Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Special Joint Committee of the Senate and of the House of Commons on the Constitution of Canada, 32nd Parl, 1st Sess, Index (13 February 1981)

1981-02-13 1 Comment

Document Information

Date: 1981-02-13
By: Canada (Parliament)
Citation: Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Special Joint Committee of the Senate and of the House of Commons on the Constitution of Canada, 32nd Parl, 1st Sess, Index (13 February 1981).
Other formats: Click here to view the original document (PDF).

The HTML Text Below Has Not Yet Been Edited

This document has not yet been edited for mistakes. Help us out by correcting the text and mailing it as a text file to pd@theccf.ca. Your help will make PrimaryDocuments.ca the most complete word-searchable electronic repository of documents relating to the Canadian constitution. For more information consult our Be a Contributor page.

Read the unedited text

INDEX

SPECIAL JOINT COMMITTEE ON

Constitution of Canada

SENATE
AND
HOUSE OF COMMONS

Issues 1-57 0 19804981 ‘ 1st Session 0

Joint Chairmen: Senator Harry Hays
Mr. Serge Joyal, M.P.

32nd Parliament

29973— I

INDEX

HOUSE OF COMMONS COMMITTEES-OFFICIAL REPORT

FIRST SF5SION—THIRTY-SECOND PARLIAMENT

Abbreviations: A.=Appendices. Amdt.:amendmcnt. M.=motion. S.O.=standing order.
DATES AND ISSUES
_ —19so——
Novcmber: 6th, 1; 7th, 2; 12th, 3; 13th, 4; 14th, 5; 17th, 6; 18th, 7; 19th, 8; 20th, 9; 21st. 10; 24th, 11; 25th, 12; 26th,
13; 27th. 14; 28th, 15.
December: 1st, 16; 2nd, 17; 3rd, 18; 4th, 19; 5th, 20; 8th, 2!; 9th, 22; 10th, 23; 11th, 24; 12th, 25; 15th, 26; 16th, 27;
17th, 28: 18th, 29; 19th, 30.
«-1981-
January: 5th. 31; 6th, 32; 7th, 33; 8th, 34; 9th, 35; 12th, 36; 14th, 37; 15th, 38; 16th, 39; 19th, 40; 20th, 4!; 21st,

42; 22nd, 43; 23rd, 44; 26th, 45; 27th, 46; 28th, 47; 29th, 48; 30th, 49; 31st, 50.
February: 2nd, 51; 3rd, 52; 4th, 53; 5th, 54; 6th, 55; 9th. 56; 13th, 57.

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 3

Abortion, 7:17; 9:144-5; 22:36-49; 24199-102, 108-10; 29:9-10, 13-4,
37-49, 86; 34:1 19-21, 124-7

Advisory Council on the Status of Women position, 34:l23
Badgley report, 29:41

Birth control/sex education, relationship, 22:44; 24:104, 113
Canadian Medical Association position, 24:l03-4, 113

Capital punishment, relationship, 22242-3, 49; 24:105-6; 341128-9
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints position, 29:9
Coalition for the Protection of Human Life position, 22:49
Courts interpreting, 24:lI5-6; 341119, 126; 49:16-7, 20-2, 25
Dantzcr position, 24:] 15

Enforcement difficulties, 49: 1820

Freedom of choice, organizations supporting, etc., 24:99, 114-6
Hospital staff, conscience clause, 22:41 -2; 24:107

Liberal position, 43246-8, 52

Life at conception/birth, 24:113-4; 29:11-4

Medical developments, 22:27-30, 34-5, 37; 24:l0l-3; 29:37-8, 47-8;

34:129-30
New Democratic Party position, 241107-8; 43:49-$1
Ontario Conference of Catholic Bishops position, 33:58-9, 63-5,
73-4, 86

Parliament responsibility, 24:106; 34:127; 43:46, 50; 49:13-26
Privacy, relationship, 49:17-13

Progressive Conservative position, 411101

Public attitude, 1979 Gallup poll, 24:99

Right to life, 22:25; 342124, 127

See also below Courts

Blakeney position, 14:82; 20:25-6; 30:14-5, 36-9, 56-7; 322109
Britain system. 5:20-2

Britain, Thatcher government position, 5:7; 50:31-3

Compaign Life—Canada position, 34:124.

Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police position, 14:6-7, 24
Canadian Association of Lesbians and Gay Men position, 24:35
Canadian Bar Association position, 15:7~10

Canadian Catholic School Trustees’ Association position, 19:6-7
Canadian Citizenship Federation position, 29:51-2

Canadian Civil Liberties Association position, 7:8, 24-7, 106-8:

9:133, 148-50
Canadian Committee on Learning Opportunities for Women
position, 24:62

Canadian Council on Children and Youth position, 21:30
Canadian Human Rights Commission position, 5:6-8; 5A:l-4
Canadian Jewish Congress position, 7:81-4, 101-3, 106
“Charter”, 31:9

C1yne,J.V.,position, 122100; 13:20; 14:12; 21:27

Coalition for the Protection of Human Life position, 22:26

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 11

Charter of rights—Conz, Charter of rights——ConI.

Collective/individual rights, 10:32-8, 44-5; 19:9-13, 17, 20; 20:21; International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. relationship,
24:15, 30-2, 51-2; 29:12-3, 83-4; 30:40; 32:88; 33:1 10-1, 114-5; 4:58-60; 5:14; 7:111-2; 10:9-10; 11:27-31, 35-8; 15:17-29; 17:60;
34:96-7; 35:72, 77 19:6; 21:23, 27; 22153-4; 24:45, 48: 29:62; 31:14; 36: ;41:14-5

See also Native rights Landed immigrants, affecting, 22:10
Common law rights, 7:103-5; 22:22-3; 24:105 Legal, drafting/language, 7:96-9, 102-3; 8:34-5, 42; 12:103; 22:55;
See also Native rights 32:9

Community/regional standards, 35:44-5 Legal opinion, 42:1 1

Consensus. importance, 29:31-6; 30:37-8; 32:24 Legislatures best protectors of rights, 22:11; 29:15; 33:110; 34:l67-8

Consultations with provinces, Bill C-60 of 30th Parliament, Lyon position, 38:43, 78; 50:36; 51:41, 47-8, 54
comparing, 3:52-4 MacKenzie King remarks, 50:52

Council for Yukon Indians position, 18:19-21, 32 Mckuer commission (1968) report, 12:100-l, 126-8; 22:10}

Courts interpreting, 121101-2, 123-4; 14. 3-5, 24-6, 102-3; 15:9, 21, Monarchy, affecting, 341155-6
28; 1933; 22:11, 63, 122-5′ 24:54-5; 26:33-6, 44-5, 50-1; 27:49, Moral priorities, reflecting, 33:13-4
64; 29:10, 20, 29-30, 56-7 0:38, 43; 321116, 133-5; 34:148-50, National Congress of Italian-Canadians (Quebec region) position,
167-70; 35:36; 43:17-8; 48:120; 50:66 23:8-9

Bill of Rights (1960), comparing, 7:8 New Democratic Party position, 3:27; 27:22
Judges, appointing, 22:14, 19, 22-3, 128; 24:54-5, 106: 29:17-8, See also above Enacting
24; 32:23; 34:118 Nondcrogable rights, 7:10, 109-10; 20:17-20, 26; 22:1 16-7; 32:109;
Parliamentary supremacy doctrine, 5:18-9; 7:24-6; 11:36, 43-4; 34:30; 38:46-7; 42:26-33; 43:30-4; 49:55-64
14:10-1; 21:26: 222103-5, 123; 27226-7, 63; 29:25-8, 31-2 Non-discrimination rights, see Non-discrimination rights
Browne, G.P., position, 7:16-7; 9:43 Northwest Territories, affecting, 12:69-70
Tarnopolsky position, 7:30 Nova Scotia position, 17:57-8
Remedies clause, 5:16-7; 7:99-100; 11:33; 15:20-1; 21:20; 22:20, Official languages, see Linguistic and cultural rights
107-8, 115 4:36-7, 44, 50; 29:20; 31:10-2, 19-20; 34:96-7; Official Secrets Act, relationship, 4:84-6; 5:13; 7:32
38:38-40; 4 Omissions, 8:34-5; 9:146-7; 11:35-6; 20:19-20; 22:58; 27:56; 29:81;
Federal position, 36:19 32:9
Stare decisis, 41:19-21 “Opting in” provisions, 13:16-7; 50:50-1
Supreme Court, 342117-21, 126-8 Other countries, comparing, 11:34; 13:20; 15:27; 17:89; 29213-4, 56;
See also Native rights; Non-discrimination rights; Women—-Non» 32:134
discrimination rights and see also below “Reasonable limits“ Pepin-Robarts task force position, 342152
Democratic rights, see Democratic rights Pliilosophy, “rights do not come from governments”, -1:78-80; 14:92,
Diefenbaker position, 17:41-2; 20:23-4 95-6; 322109; 33:7, 24; 41:8-10‘. 43:17

