welfare of society. From these premises, the white planter concludes to the necessity of keeping the negro, for a time, in a state of tutelage, and compelling him to work so that he may neither be a burden upon, nor a menace to society. The Globe, from similar premises, concludes to the necessity of incarcerating these lazy, self-indulgent, and improvident members of the body politic, in reformatories or workhouses, where they may be utilized, taught habits of industry and self-control, educated “into respect for themselves and the rights of others, and reverence for the laws of God and man.”
But who is to teach reverence for the laws of God?—or in other words, religion—for it is in that reverence for, and in the obedience then accruing to the “laws of God,” that religion consists. The State, answers Mr. George Brown, shall do this; the County Councils and Municipalities—these are they who availing, themselves of the “Consolidated Statutes” of Upper Canada, Cap. 25, Sections 415, 419, are to undertake the task of educating the lazy, improvident, and vicious into reverence for the laws of God, as well as of man. Here is the plan in its details.
There are many members of the body politic, the Globe complains, who, “when not committing open offences,” that is to say offences of which human law can take cognizance, “are allowed to lead their miserable, heathenish lives, and to bring up families to perpetuate the evil.” This is the evil; the remedy is to consist in the imprisonment of these heathenish, but unfortunately prolific wretches in reformatories, workhouses, or houses of correction, in which they shall be taught reverence for the laws of God under the auspices of the City Councils, and Municipalities aforesaid.
The social machinery of Mr. George Brown is, so at first sight it seems to us, very complex, not to say cumbrous. It consists of two parts;—First of the “Common Schools,” from which all religious instruction, that is to say, teaching of reverence for the “laws of God,” is to be carefully eliminated: and then when these Godless and heathenish institutions shall have done their work, and shall have turned out their heathenish pupils into the streets, then they are to be supplemented by the House of Correction, and Work Houses, in which religion, or “reverence for the laws of God,” is to be inculcated. Would it not be better in every way, better for the pupils, better for society, cheaper and more simple, to do in the Common Schools that which Mr. George Brown proposes shall only be done in the jail? Is not prevention better than cure? and if the educating of the vicious into a reverence for the laws of God is likely to be effectual for their reformation, is it not equally probable that the same education, if imparted sooner, might have prevented their falling into vice?
And yet the scheme now propounded by the Globe is but part and parcel of the great social machine which it and the party which it represents, are bent on running, and which has for its main object proselytism, or the perversion of Catholic children: first by the heathen and purely godless system of the State Schools; these to be supplemented in due time by the more positive or active agencies of the State Reformatory.—Yes! Mr. George Brown, your plan, complex and cumbrous though it may appear, is a well considered scheme for the perversion of the poorer classes of Catholic society, whom it proposes to place at the mercy of a very unscrupulous and wealthy Protestant majority. Yes! Mr. George Brown, we can see plainly your cloven hoof. In the words of the great Western orator, “We smell a rat; we see it brewing in the storm; and we will do our best to crush it in the bud.” For put into plain English, here is the plan in its naked deformity. First, the children of poor Catholic parents are, through the operation of State-Schoolism, to be coerced into the godless common schools wherein, no doubt, their faith and morals will be corrupted; secondly, the Municipalities and County Councils which, in Upper Canada, are almost exclusively Protestant and bitterly anti-Catholic, are to be armed with power to tear from the bosoms of their families those who in consequence of a godless or heathenish education at school, lead godless and heathenish lives; and to commit them, without any positive offence having been legally proved against them, to Protestant institutions wherein they will be taught a religious system in accordance with the views of the Protestant majority. This plan, or one somewhat similar to it, has for some time been in operation in the United States; and through its instrumentality numbers of poor Irish Catholic children, whose only sin was that their parents were also poor, have been kidnapped and condemned to a fate worse than death. This, upon the plea of anticipating, or preventing crime, is the plan that Mr. George Brown is anxious to inaugurate in Upper Canada; and will succeed in inaugurating unless the Catholic laity of that section of the Province approve themselves zealous in defence of their personal liberties as British citizens, and of their rights as parents. If once we allow the civil magistrate to sentence to imprisonment those against whom no crime has been proved, there is an end to all personal liberty, to all justice, and we might as well introduce the Bastille, and lettres de cachet at once. Never, upon any pretext, should Catholics consent to arm a Protestant Executive with such tremendous power over the children of their poorer co-religionists; for, no matter what pledges given, or promises made, such power would most assuredly be wantonly abused, and prostituted to purposes of proselytism.
If—and so important is the subject that we fear not to repeat ourselves—if the teaching of “reverence for the laws of God” be effectual to reclaim from vice, much more then will it prove effectual to restrain from vice. Therefore, we argue, let that reverence be inculcated or taught in the schools established by law, and maintained out of the public funds; instead of being relegated, as the Globe proposes, to the Jail, the Work-house, and the Reformatory.
But before school-boys can be taught to “reverence the laws of God,” they must be taught what these laws are, and wherein they consist: that is to say, we must have religious dogma taught in our schools, if the pupils thereof are to be educated into a “reverence for the laws of God.” We must have the “Christian religion”—not the vague abstraction spoken of as “natural religion” taught; and since men do not yet agree as to the “laws of God,” since the Protestant will call one thing the law of God, and the Catholic will predicate the same of something else, we must have “sectarian” or distinctive religious teaching in our schools, if we are to have any positive religious teaching therein at all.
So, after all, it comes to this:—We must either abandon the godless or common school system entirely; since in schools “common” to both Catholics and Protestants no positive, dogmatic, or religious teaching of any kind whatsoever can be given, no reverence for the laws of God inculcated; or we must be content to supplement the imperfect common or non-sectarian school, by the jail, and Reformatory prison; to which, as the Globe proposes, the Councils of every city and town may have the power of “committing such persons as may be deemed expedient.” And this is what our Liberals call liberty!