“The Conference at Quebec”, True Witness (21 October, 1864)
Document Information
Date: 1864-10-21
By: True Witness
Citation: “The Conference at Quebec”, True Witness (21 October, 1864)
Other formats: TBA
THE CONFERENCE AT QUEBEC.
—The delegates from Canada, and the Lower Provinces have been in session during the past week; but as their proceedings have been conducted with closed doors nothing official has as yet been published with respect to their deliberations. Nevertheless we have had daily semi-official utterances from the Globe the organ of our Clear-Grit President of the Council, and from the Montreal Gazette, a paper generally suspected of speaking under Ministerial influences, and to whose statements therefore a quasi official importance attaches.
What we gather from these sources amounts to this: That with great unanimity the proposition that “a union of the B. N. A. Colonies is desirable,” has been adopted, but that the same unanimity does not obtain as to the nature or details of the said desirable union—the general sentiment however being strongly in favor of a Legislative or Incorporating Union, with the farce of guarantees for Lower Canada’s peculiar institutions. We also learn that the idea of a Viceroy is favorably entertained, and that it was generally admitted that the governors or executive heads of the several local governments, should be nominated by the central government. The Quebec correspondent of the Montreal Herald, writing under date 13th inst., enters more into details, and assures us that the tendency of the discussions so far, is favorable “to an adjustment of the relations between the general and local governments (if these terms are properly applied) —on such terms as to circumscribe as much as possible the powers of the latter; making them little beyond municipal Corporations for the transaction of the affairs of their respective localities.”—Montreal Herald, 15th inst.
We are the more inclined to give credit to these statements of the Herald because they tally exactly with what Mr. George Brown in the Globe of the 1st., and 8th of August last, and the Montreal Gazette repeatedly, have already told us on the same subject. The words of the Globe were at first received with incredulity and much indignation by the French Canadian press favorable to the Brown-Cartier Ministry. The Canadien, the Journal de Quebec even the Minerve, denounced such a scheme of Confederation as that which the Globe and the Gazette proclaimed as the scheme agreed upon by the Ministry, as ruinous to Lower Canada, as the extinction of her autonomy; they refused to believe that a scheme so utterly at variance with, rather contradictory of, the public declarations of Sir E. Taché had received or ever would receive the sanction of the French Canadian members of the Ministry; and the Canadien of the 26th August last concluded an indignant criticism on the statement of the Globe, that the Ministry had agreed to a plan which would make of the several local governments, little more than Municipal Corporations exercising only limited and delegated functions with the significant reminder: that though the French Canadian people had reposed a generous confidence in its political leaders, “if it be deceived its awakening will be terrible.” It is perhaps well to refer again to the article in the Canadien, as we should regret to see so much good indignation evaporate. Thus spoke then our Ministerial contemporary but a few weeks ago; and we do hope that his words may find an echo in the bosoms of all Canadians:—
“If power proceed downward from the central government to the local governments, instead of proceeding upwards from the local governments to the central government, if sovereignty is inherent in the latter instead of in the States, there will be no Confederation; there will be but one sole power delegating some of its secondary attributes to provincial municipalities, completely subject to its will, and subdued by its omnipotence.
“If Mr. Brown or others, dream of imposing on us a Legislative Union of all the Provinces, let them spare us their hypocrisies, and let them not try to make us accept a virtual Legislative Union, under the name of Confederation.”—Canadien, Aug. 26th, 1864.
Brave words these! will they be followed by as brave deeds? Time will soon show; for it is now a moral certainty, that the scheme which the Globe announced as the scheme agreed to by the Ministry; which the Montreal Gazette advocates; which the Journal de Quebec of the 6th ult. denounces as ‘an expensive tyranny, which whilst oppressing would beggar us;’ which the Courrier du Canada, the Canadien and even the Minerve unite in condemning—is the only scheme that has any chance of finding favor in the eyes of Mr. George Brown; and is one which will be imposed upon us if we do not speedily awake from our apathy, and postpone the interests of party to those of our country, and of our religion.
In the hints, or semi-official utterances as to the proceedings of the Conference, we can find no allusion to the all important question of the “Double Majority;” no information as to whether the principle is to be applied in the Canadian Legislature to any project of “constitutional changes” that the Ministry may lay before it. This question is nevertheless to Lower Canada a vital question; for if the “Double Majority” be not by the Lower Canadian section of the Ministry insisted on as a condition sine qua non, it is evident that Lower Canada is without a voice in determining her future; and that the Upper Canadians, aided by two or more votes from this Province, have it in their power to impose on us the most odious political changes, in spite of all that Lower Canadian representatives can say or do. The people of Lower Canada should see to this in time; and with one voice should call upon the Ministers whom they have honored with their confidence to take a resolute stand, no matter what the consequence, upon this vital question of the “double majority.”
The little Province of Prince Edward Island, with its 81,000 of a population, will have an absolute voice, to affirm or reject any propositions that may be made affecting its future relations with the other British North American Provinces. Is it just, will the people of this Province tolerate, that the same opportunity to determine their future shall not be given to 1,111,000 of Lower Canada, as is given to the 81,000 of Prince Edward Island?