Douglas, T.C., position, 37:26 OK Preamble, 33:44-6; 40:32; 41:7-12; 42:36-45; 43:13-21
Emergency provisions, see Emergency and see below Nonderogab1e”°” Premiers position, 50:35-6, 50-4, 77; 55:12, 17-9; 56:47-8

rights Primacy of charter, 7:99; 9:1 14; 19:7; 20:20-1; 21:14; 29:20; 34:126,
Enacting 63, 75-6; 36:21
Moratorium (3 years), 9:71, 131, 138-9, 143-4; 13:51-2’ 26:31-2 Prince Edward Island position, 14:81-2
New Democratic Party proposal, 49:45-54 Progressive Conservative position, 23:54; 41 :96-9; 50:46, 79; 55:9, 17
See also Age; Disabled and handicapped; Non-discrimination Public attitude, 38:78-9
rights , -Public input, 13:12-3; 32:7-8; 34:l49-52
Provincial/municipal role, 7:60-1; 50:61 Quebec legislation, 29:57
Enforcement, 10:28, 42-3; 13:30; 15:9; 35:36 “Reasonable limits”, 3:14-5, 27-8, 77-8; 4:92; 5:8, 11-4; 7:9-10, 20,
Entrenching after patriation, 27:49, 69-71 24-7, 85-6; 9:45, 129-30, 137, 149-50; 11:32, 38; 13:10-2;
“Entrenchment”, 17:89; 33:7, 9-I3 14:12-3, 20-1; 21:17; 22:78, 106; 29:20; 30:39-40; 32:39; 33:1 10;
Entrenchment by Britain, Russell position, 34:131-6, 144, 147-8, 34:l25; 38:41-5
152, 160-6 Austin position, 22: 1 19-20
Fairweather position, 9:147-9; 21:24; 24:28-9, 32, 40: 29:16-7; 32:7; Court interpretation of charter, affecting, 5:24; 13:23; 22:105;
38:42-5; 42:34-6 34:122
See also below “Reasonable limits”, Criticisms Criticisms, 13:21; 14:10, 54, 59-60, 66; 15:78 18, 22-3; 17:10-1;
Federal position, 50:31-3 18:25; 21:6 2:32-3, 38, 53-4,115; 4243-6, 51; 25:11-3;
See also above Amdts.——CourIs and see also below “Reasonable 26:48; 27:87; 29:125, 148, 152-4; 32:10, 26; 34:78-9
limits“ Fairweather remarks, 15:29
Fundamental freedoms, 11:34; 24:1 1-6; 29:8, 25-6; 32:10; 35:45; Drafting, English/French versions, 11:33; 38:49
36:1 1; 43:55-62 Federal position, 36:11 ‘
Restricting, 24:13-4 Irwin amdt., 42:23-36
“Right to life”, 22:26, 38, 42, 47-8 Linguistic and cultural rights, affecting. 6:27~8
Fundamentaljustice, defining, 3:79; 7:20-1, 30-1, 88-9 Mackasey position, 13:18; 14:66
German-Canadian Committee on the Constitution position, National Action Committee on the Status of Women position,
26:38-40, 50-1 9:58, 63-4
Government departments, compliance, 5:25-6 Parliamentary supremacy, relationship, 7:9; 29:89
Historical background, past discrimination, 22176-7, 95; 30:7; 32:10; Ruby position, 5:23-4
34:118,151;38:11, 23-4 Symbolic importance, 42:25-6
Implementation, see below Moratorium Responsibilities, 29:52; 33:12-3
International agreements, reﬂecting, 5:7-12; 22:78, 85-6; 31:10, 14; Richardson position, 27:16-7, 31
32:7, 83-4, 128; 43:56-8; 46:129 St. Laurent position, 37:26

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

29973— 2

12 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Charter of rights-Cont.

Saskatchewan Human Rights Commission position, 20:14, 21-2;
30:35, 38; 32:132

Saskatchewan legislation, 20:18-9; 32:l28

Scrutiny clause, 411101

Statutes and regulations, tabling list of those affected, 49:43;
54:92-4

Supremacy over statute law, 3363; 54:91-4

Tarnopolsky position, 7:106; 2 . , 38:45

See also above Courts
Ukrainian Canadian Committee position, 14:53
“Undeclared rights“, 27:132
See also Native rights—Spccial status

Union nationale position, 28:34

Vancouver Peop1c’s Law School Society position, 32:15

War criminals, effect on prosecution, 2:45; 7:92; 36:12-3; 47:58-9,
62

War Measures Act, relationship, 3:28-9; 4:85; 5:13; 7:19, 107-9;
40:27-31; 41:6, 12-3,16-7;43:33-4

See also Administrative abuses; Amending
procedurc—»-Referendum—Testing-—Vancouver consensus
(1980), Opting out; Family; God; Linguistic and cultural
rights—-Courts; Mobility rights; Official languages
policy/bilingualism; Writs of assistance

Chi1dren‘s rights, 21:28-51; 22:66; 26A:1-9; 29:9
Canadian Council on Children and Youth position, 21:28, 32, 36-7,
49
See also Sexual orientation; Young offenders

Chinese Canadizms, discrimination, 5:12

Chrétien, Hon. Jean (L– -St-Maurice; Minister of Justice and
Attorney General and Minister of State for Social Development)

Abortion, 46:71; 49:18-23
Administrative abuses, 37:21
Advertising, 4:131-2; 38:87-8
Age, 38:79
Air transport, bilingualism policy, 4:135-6
Amending procedure, 36:19-20, 37-8; 52:1 1 1-3, 118-9

Federal position, 38:24-5; 52:1. 5, 121-8

Interim, 4:15, 61-3, 133-4; 52:69-70

Newfoundland-Labrador, 3:12-4

Parliamentary approval, 4:65-6

Prince Edward Island, 32803; 4:43

Referendum, 2:23; 3:21-3, 29-31, 50, 74-5; 512118-9; 53:17-20,

23-6, 33-6, 53-4
Charter of rights, affecting, 3:29-31; 4:56-7, 78; 39:15-6; 52:58
Federal position, 4:15-6; 52:13-5, 121-8
Initiating, provinces excluded, 3:61-5; 4:139-41
Rules, 4:8-9, 128-32; 36:20-1, 28-9; 38:96-9, 112-3; 39:11-4;
53:17-20, 23-6
Voting, 4:16-8, 68-71, 88-92, 127

Senate veto, 3:26-7; 4:66, 139

Unanimity, 55:11-4

Vancouver consensus (1980), 4: 1 24-5; 38: 14-6; 51:50-4;

521129-30;55:11, 14-5
Victoria formula (1971), 2:32, 44; 3:79-83; 4:36-7, 43-4, 68-72;
36:30; 38:26, 52-5, 73-5; 51:52-3, 60-1, 110-]

Wells position, 51:39, 51

Britain, legislation enabling Canadian constitutional amdt., 2137-9,
42; 3:84; 4:24-8, 32-3, 37-41, 50-3; 38:9-11, 35-6, 77-8; 50:38-40;
522120-1; 56:32
Britain, Parliament, 37:8 10, 16-8; 48:52~6; 49:62; 50:41
Capital punishment, 47 6; 49:23-4
Charter of rights, 2:45-6; 3:53-4, 60; 4:56, 59-60, 79, 84-5; 37:25-6;
38:23, 43; 49:47, 53-4, 64, 70; 51:54; 54:93-4; 55:12

“Reasonable limits”, 3:15, 27-8, 78-9; 36:1 1; 38142-8

Chrétien, Hon. Jean-Cont.
Charter of rights—Conl.
War criminals, prosecution, 2:45; 36:12-3
War Measures Act, relationship, 3:28-9; 4:85

Citizenship, 46:1 18-22

Conferences, 2:25-6, 31, 45; 51:17-8

Constitution of Canada, 2:20-50; 3:12-39, 44-50, 53-7, 60-75, 78-85;
4:7-73, 76-98, 106-16, 119-41;36:9-22, 28-3 ‘ 7:6-46 8:8-31,
35-9, 42-9, 52-1 13; 39:4-25; 45:9-12, 34-6; 4 :14, 32, 37-8, 41-3,
51-4, 64, 67-90, 94-100, 103-4, 108-22, 125-7, 131; 47:25-7,
31-5, 41-2, 47, 53-5, 58, 71, 76-8, 84-7, 91; 48:23, 26-8, 31-4, 37,
44-8, 52-6, 70-1, 74-5, 80, 85, 91-4, 103, 108-20; 49:11-2, 18-24,
28-31, 40-3, 47-56, 61-4, 70-89, 92-7, 100; 50:1 1-2, 15-7, 20,
32-4, 37-41, 79-82, 85-6; 51:14-5, 25-9, 37-9, 50-4, 60-1, 83-4,
110-1, 118-9; 52:13-5, 58, 66-70, 73-8, 81-4, 95, 99-100,111-3,
116-30; 53:17-20, 23-6, 33-7, 41-54, 58-70, 77-9, 84-7, 90-2;
54:20-3, 27-30, 33, 44-8, 60, 72-5, 84-7, 93-6, 103-8, 111; 55:7,
11-6, 21-4; 56:8, 13-4, 24, 32-3, 36-7

Consultations, 38:8-9; 50:80

Convention/precedence, 4:52-3, 94-5

Courts, 49:29-31; 56:33

Deportation, 46:11 1-21

Disabled and handicapped, 3:85; 36:31-2; 37:22-4; 39:17-8; 47:91

Equalization, 2:46; 3:23-4; 36:19; 49:72-81

Federal position, 4:106-9; 50:33

Federal-provincial relations, 3:73-4; 4:40-1

Fisheries, 54:75

House debate, closure, 56:24

Indian Act, 4:10; 54:94

1ndians,women, 3:33, 69, 85; 4:14; 49:49-51

James Bay and Northern Quebec Native Claims Settlement Act,
38:16-7

Judges, 49:52

Jurisdictions, 4:112-5; 37:15-6; 49:28; 50:80-1

Language of instruction, 2:30, 43; 3 7-8, 55, 66-7; 4:1 1, 21-2,
28-31, 60-1, 82; 36:17; 37:31-2; 38:36-9, 82-3, 107-11; 39:23-5;
48:74-5, 109-15, 118; 53:66-7

Legal rights, 4:57-8; 36:11-3, 18-9; 37:24-5; 46:32, 37-8, 41-3, 51-4,
64, 104, 125-7, 131; 47:25-7, 35, 47, 55, 58, 78

Linguistic and cultural rights, 4: 140-1; 36:15-7

Courts and legislatures, 2:27-30, 43-4, 48; 3:17-8, 55-7, 60-1;
4:22-3, 81-3, 138; 37:27-46; 38:79-81, 90-3; 48:70-1, 91-4.
103; 52:73-8, 81-4
Equality principle, 2:43; 4:32

Mackasey, Mr., references, 2:35

Mineral resources, offshore, 53:90-2

Mobility rights, 3:32, 48-9, 66; 4:120-2; 39:12-3; 46:73-90, 94-100

Monarchy, 4:67; 53:59-62

Multiculturalism, 36:18; 50:17

Native people, land claims, 38:17-8

Native rights, 3:32-4, 68-70, 84’ 4:13-4; 36:18, 32-5; 37:27;
38:19-22, 67-71; 48:78; 49:83-9, 92-7, 100; 50:82; 51:29, 83-4;
52:66-8, 115-6; 541103; 55:12

Natural resources, 2:47, 4:107; 36:35; 38:29-31, 93-5,103,106-7;
39:4-10; 53:77-9, 84-6; 54:20-3, 27-30, 33, 44-8, 60, 72-3, 84-5

Newfoundland-Labrador, 2:40; 3:71-2; 4:33-6; 38:56-66; 53:41-9

Non-discrimination rights, 36:14-5; 48:28, 31-4

Par1iamen_t, 2:33; 38:85-7

Passports, 46:74

Patriation, failure of past attempts, 2:20-1. 38; 39:20-1

Point of order, ministers, availability to Committee, 4:97-8

Political belief, 48:23, 26

Privacy, 46:67-9

Process, 38:26

Property rights, 4:86-7; 37:19-20; 45:9-I2, 34-6

Public opinion polls, 3:34-9, 44-6: 38:87; 50:81-2

Quebec, 2141; 38:11-2,25; 39:20-3;48:116-7

Note: See page I for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 13

Chrétien, Hon. Jean~—Com.
References, 2:35; 38:65; 40:4-5
See also Amending procedure——Referendum, Charter of
rights-—Senate veto; Britain-Legislation;
Committee—Witnesses, Justice minister;
Consultations—Provinces; Disabled and handicapped;
Jurisdictions; Linguistic and cultural rights—-Courts and
legislatures; Monarchy; Native rights; Newfoundland-
Labrador–Terms of union; Non-discrimination rights;
Patriation; Process; Property rights; Reso1ution—Amdts.,
Federal position; Unilateral action
Regulations, 49:40-3
Resolution to Queen, 2:20-1; 37:17
Amdts., 2:47; 4:106-7; 36:10-21, 35; 39:6-7; 46:14; 47:71, 84-7,
91; 50:20; 51:26, 53-4; 52:76; 53:47-8, 64
Drafting, 47:31-3, 41-2, 53
Federal position, reference to courts, 54:85-7
Form of final presentation, 56:8
Legal opinions, 4:50-2
New Democratic Party position, 38:75-6
“Newfoundland”, 54:104
Ryan position, 38:25
Supreme Court reference, 4:95
Title, 37:7-8; 55:21-4; 56:13-4
Retirement, 4:1 19-20
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 46:l09
Senate, 3:25; 4:25, 95; 36:38; 38:100: 52:95, 99-100; 53:51, 67
Sexual orientation, 39:17
Taxation, 38:l02
Treaty making power, 4:68
Unilateral action, 4:38-9, 76-7, 93-7, 106-10; 37: 1 1-5; 50:82;
55:12-6
Clark position, 38:12-4
Unilateral declaration of independence, 2:31
Women, 4:55-6

Christinson, Dr. Carole (Afro-Asian Foundation of Canada)
Constitution ofCanada, 32:32-42

Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, 29:13
See also Abortion; Organizalions/individuals appearing and briefs
submitted; Resolution

Churches, taxation/separation from state, 29:15, 73-4, 91-2
See also Native rights

Citizenship, 29:55-9; 43:1 17-9
See also Deportation; Language of instruction; Mobility

rights–Employment
Clark, Rt. Ilon. Charles Joseph, references, see Quebec—So1idarity
petition; Unilateral action

Clarke, Mr. Alan (The Canadian Connection)
Constitution of Canada, 32:67-71

Closure, sec 1-louse debate

Club Media of Cannda, see Committee—Witnesses:
Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs submitted;
Press / Media

Clyne, I-Ion. J.V. (Counsel, Canada West Foundation)
Constitution of Canada, 12:100-3, 109-10, 118, 124-36
References, see Charter of rights; Resolution

Coalition for the Protection of Human Life, see Abortion; Charter of
rights; Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs submitted

Coalition of Provincial Organizations for the 1-Ianclicappetl, see
Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs submitted

Cohen, Mr. Andrew (Executive Director, Canadian Council on
Children and Youth)
Constitution of Canada, 21:28-30, 34-7, 41-2, 45-51

Cohen, Mr. Max (Chairman, Selected Committee on the Constitution
of Canada of the Canadian Jewish Congress; Professor, McGill
University)

Constitution ofCanada, 7:81-91, 99-113; 34:56-100

References, 50:47

See also Amending procedure——Refercndum, Initiating;

Committee—Staff; Federal-provincial relations—1mproving:
Linguistic and cultural rights; Patriation; Proeess——De1aying;
Unilateral action

Collective bargaining, see House of Commons

Commanda, Mr. William (Algonquin Council)
Constitution of Canada, 31:7, 21

Commissioner of Official Languages, see Organizations/individuals
appearing and briefs submitted

Committee
Agenda and procedure subcommittee (steering con1mittee),.ree
Procedure and decisions of the Chair
Data, analysing, Library of Parliament collation, etc., 23:67-8:
24:59-60
Deadline, Dec. 9/80, 1:81-8; 4:53-4; 17:51-2, 62-3; 29:88-9
Epp proposal (Feb. 6/81), 7:37, 47; 8:28-9; :28, 42-3
Amdt. (Mr. Epp), 9:29, agreed to, 4
M., 9:56-7, ncgatived on recorded division, 4-5
Federation of Canadian Municipalities position, 9:22-5
Liberal position, 9:32, 53
New Democratic Party position 9:32, 47
Pinard position, 1:36; 8:26; 9:2 -8, 33-4
Senator Perreault position, 1:35-6; 7:44
Witnesses appearance affecting, 7:7-8, 32-46; 9:29-57
Feb. 10/81, extension, 8:27
Feb, 13/81, extension, 53:4
Deadline, extending, Austin proposal, 23:43, 51-2, 55, 57, 61, 64
Electronic communications, 5:5
Joint-chairmen, congratulatory remarks re, 35:78, 81
“Master of its own proceedings”, 1:33, 69; 9:53; 44:30
Members, congratulatory remarks re, 35:79-82
Members, native representation, 31:12
Proceedings
Allocation of time to each party, 42:33
Bank Act debate, comparing, 9:45
Broadcasting, 1:58-66; 2:14
Authorization, Committee responsible, Pinard Oct. 24/80
remarks, 1:51-2, 70-3
Authorization, House responsible, 1:71
Sauvé ruling, 1:74-6, 86-7
New Democratic Party position, 1:50
Progressive Conservative position, 1:48
Publicity seekers, danger, 1:49-51, 60, 63-5
Sauvé Aug. 13/80 letter to D. Smith, 1:49-54, 71-3
Senate policy, etc., 1156-7, 63
Television lighting and temperature discomforts, 1:63-5
Trudeau position, 1:47-51
See also Procedure and decisions of the Chair
Members of Parliament participation, 50:78
Procedural delays, Goldenberg accusation, 9:39-44, 52-5
Procedural delays, National Action Committee on the Status of
Women position, 9:49-50, 54
Quorum, 1:91-7; 2:7-11
Austin proposal re delay in proceedings, 2:7-1 1
House leaders discussing, W. Baker remarks, 2:] 1-5
Irwin position, 1:93

Note: See page I for Dates and Issues

14 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Committee——Coiz1. Coinmittee—Con1,
Recommendations, enforcing, 3 1 :91 -2 Witnesses-Cont.
Report to House Parti Québecois, difficulties, 1:42
In camera/open meeting, 56:52-8 Perreault (Oct. 27/80) remarks, 1:32
Interim, 1256-7, 71-4, 93 Pinard remarks, 1:32-6
Minority TCPOTL 56:56 Premiers/opposition leaders appearing, Epp correspondence,
Sittings‘ 10123301 23132» 53 referring to traffic subcommittee, etc., 28:51-5
Liberal/ND? 3Sl’°9l“”-“la 47129-30 Progressive Conservative position, 9:51
513“ Quebec representation lacking, 23:66, 70-2
C0119“ “marks 0″ F°b- 2/81 W<7150″I‘8P0’l- 52155-7 Ryan, Claude (Que. liberal leader), appearance, requesting,
Congratulatory remarks re, 30:60; 35:78, 81-2; 56:61-4 2850.5
Justice Department officials, 56:62-3 Time restrictions, 23-49.51; 27:45.7
S(£IllS(lCS,.23C49, 59; 32:29, 52, 59-62, 116-7; 35:78; 56:55 Tflldgau appearance, 50347
S“b°°m”““°°5= 15514? 85259 Vancouver People’s Law School Society appearance, 32:6-7
T_(T5‘°]d°‘(‘b,°‘;,g l”‘°i;‘;5:l41 2545578 9 See also Procedure and decisions of the Chair; Unilateral
11cresric1ons,..: -; :~ -_, -1
Travel, 1:78-91; 32:8, 100, 148 am)” F°dm1p°S”‘°”
British Columbia position, 1:89-90 Common law, see Charter of rights

Liberal position, 1:83

Mackasey position, 1137390 Communications,jurisdiction, 322102

Witnesses « it n . . , _ . . _

Afro-Asian Foundation of Canada appearance, 32:34-6 Confederation” Compact ’ HA7 8′ 2729’ 62 3′ 35$ 3

Alberta Chamber of Commerce appearance, 27:47 Connolly, Senator John J. (Ottawa West)

Alberta Chamber of Commerce/Nuu-Chah-Nultli Council, Abortion, 22:47-8

briefs, comparing, 271143-4 Amending procedure, 3:26-7; 39: 10-1: 52:26; 53:43

Alberta government absence, 33:l02, 156 Charter of rights, 34:96; 38:48;-11:19-21

Algonquin Council ai2iJearanc<=. 31:6 Constitution of Canada, 1:21, 25-6, 44-5; 240-2, 50; 3:19, 24-7;
Appearances/briefs. deadlines, Austin proposal, 23:31-40, 44, 52-3. 5:6-8;14:21-3,50; 19116-8, 21, 38-41; 22:46-8; 25118-9;

60, 65, .77-80 _ H 27:144-6′ 3495-7; 3 . 8; 39:10-I; 41:17-21; 46:43-4; 48:18;
Advertising, S. Robinson position, 23:76-80 5139; 52:23; 5343; 559.10

-Association of lroqiiois and Allied Indians appearance, 31:43 Denominaﬁonal/indcpcndanl schools’ 19;1(,_g

Blakmey ai’l’ea”3″°°i 3:561 50“1 _ _ Disabled and handicapped, 25:18-9

Bourassa, Robert (forrner Que, premier), appearance, requesting, Legal rights’ 141224; 461434

2759? 2815” ., . . ,, Native rights, 27:1-14-6
Mackasey remarks, facetious/frivolous ,28:54-7 Non_disc,.imina,i0n righm 41:17_9

B’!°.‘317-‘9~ ‘4-.9”. . . . . . Organization meeting, 1:21, 25-6, 44-5

~Bl’lllSll Columbia Civil Liberties Association appearance, 222119 Pammion 19,40

Business and labour representation lacking, 33.90 Point of Order, Witness“, 1:256

-Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police/Canadian Association
of Crown Counscls, joint appearance, 14:16-7
Canadian Association of Social Workers appearance, 291151-2

Provinces, entry into Confederation, 14:50
Resolution to Queen, drafting, 2:50
Social services, 19:38-40

Canadian Citizenship Federation appearance, 29:54, 57,61 , . .
Canadian Connection aPpcamnce_ 32:50_2 Supreme Court, Bi1lC-60 of 30th Parliament, 324-5
32
– » -« – ‘ 1 ‘ ‘ d 2 :38-49
1356’ H942 Constitution ofCana a, 9
Canadian Polish Congress appearance, 9:120-3 Conscription l”1e1.1iscite(l942), 52:25-8
Club Media of Canada appearance, 24:7-9, 19-20 See also Amending procedure—Referendum, Voting

Constitution committee (1972), comparing, 1:40
\ Denominational Education Committees of Newfoundland
appearance, 35:49-50

Consensus, 27:106-7; 30:6-9, 17-8; 34:18, 21-2, 106-7; 35:42-3
Blakcney position, 30:58-9

‘ Devine, Grant (Sask. PC leader), appearance, requesting, 28:51-3 N9W D‘5‘_”‘0°l’3ii° P379’ P°3ill_0}1» 503304
Expenses, Committee paying, 1:76-7 Progressive Conservative position, 55:7-9 _ ‘ I _
Expert, 12:89-97, 125-6; 141117-9, 124-5; 17:82; 27:73 See also Amending procedure; Charter of rights; 1-ed_er‘al-provincial
Austin proposal, 23:35, 38-41, 44, 47, 50, 60-4, 66-7, 72, 80 conferences; Patriation; Premiers; Process——1″ublic input
Laﬁresi appearance’ 34:5-7 Constitution committee (1972), 22282-4, 91, 94-6

Qualifications, 24:49; 35:13

See also Cohen; 1,aForest; Rémillard; Russell; Scott S“ “I” C°mmm°°”Wim°5seS

]l::<‘irc”;’:‘li::)‘:‘;:é’:5f;;Q§Z;‘:: 120:_’456 7 Constitution committee (1978), see Multiculturalism-Entrenching Justice Minister Chréticn appearance, 2:16 Constitutional assembly, 9:9, 13-7; 22:62, 66, 69-70; 32:8, 26-7, 55; Members of Parliament appearing, Flis letter, 1:24 34:29; 35:42.3; 41;i09-10; 51:16-7 Minislefs 3l>l)9ﬁr3nC95- 42il0 Anglican Church of Canada position, 33:23-32, 39-40

National Indian Brotherhood appearance, 16:30; 17:25-6; 27:89 Canada west Foundation proposal, 12:99, 117, 121-3, 129
Native people appearing, 1:32, 42; 142116, 119-22;15:29-30;

17;1o3.4;27;g9.go; 34;35 Constitutional reform 322102, 129-33, 141; 34:60-1
New Brunswick Human Rights Commission appearance, 11:37-8 Rémillard Position: 35i46’7

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 15

Consultations, 34:17; 35:19
Anglican Church of Canada position, 33:29
Association culturelle lranco-canadienne de la Saskatchewan,
12:12-3

Canadian Association of Crown Counsels, 14:16

Chamber of Commerce position, 8:11-2

Francophones outside Que., 13:32-3

Minority groups, 14:62

National Action Committee on the Status of Women position, 9:63
Native people, 16:6: 33:11-2, 20-1, 162, 169-71

Private sector/business community, 33:151-2

Provinces, 4:106; 14:74; 30:39-41; 33:8-9; 34:78

Chrétien position, 38:8-9; 50:80
See also Amending procedure; Natural resources–Broadbent;
Unilateral action
Public involvement, Lapierre remarks, 1:85; 13:50
See also Amending procedure; Charter of rights

Convention/precedence, 2:37-9; 4:52-3, 94-5; 12:135: 14:l0l~3;
15:24-5; 17148-9, 57; 21:43; 27:69, 142; 3015-6, 31-4; 34:8, 11-4,
22, 31-5,38-44, 47-50, 71-2, 82-4; 35:26-7, 36-7, 41; 52:42-3;
56:18-9

Cooper, Mr. Philip (Vice President, Coalition for the Protection of
Human Life)
Constitution of Canada, 22:31-3, 38-44, 47-9

Copp, Professor David (Vice President. British Columbia Civil
Liberties Association)
Constitution of Canada, 22:103-8, 112-24

Corbin, Mr. Eyntarrl (L—Madawaska-Victoria)

Abortion, 29:49

Amending procedure, 4:61-3; 19:61; 512109, 123-4; 52:114-8;
53:21-2. 28-9, 37; 54:98-9

British North America Act, 34:160

Charter of rights, 13:51-2; 42:24: 54:91

Committee

Proceedings, broadcasting, 1:64-5
Report to House, 1:56-7
Witnesses, 1:37-8; 28:56

Conferences, 51:22-3

Consensus, 34:17

Constitution of Canada, 1:1 1, 14, 18-9, 37-8, 56-7, 64-7; 3:15-8;
4160-3, 100; 7:49; 8:38 49‘ 9:28; 10:30, 44; 12:18-21; 13:19, 26,
37-41,51-2;19:61-3;22. ; 28:52, 56; 29:49, 74~5,160-1;
30:49-52; 33:76-7, 101, 111-3; 34:15-8, 157-61; 35:38-40;
37:43-4;38:35-9,110-1:41:41-3, 93; 42:24; 43:24, 52, 67, 84, 90;
44:6; 47:12, 59-60, 80, 88; 48:60, 69-70, 81-3, 95-6,121,125:
49:62, 71-2, 85, 94; 50:14-7; 51222-3, 27, 109, 123-4; 52:69-73,
114-8; 53:21-2, 28-9, 37, 66, 69, 78-9; 54:91, 96-101,110;
55:19-20; 56:17

Convention/precedence, 34:15-8

Denominational/independent schools, 29274-5

Equality rights, 47:88

Fraser, Mr., references, 52:70

Freedom of association, 43:67

House of Commons, 43:90

Language of instruction, 3116-8; 4160-1; 30:50-2; 33:76-7; 38:36-9,
110-1; 41:41~3: 48:95-6

Legal rights, 47:59-60

Linguistic and cultural rights, 1220 1; 13:37-41; 19:62-3; 29:160-1;
30:52; 34:157-61; 35:38-40; 37:43-4; 48:60, 69-70, 81-3;
52:69-73; 54:97-8

Monarchy, 53:66

Multiculturalism, 50:14-7

Natural resources, 53:78

Official languages policy, Sask., 12:18-9

Organization meeting, 1:] 1, 14, 18-9, 37-8, 56-7, 64-7

Corbin, Mr. Eymard-—CorxI.

Points of order
Agenda and procedure subcommittee, quorum. 1:14. 18
Documents, appending to minutes and evidence, 33:111

M., 332113
Documents, briefs, advertising for, M. (Mr. Irwin), and
requesting witnesses, amdt. (Mr. Nystrom), 1:37-8
Meetings, seating, etc,, acceptability, 1:67; 2:18
Members, substitutes, 43:24
Ministers availability to Committee, 4:100
Printing 5,000 copies of minutes and evidence, M. (Mr, Irwin),
1:1 1
Proceedings, radio and TV broadcasting, M. (Mr. lipp), 1:64-5
Report, interim, order of reference omitting, Committee ceasing
to exist, 1:56-7

Witnesses, hearing immediately, 13:19

References, see Language of instruction

Resolution to Queen, amdts., 43:84; 54: 101-2, 110; 55:20

Senate, 53:66

Corkery, Ms. Mary (Co-ordinator, Canadian Committee on Learning
Opportunities for Women)
Constitution of Canada, 24:60-2, 66-82

Cornelius, Mr.C1tarles (President, Association of Iroquois and Allied
Indians)
Constitution of Canada, 31:43-7, 50-6

Cﬁté, Mrs. Eva (Lv—–Rimouski)
Constitution of Canada, 21:49-51; 22:92-3

Cotler, Professor Irwitt (Canadian Jewish Congress)
Constitution o1″Canada,7:80-1,93-103, 109-12

Council for Yukon Indians, see Cltarter of rights; Native rights;
Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs submitted;
Yukon%Governmen2——-Legislative assembly

Council of National Etltnocultural Organizations of Canada, see
Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs submitted

Council of Quebec Minorities, see Organizations/individuals
appearing and briefs submitted

Council of the provinces, Alberta New Democratic Party proposal for
proportional representation, 33:104-8, 124-6
Yukon and N.W,T., affecting, 33:122~3

Courts
Bilingualistn, see Linguistic and cultural rights
Interpreting constitution, 56:32-3
See also Amending procedure~Rcferendum; Charter of rights;

Language of instruction—“Where numbers warrant”;
Reso1ution——Postponing

Legislative powers, 49:28-9, 33-6

See also Abortion; Rcso1ut1on—–Provincial reference——Supreme

Court reference

Cox, Mr. William (President, Canadian Bar Association)
Constitution of Canada, 15:4-5

Crantlall, Mrs. Esther (President, Club Media of Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 24:7-20
Criminal convictions, former, non-discrimination rights, 22:1,25-6

Crispo, Professor John (Co-ordinator Consultant, Canadians for
Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 34:10/4-12, 115

Crombie, Hon. David (PC~—Roseda1c)
Abortion, 7:17; 9:144-S; 43:45-6, 49-50; 49:17-8, 21-3

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

I6 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Cromliie, Hon. David-—Cont.
:93

Britain, 50:57-60
Capital punishment, 7:17-8; 9:144-5
Charter of rights, 2:45; 52 :78-80; 5122-5‘ 7116-8, 23-5;
9:146-8:33:24; 342147 :32;41:7-11:4 . : 1
Committee
Proceedings, broadcasting, 1:65-6
Proceedings, procedural delays, 9:41-4
Witnesses, 9: 1 20-3; 32:34~6
Conferences, 17:59
Consensus, 35:42
Constitution of Canada, 1:28, 34, 62, 65-6, 76; 2:42-6; 3:45-6;
4:6-10,75-80,101-2,116,121-2,139-41;5:22- , -7; 7:16-8,
23-5; 9:19-21, 35, 41-4, 100-1, 120-2, 144-8; 16:2 , 17:59;
19:41-3, 74-8; 32:34-8, 67-8; 33:21-4, 53-7, 78-80, 174-6;
34:46-9, 67-72, 147-9; 35:41-5, 69-70; 37:47;40:32-3;41:7-11;
43:15-21, 29-31, 38-9, 44-6, 49-50, 55-61; 46:17-8, 38-43, 64-6,
78-81,93-4,120-1,132-3:4 . -5, 49-50, 90-1; 48:60-6, 71, 80,
85-8:49:11, 17-8, 21-3, 33-5, 8-9, 56-7, 61-4, 70-4, 81;
50:57-61: 51:87-93; 52:55, 60-5, 68, 78-82
Constitutional assembly, 33:23
Convention/precedence, 34:47-9; 35:42
Courts, 49:33-5
Deportation, 46: 1 20-1
Disabled and handicapped, 37:47; 47:90-1
Emergency, public, 49:56-7, 61, 64
Equalization, 2:46; 49:70-4, 81 7
“Everyone”, 43:45-6
Family, 40:32-3; 43:57-61
Indian Act, 4:9-10
Language of instruction, 3:54-5; 6:34-7
Legal rights, 46:38-43, 132-3; 47:49-50
Linguistic and cultural rights, 2:42-4; 3:55-7; 4:139-41; 6:33; 9:21;
19:74-8; 33:78-80; 48:60-6, 71, 80, 85-8; 52:78-82
Mobility rights, 5:22-3 6:78-81, 94
Municipalities, 9:19-20
Native rights, 9:146; 16:28-9; 33:176
Natural resources, pricing, 33:175
Non-discrimination rights, 32:36-8
Organization meeting, 1:28, 34, 62, 65-6, 76
Points of order
Documents, briefs, advertising for, M, (Mr. Irwin), and
requesting witnesses, amdt. (Mr. Nystrom), 1:28
Documents, tabling, M. (Mr. Beatty), 3:45-6
Ministers, availability to Committee, 4:101-2
Proceedings, postponing, 47:12-5
Proceedings, radio and TV broadcasting, 1:28
M. (Mr. Epp), 1:65-6
Questioning of witnesses, 37:47
Witnesses, scheduling, 33:53-7
Privacy, 46:64-6
Process, 32:67-8; 33:21-2, 176; 34:67-70; 35:42; 50:59-60
Property rights, 41:10-1; 43:56-61; 46:17-8
Public opinion polls, 3:45-6
Quebec, sovereignty association referendum, 33:22
References, 52:65-6 ‘
See also Linguistic and cultural rights
Resolution to Queen, amdts., 43:21
Sexual equality, 43:29
Sexual orientation, 5:24-5
Social services, 19:41-3
Unilateral action, 4:75-7; 34:70; 35:41

, 77-8; 9:100-1; 17:59; 51:87-93; 52:60-5,

Crown liability, 40:31

Cruickshanlt, Mr. David (Vice President, Canadian Council on
Children and Youth)
Constitution ofCanada, 21:30-3, 37-49

Cuthand, Mr. Douglas (First Vice President, Federation of
Saskatchewan Indians)
Constitution of Canada, 292116-7

Cyr, Mr. Donald (Director General, La Fédération des Francophones
Hors Quebec Inc.)
Constitution of Canada, 13:39-40

Daniels, Mr. Harry (President, Native Council of Canada)
Constitution of Canada, l7:105-33

Dantzcr, Mr. Vince (PC—Okanagan North)
Constitution of Canada, 24:77-8, 115-6; 27:71, 134-5
References, see Abortion

Davidson, Mrs. Diana (President, Vancouver Peop1e’s Law School
Society) :
Constitution of Canada, 32:5-28

Davis, 1-Ion. William (Premier of Ontario), see Amending
procedure—-Referendum; Linguistic and cultural rights»-Courts {
and legislatures, Ontario; Resolution

Deaf, hearing/speech impaired, 47:84-8

de Bellefeuille, Dr, Paul (Associate Professor ot’1’ediatrics. University
of Ottawa, Alliance for Life)
Constitution of Canada, 29:37-8, 42-9

Decore, Mr. Lawrence (Chairman, Canadian Consultative Council on
Multiculturalism)
Constitution of Canada, 29:122-45

de Corneille, Mr. Roland (L–Eglinton-Lawrence)
Constitution of Canada, 22:98-9

de Jong, Mr. Simon (NDP—-Regina East)
Constitution of Canada, 8:39-43; 29123-4; 30258

Democratic rights, 7:87; 9:131; 22:21; 32:1 1-2
“Legislative assembly”, native people, affecting, 27:86
See also Elections

Denominational Education Committees of Newfoundland, see
Committee–~Witnesses; Organizations/individuals appearing and
briefs submitted; Unilateral action

Denominational/independent schools, 19:6-24; 29:66-77; 30:15-6;
33:1l4-5;34:96,156

Manitoba, “value schools”, 19:11; 33:74

Ontario Conference of Catholic Bishops position, 33:59-60, 65-9,
75-7, 81-3

See also Amending proccdure—Referendum; Freedom of religion;
Newfoundland-Labrador; Non-discrimination rights

Deportation, 46:1 10-8, 123-4
Citizenship, relationship, 46:1l8-23
New Democratic Party position, 46:1 13-4
Progressive Conservative position, 41:98

Derksen, Mr. Jim (National Co-ordinator, Coalition of Provincial
Organizations for the Handicapped)
Constitution of Canada, 12:33-43

Desantis, Miss Rita (Spokesperson, National Congress of Italian-

Canadians (Quebec Region))
Constitution of Canada, 23:8-24

Note: See page I for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 17

Desehamps, Rev. Guy (French-English Relations Officer, United
Church of Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 29:79-80, 87-9

DeVeber, Dr. Barry (Coalition for the Protection of Human Life)
Constitution of Canada, 22:28-31, 34-6, 39-49

Devine, Mr. Grant (Leader, Progressive Conservative Party of
Saskatchewan)
Constitution of Canada, 32:100-48
References, see Committee———Witnesses

Dewar, Mrs. Marion (The Canadian Connection)
Constitution of Canada, 32:47-75
References, see Canada West Foundation-—-Conference

Diefenbaker, the late Rt. Hon. J,G., references, rec Charter of rights;
Native people—Voting; Patriation-—-1’ailurc of past attempts

Dinsdale, Hon, Walter (PC-—~Brandon-Souris)
Constitution ofCanada, 10:11-3; 12:32-4

Dionne, Mr. M.A. (I.—Northumbcr1and~Miramichl)
Constitution of Canada, 35:47-8; 54:79-80

Disabled and handicapped
Chretien position, 25:10; 37:21-4, 27-8, 47; 39:16~8
Defining, 25:10, 14
Discrimination, housing, employment, etc., 10:8-9, 12-4, 16-20;
12:35-7, 41
International Year of Disabled Persons 1981, 10:10; 12:30-2
Legislation, 10:18-20; 11:41-2;12:39–40;25:8-10, 15-7
Mentally retarded, imprisomnent without due process, 10:14-6
New Democratic Party position, 47:9l~2
Non-discrimination rights, 3:85; 518-‘), 17; 10:7-12; 11:41-2;
12:26-43; 19:49: 20:19-20, 24; 2526-19; 32:21; 36:30-2; 48:45
Canadian Jewish Congress position. 12:27-8
MacGuigan remarks, 25:7-10
Moratorium, 49:45. 53
Progressive Conservative position, 41:99; 42:18-9; 47:90-2
Public buildings, access, 12:40
See also Blind; Deaf

Disabled and Handicapped (Special Joint) Committee, hearings.
interim report, 10:7, 11-4, 18; 12:26-7, 32~6,42

Disarmament, ree Atomic weapons

Discrimination, see Chinese Canadians; Disabled and handicapped;
German Canadians; Japanese Canadians; Ku Klux Klan; Native
people; Non-discrimination rights

Division of powers, see Jurisdictions
Divisions recorded, see Resolution———Constitution Act (1980)

Divisive aspects, see Amending procedure—–Referendum; Patriation;
Resolution: Unilateral action

Dominion Plehiscite Act (1942), see Conscription Plebiscite (1942)

Donahoe, Senator Richard A. (Halifax)
Constitution ofCanada, 25:15

Doran, Ms. Claire (Political adviser, Association culturelle franco-
canadienne de la Saskatchewan)
Constitution of Canada. 12:14-23

Daugherty, Ms. Joan (Chairman, Protestant School Board of Greater
Montreal)
Constitution of Canada, l1:7~24

Douglas, T.C., see Charter of rights

Driscoll, Mr. Fred (Minister of Education, Prince Edward Island)
Constitution of Canada. 142104

Drugs, trafficking, 47:65-7
Drury report, see Northwest ‘1‘erritorics

Duality/two nations, 12:1 1, 17-8, 21-2, 26; 13:27, 30, 50; 22:78-82,
92-3, 97; 26257-8; 27:25-6; 28:31; 35:17, 31-3
Native people position, 29:102; 31:59
See also Qttebec —“Nation”
Duclos, Mr. Louis (L—Montmorency; Parliamentary Secretary to
Minister‘ of External Affairs)
Constitution of Canada, 4:18-21, 132-6; 38:77-80
References, we Language of instruction; Linguistic and cultural
rights — Courts

Dumouchel, Miss Nicole (Board Member, Canadian Council on Social
Development)
Constitution of Canada, 19:28-31,34, 37,41

Dunn, Mr. William F. (Chairman of the Executive Committee,
Canadian Chamber of Commerce)
Constitution of Canada, 8:4-5

Duplé, Ms. Nicole (Advisory Council of the Status of Women)
Constitution of Canada, 9:141-6

Dupuis, Ms. Renee (Legal Counsel, Attikamek~Montagnais Council)
Constitution of Canada, 28:26-7

Durocher, Mr. Jim (Provincial Treasttt’ex’, Association of Metis and
Non~Status Indians of Saskatchewan)
Constitution of Canada, 221134

Durocher, Rev. Father Raymond (Expert Researcher, Ontario
Conference of Catholic Bishops)
Constitution of Canada, 33:65-8, 71-2, 75-6

Duthler, Mr. Gary (Director, Federation of Independent Schools in
Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 29:70-6

Eberts, Ms. Mary (Legal Counsel, Advisory Council on the Status of
Women)
Constitution of Canada, 9:125-52

Economic Rights, 29:20-1, Z4-33, 85,90
Economic union, federal primacy, 8:6-7, 21-2

Economy
Newfoundland contribution, 91801
See also Process—Timetable; Unilateral action

Education

Adult, access, 24:61-82

Curriculum proposals, 1 1122-3

Equalization grants, 11:15-6, 25-6

Jttrisdiction,38:1l1

Official languages policy, second and minority language, 1 119-10,

13; 19:79-80; 27:53
1’enetanguishcne,Ont., French high school, 4:29-30; 13:29;
39:24-5

Quebec anglophones, 11:16; 23:14
See also Language of instruction

See also Denominational/independent schools; Native people;

Sexual orientation

Elections, 3:80-90
Voting, see Native people

Electricity, see Natural resources»—-Irlydro——’l‘axation

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

18 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Elton, Mr. David (Research Director, Canada West Foundation)
Constitution ofCanada, 121106-8, 121-3, 128-32

Emergency, public, declaration by Parliament, 7:87, 100-3, 109-10;
8:34; 9:130; 11:30-1, 38-9; 22:53, 106, 120-1; 40:27-9; 49:55-64

Employment, see Disabled and handicapped

Energy policy, 34:73-4, 103
Constitutional change, relationship, 332148-50; 34:102-3, 109-11

Environment, 24:91-5; 26:30; 32:11; 49:65-71

EPP. Hon. Jake (PC—Provencl1et’)
Abortion, 22:45-6; 29:11; 33:73-4; 41:101; 43:43-4, 52
Affirmative action, 48:40-1
Alberta, government constitution paper, 33:112
Amending procedure, 14:144; 16:20; 17:34; 20:19; 27:122; 30:18-21;
332180; 52:1 19-21
Interim, 51:30; 52:109’
Referendum, 27:24-5; 38:95-7; 41:95-6; 52:125-8; 53:22-5, 33
Toronto formula, 33:130-1
Vancouver consensus (1980), 38:14-5, 27-8; 41:105-11, 123-4;
51:33-8; 55:8-9
Victoria formula (1971), 3:79-83; 4:68-75; 51:32-7, 103-9, 113
“Apprehcnded”/“imminent”, 43:93
_Britain, legislation enabling Canadian constitutional amdt., 2:36-7;
48:51, 50:28-30, 83-4
Capital punishment, 41 :101
Charter of rights, 5:1 1-3; 20:25-6; 29:83; 33:44-6; 34:136; 41:96-9;
42:36-41; 55:9; 56:42-3
Citizenship, 43:118
Committee
Data, 24:59-60
Deadline, 7:27, 47; 9:27-8; 17:62; 23:33-5
“Master of its own proceedings”, 1:33
Proceedings, broadcasting, 1:47-23, 55, 70-1
Quorum, 1:92-3; 2:8-12
Sitting, 10:29-30; 47:29-30
Staff, 56:61-2
Travel, 1:78
Witnesses, 1:27, 32-3; 732-7, 49; 12:89-90, 94, 97; 14:1 17-21;
23:35, 39-40, 77-8; 2 1-2, 55-6; 32:59; 34:5
Conferences, 12:72; 14:42; 32227-8; 51212, 15-7, 24-8
Consensus, 34:106-7; 55:7-9
Constitution of Canada, 1:11-6, 20, 26-7, 2-3, 46-8, 55, 68-71,
76-8, 92-6; 2:8-9, 12, 18, 36-9; 3: 1- , 43-4, 79-83, 8 4:53 4
7 8

3
1 – .
68-75, 99, 103-5, 141; 5:5, 11-3. 2 – ;6:8-9,15-9,41;7:32-7,
8:10-4, 19, 24-5, 29, 49; :25 8,50, 54, 101-2, 111-3;
10:5-6, 29-30; 12:44, 52-3, 71-4, 89-90, 94, 97, 125, 135;
14:42-4, 50, 69-70, 117-21; 15:30; 16:18-21, 30; 17:21, 25, 31-4,
50,62 81-2, 91-4, 104, 116-9; 18:20-2; 19:19-20; 20:20, 25-6;
22:45 97, 135 8‘ 23:31-42, 45, 63, 73-81; 24:29-32, 59-60,
89-91, 25:14; 26:21-4, 53-4; 27:24-5, 89-93, 122-3; 28:51-2, 55-6;
29:11, 82-5, 94-5, 119-20, 143-4; 30:18-22, 59-60; 31:5, 47-9,
75-8, 82; 32127-8, 45-6, 59, 142 3:15-6, 44-6, 51-2, 57, 73-5,
100-1,112-3,128-31,179-81:3 . 6, 49, 63,106-9, 134-7;
35:30, 70-1; 36:5-9; 3725-6, 35, 39; 38:14-5, 27-32, 93-7, 104-5;
41:92-111, 115-7, 123-5; 42:9-12, 19-25, 36-41, 45; 43:18-20, 28,
32-9, 43-4, 52, 55, 69-70, 88-9, 92-3, 96-100, 116-8, 124-6;
44:24; 45:8, 15-6, 19, 28, 33; 46:12-3, 58-61, 65-6, 71-8, 99-101,
117-20; 47:25-30, 47-8, 52, 55-8, 71-2, 75-6, 89, 92; 48:32,
35-41, 45, 49-54, 59-62, 72, 77-9, 89, 109-11, 123; 49:82-9, 92-3,
99; 50:10-2, 20-30, 68-9, 82-5; 51:12, 15-7, 22-39, 54, 102-13;
52:87, 92-3, 109, 115, 119-21, 125-8; 53:18, 22-5, 32-7, 41-2, 50,
54-60, 64-5, 70-1, 77, 82-7, 92, 96; 54:43-5, 58 69, 76-8,
87-90, 95-6, 103-5,109, 112-3, 127-33; 55: 9; 56:41-7, 50-1,
55-6, 59-62
Constitutional assembly, 4l:109-10

Epp, Hon. Jake—Cont.
Consultations, 8:11
Convention/precedence, 2:37
Denominational/independent schools, 19:19-20; 33274-5
Deportation, 46:117-20
Disabled and handicapped, 41:99
Duality/two nations, 22:97
Elections, 43:88-9
“Everyone”, 43143-4, 52
Federalism, 17:31
Freedom of association, 43:69-70
Freedom of conscience, 12:49-51
Freedom of information, 41:98
God, 29:82-3; 42:38; 43:18-20
Immigration, refugees, 29:84-5
Jurisdictions, 2:38-9; 50:83-4
Language of instruction, 6:17, 69-70; 41:99-100, 106; 482110-1
Legal rights, 41:100-1; 47:25-7, 55-6, 71-2, 75-6
Linguistic and cultural rights, 6:15-9; 22:97; 37:39; 48:72, 77-9
Mackasey, Mr., references, 54:128-9
Mineral resources, offshore, 54: 6-8
Mobility rights, 8:12-4: 12:74; 43:124-6; 46:73-8, 101
Monarchy, 53\55-7, 64-5
Multiculturalism, 9:112-3; 14:70; 26:53-4′ 29:143-4; 50:10-2
Native rights, 16:19-21; 17:91 4; 222135 ’26:21-4; 27:89-93;
31:47-9, 75-8, 82; 34:63; 49:87-8, 9
Natural resources, 24:89-90; 321142-3; 38:28-32, 93-5; 53:82-6;
54:43-5, 69, 87-90
Newfoundland-Labrador, 41:124-5; 53:41-2
Non-discrimination rights, 29:11; 48:45
Northwest Territories, 12:72-3 _
Organization meeting, 1:11-6, 20, 26-7, 32-3, 46-8, 55, 68-71, 76-8,
92-6; 2:8-9, 12, 18

Passports, 46:74
Points of order

Adjournment, M., 56:50-1

Agenda and procedure subcommittee, 1:13; 48:49-50, 59

Amdts., 48:35-9; 53:35-6

Tabling, time limit, 54:58-9
Documents, appending to minutes and evidence, 33:112-3
Ms.,17:21;33:113
Documents, briefs, advertising for, M: (Mr. Irwin), and
requesting witnesses, amdt. (Mr. Nystrom), 1:27, 32-3
McGrath privilege, 45215-6, 19, 28, 33
Meetings
Adjourning, 12:44; 29:94-5
Extending hours, 30:59
Scheduling, 6:8-9; 36:5-9
While constitutional discussions being held, 32:44-6
Member of House not Committee member, 1:20; 6:41
Members, official record not updated, registration with Whip
sufficient to maintain eligibility, 1:15-6

Members remarks, 27:122-3

Ministers, availability to Committee, 4:99, 103-5; 42:9-10

Minutes and evidence, availability, 5:5-6

Printing 5,000 copies of minutes and evidence, M. (Mr. Irwin),

1:1 1-2
Proceedings, radio and TV broadcasting, 1:32; 31:5
M., 1:47-8, 55, 70-1
Questioning ofwitnesscs, 3:11, 19; 8:19; 292119-21; 31:15; 35:30;
42:1 1-2
Time limit, 50:68-9
Quorum, official opposition, including, M. (Mr. Beatty), 1:92-3;
2:8-10
Reports to both Houses, draft consideration, in camera meeting,
M. (Mr. S. Robinson), 56:55-6

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 19

Epp, Hon. JakeAConz.

Points of order——Co/zl.

Reports to both Houses, draft consideration, in camera meeting,

staff, 56:60-1
Travel, M., 1:78
Witnesses
Appearance before Committee, 7:32-7; 8:24-5, 29; 9:25-23, 54,
101-2. 111-2
Experts, requesting, M., 12:89-90, 94, 97
Invitation by political party, implied affiliation, 33:15-6, 51-2
Expenses, Committee paying, M., 1:76-7
Participation in points of order, 3:43
Scheduling, 33:57
Statements, 332100-1

Privacy, 46:66
Process, 34:135; 50:25-7; 56:44-6
Progressive Conservative constitution position, 31:93; 53:96; 56:41-7
Property rights, 9:113; 41:98; 45:15-6; 46:12; 56:43-4
Provinces, entry into Confederation, 14:43
Public opinion polls, 23:36-7
Quebec, 34:108; 541127-8
References, 23:46; 31:53

See also Amending procedure-Victoria formula (1971);

Committee—Deadline—Witnesses; Natural
resources-—Broadbent proposal; Resolution~
“Newfoundland”-Provincial referral; Yukon
Territory—-Government, Legitimacy
Resolution to Queen, 17:33; 23:35-9; 34:106; 38:27-32, 95, 104-5;
41:92-103, 115-7

Amdts., 42:21-5; 43:20, 28, 34-9; 46:12-3; 47:47-8

“Newfoundland”, 542103-5

Provincial referral, 50:20-2, 25-7
Retirement, 5:12
Robinson, Mr. S., references, 52:92-3
Scott, Rev. Edward W., references, 33:16
Senate, 41:96; 52:92-3; 53:50
Sexual orientation, 24:29-32
Trudeau, constitution position, 541128-31
Unilateral action, 8:11; 17:34; 33:l28-30, 181; 34:136-7; 54:132-3
Western provinces, 34:107-8
Yukon Territory, 14:42-4; 18:20-3

Equality rights, 47:88
See also Non-discrimination rights

Equalization, 8:7-8, 24; 27:49; 29:23-4, 81; 30:14; 32:103-6, 112-5,
129; 34:143: 49:78-80

Alberta Chamber of Commerce position, 27:36

Alberta New Democratic Party position, 33:103-4

Amdts., 2:46; 49:65-81

British Columbia position, 49:77

Defining, 3:23-4; 14:83-5; 15:21; 17145-6, 52; 19:49, 81-2
Minimum standards, 8:8, 16-7

Nova Scotia position, 17:43-6

Payments directly to provinces, 9:83, 88-9; 19:81; 27:51; 32:1 18-9;

49:71-81
Bennett position, 19:63
Federal position, 36:19

Payments, excluded from federal proposal, 8:17-8
Saskatchewan position, 49:81-2

Social services, 19:36-7; 49265-9, 73

Euthanasia, rec Freedom of conscience

“Everyone”, 7:18, 89′ 9:61, 131, 140-1, 144-5; 12:55; 19:14-5, 27;
21:25.40-1.44 , 2:54; 24:54, 115; 33:63; 43:39-55; 44:6-12,21,
25; 46:15, 105; 47.30-1, 78-9

Abortion/right to life, affecting, 22:26-7, 31, 36, 43, 48; 29:38, 45;
34:122-5: 46:70-1; 48:18, 21

“Everyone”——Com.
Press/media, freedom of speech, affecting, 24:11-2

Ewaschuk, Mr. E:G. (Director of Criminal Law, Amendments
Section, Justice Department)
Constitution of Canada, 46:136; 47:22-5, 32-3, 37-9, 44, 47, 55-6,
61-8, 71-2, 75-82, 85-6, 123-4

Expropriation, see Native rights; Property rights

Fairweather, Mr. Gordon L. (Chief Commissioner, Canadian Human
Rights Commission)
Constitution of Canada, 5:6-28
References, see Affirmative action; Charter of rights;
Committee—Witnesses

Family
Charter of rights including reference, 40232-3; 41 :7-8, 11
Progressive Conservative position, 43:56
See also Non-discrimination rights

Fathers of Confederation, see Federalism

Federal position, 50:33, 49; 51:54-7

Press/media influence, 56:39

See also Affirmative action; Amending procedure; Charter of rights;
C0mmittee~Witnesses; Equalization—Payments;
Justice–Legal aid; Language of instruction; Legal rights:
Linguistic and cultural rights; Mineral resources—Offshore
jurisdiction; Multicu1tura1ism—Entrencl1ing; Native rights;
Natural resources—-Broadbent; Property rights; Public opinion
polls——Gallup; Quebec—Sovereignty association; Resolution;
Unilateral action I

Federal-provincial conferences
Consensus, 17:36-7
Federalism, relationship, 51:18-9
Native people participation. 16:7-8, 15-6, 29; 17210-1, 107-10, 114;
27:51-2, 80-1, 84, 90-1; 51:22-4, 28-9
Native rights, priority, 31:53, 88-9
Ottawa, June 9/80, press release, changed wording re September
deadline, 2225-6, 31, 44-5
Ottawa, Sept. 8-12/80
Failure, effects, 28:47-8; 32:58; 34:78; 35:12
Memorandum no. 800-14058, see Linguistic and cultural
rights—Courts and legislatures
Premiers, consensus, 14:76-7; 17:30; 28:37
Public attitude, opinion polls, 32:25-8
See also Amending procedure—Referendum, “Dead1ock”
Permanent, 27:36, 59-60; 51:11-5
Progressive Conservative position, 51:21
Re-convening, 14:112; 17:30, 48-50, 59: 30:44
Representation, broadening, NDP proposal, 51:17-20
Victoria, June 1971, 2:44
See also Linguistic and cultural rights——Courts and legislatures
Yukon and N.W.T. participation, 12:61-2, 65-6, 72; 14:31, 41-3;
41:56-60; 51:13-7, 24-8
See also Amending procedure——Vancouver consensus (1980),
Opting-out

Federal-provincial relations

Constitutional change, effect, 41:54-S, 61-2

Fiscal arrangements, transfer payments, see Equalization
Improving, co-operation priority issue, Cohen remarks, 34:73-5, 78
Jurisdictions, transfer, 4:40-1

Non-subordination principle, 19:52-3

Provincial boundaries, 3:73-4

See also Newfoundland-Labrador——Quebec
Provincial status, see Amending procedure—Referendum

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

20 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Federal-Provincial Relations Office, Michael Kirby, secretary to the
cabinet for federal-provincial relations, references, see Privy
Council Office—Memorandum

Federalism, 28:30; 34:59-60; 35:18, 21, 47; 50:30

Biearneral system, importance, 30:29

Business Council on National Issues position, 33: 1 36-7, 148-9
“Community of communities”, 4:73

“Contract”, 4:94-5

Co-operative, 30:18, 22

Pearson role, 52:26

Decentralization, U.S., comparing, 34:85-7

Defining, Buchanan remarks, 17:27-8, 31, 48-9

Fathers of Confederation position, 50:29

Federal primacy/strong central government, 8:22-3; 27:67-8;

34:1 13-5: 50:51-2; 51:97-8
See also Economic union; Natural rcsources—-»-l£mer’gcncy
authority

“Federal state”, Blakeney remarks, 30:5-6

Social Credit Party of Alberta position, 332181-5

See also Amending procedure—Refercndum; Federal-provincial

conferences; Resolution

Federation of Canadian Municipalities
Constitutional reform, position, 9:7-10, 15-7
See also Committee–~Dead1ine; Language of instruction; Linguistic
and cultural rights; Native rights; Organizations/individuals
appearing and briefs submitted

Federation of Indcpentlent Schools in Canada, see
Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs submitted

Federation ofsasltatcltewan Indians, see Organizations/individuals
appearing and briels submitted

Federorowizc, Dr. Jan (Canadian Polish Congress)
Constitution of Canada, 9:103-8, 112-9

Fisheries, federal jurisdiction, see Natural rcsources~Broadbcnt
proposal

Fleck, Mr. Jim (Chairman, Committee on Constitutional Reform,
Business Council on National Issues)
Constitution of Carr-ada, 33:139-41

Flis, Mr. Jesse, references, we Committee–——Witnesses

Flynn, Mr. Dennis (President, Federation of Canadian Municipalities)
Constitution of Canada, 9:7-25

Flynn, Senator Jacques (Rougcmont)
Constitution of Canada, 4:23-7; 15:14-7

Fognrty, Rev. Patrick (Executive Secretary, Canadian Catholic
Schools Trustees‘ Association)
Constitution of Canada, 19:10-8, 23

Foreman, Dr. Dayton (National Vice President, Canadian National
Institute for the Blind)
Constitution of Canada, 25:4, 18

Forest industry, see Natural resources

Fortier, Mr. L. Yves (National Treasurer, Canadian Bar Association)
Constitution of Canada, 15:21-3. 26-7

Fox, Mr. Marcel (Director General, Protestant School Board of
Greater Montreal)
Constitution of Canada, 1 1:24-5

Fraser, Hon. John A. (PC- -Vancouver South)

Abortion, 22:49
Alberta 1-leritagc Savings Trust Fund, 32:136-7, 143-4

Fraser, Hon. John A.- —Cont.
Amerrding procedure, 3:61-5, 72′ 436, 63-6‘ 7:76-9; 13:14; 22:113-4;
32:18; 38:99-100; 4027-12; 4 . 2-3; 51. 80, 85, 113; 52:49-54
Britain, Parliament, select committee, 50:71-6
Campbell, Miss Colinc, references, 52:57
Charter of rights, 4:84; 7:102; 13:12; 22:22; 32:16; 38:49-50
Committee
Deadline, 9:22-3
Proceedings, procedural delays, 9:102
Quorum, 1:93-4
Travel, 1:79-80, 85-6, 90
Witnesses, 1:38-9
Constitution of Canada, 1:38-9, 52, 68-70, 85-6, 90, 93-4; 3:61-5,
72; 4:36, 54, 63-7, 84, 100; 5:10, 27; 7:22, 76-9, 85-6, 101-5;
9:22-3, 39-40; 122115-26; 13:1 1-4; 17:1l~5, 66-70; 19:83-4;
22:22, 44-5, 48-9, 81-4, 111-4; 31:20, 34-6: 32:5, 15-8, 136-8,
143-4; 37:34-6; 38:48-50, 99-101; 40:7-12; 41:32-4, 47-8, 51-4,
58-61;43:102, 107, 112-4; 44:5; 45:7, 18, 24-6; 46:35-7, 48-52,
66-9,96-7, 103-4, 107, 110-2, 116, 123-4, :10-3, 21-4, 35-7,
43, 46-8, 62-3, 67, 70-1, 77-8, 81-3; 48:52, 92-3,100-3, 122;
50:71-6; 51:75-80, 85, 113; 52:38-40, 49-55, 57, 71-2; 54:36-40,
60-1, 70-2
Deportation, 46:1 10-2, 123-4
Duality/two nations, 22:81~2
Fisheries, 54:61, 70-2
Freedom of information, 43:102, 107, 112-4
Japanese Canadians, 13:11-2
Jurisdictions, 46:49-52
Language of instruction, 12:1 12
Legal rights, 46:35-7; 47:22-4, 35-7, 43, 46, 62-3, 67, 70-1, 77-8,
81-3; 48:122
Linguistic and cultural rights, 7:77-9; 22:82-4; 37:34-6; 48: 100-3,;
51:76; 52:71-2
Monarchy, 4:66-7
Multiculturalism, 22:81
Native rights, 17:11-5, 66-9; 31:20, 34-6;46:96; 50:74-5
Natural resources, 7:105; 32:136-8, 144; 54:36-40
Organization meeting, 1:38-9, 52, 68-70, 79-80, 85-6, 90, 94-5
Points of order
Adjournment, M., 1:68-70
Documents, briefs, advertising for, M. (Mr. Irwin), and
requesting witnesses, amdt. (Mr. Nystrom), 1:38-9
McGrath privilege, 45:24-6
Meetings, punctuality, 32:5
Ministers, availability to Committee, 4:100
Proceedings, postponing, 47:10-3, 21
Quorum, official opposition, including, M. (Mr. Beatty), 1:93-4
Travel, M. (Mr. Epp), 1:79-80, 85-6, 90
Property rights, 7:105; 45:18, 24; 47:10
Quebec, sovereignty association referendum, 52:38~9, 48-9
References, 9:23-4; 51:81; 52254-5, 70
See also Linguistic and cultural rights
Resolution to Queen, 19:83; 22:1 12; 32:16
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 46:66-9
Search and seizure, 46: 103-4
Senate, 121120-1; 17:12-3; 41:47-8, 51-4, 58-60

Freedom of association, see Labour unions

Freedom of conscience
Defining, 14:7, 13; 221117-8; 34:l56
Refusal to take human life in cases of abortion/war/euthanasia,
12:46-56; 22:41-2; 243107

> Freedom ofexpression, 19:27; 342156

Freedom of information, 24:20-1;43:101-16
Progressive Conservative position, 41:98; 43:101-15
Task force recommendation, 19:28

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 21

Freedom of religion, 9:86; 32:33, 37-8; 341156-7; 35:76
Denominational/independent schools, affecting, 35:69; 38:51-2, 55

Freedom of speech
Restricting, 22:8, 16, 20
See also Press / media

Friesen, Mr. Benno (PC—Surrey-White Rock-North Delta)
Constitution ofCanada, 13:24; 24:17-8; 26:56-7; 34:94-5, 171-2;
35:44

Fulton, Mr. Jim (NDP——Skeena)
Constitution of Canada, 14:36-40; 26:5-6, 24-8; 271147-50

Fulton-Favreau formula, see Amending procedure

Galloway, Mr. C.T.P. (Canadian Life Insurance Association)
Constitution of Canada, 33294-5

Gallup poll, ree Public opinion polls
Garn, Lord Trcff, ree Britain—~Legislation
Gas, see Natural resources-Taxation

Gauthier, Mr. Jean-Robert (L-Ottawa-Vanier)
Constitution of Canada, 4:28-32; 41:35-9; 48: 106, 114
German-Canadian Committee on the Constitution, sec
Organizations/individnals appearing and briefs submitted
Gerntan Canadians, discrimination, World War 11 treatment, ete.,
26:39-51, 56-7; 32:14

Gill, Mr. Aurélien (Chief of Pointc-Blcue, Attikamek-Montagnais
Council)
Constitution of Canada, 28:14-24

Gimaiel, Mr. Pierre (L–Lac-St.-Jean)
Constitution of Canada, 38:88-91

God, including reference in charter, 29:82-3; 33:6-7; 4127-8, 11; 42:39,

42-3; 43:16-20
Progressive Conservative position, 56:49
See also Charter of rights-Preamble

Goldenberg, Senator Carl (Rigaud)
Amending procedure, 4236-7; 7:46; 9:99
British North America Act, 27:26-7
Charter of rights, 7:1 1 1-2; 12:123-4; 42:36
Committee

Deadline, 7:40-2
Proceedings, broadcasting, 1:63-4
Proceedings, procedural delays. 9:39-41
Confederation, 27:62-3
Constitution of Canada, 1:10, 26, 63-4; 3:6; 4:36-8; 7:40-2, 46,

111-2; 9:39-41, 48, 99-100;12:l2l-4;17:47-50;19:82-3:26:34-6;

27 5-7, 61-4; 42:36; 47:21, 51

Constitutional assembly, 121121-3
Duality, 27:26
Native rights, 26:34-6
Newfoundland-Labrador, 4:37-8; 9:99-100
Organization meeting, 1:10, 26, 63-4
Points of order

Agenda and procedure subcommittee, M., 3:6

Election ofJoint Chairman, M., 1:10

Proceedings, radio and TV broadcasting, M. (Mr. Epp), 1:63-4

Witnesses, appearance before Committee, 7:40-2
Premiers, 19:82-3
References, see Committee——Proceedings—-Subcommittees
Resolution to Queen, Ryan position, 9:48
Supreme Court, 27:64
Unilateral action, 27:61-2

Goldenberg, Senator Carl-Cont,
Unitary state, 27:63
Western provinces, 12:1 21-3

Gordon, Mr. Mark R. (Coordinator, Inuit Committee on National

Issues)

Constitution of Canada, 16:20-9; 17:8-13, 17-22

Gordon, Mr. Peter (Chairman, Business Council on National Issues)
Constitution of Canada, 331133-54

Gosnell, Chief James (President, Nishga Tribal Council)
Constitution of Canada, 26:1 1-4, 20-36

Goulet, Mr. Bertrand (M.N.A. Union Nationale Party)
Constitution of Canada, 28:38-9, 43

Government, Clark government, previous, see Natural resources

Government departments, boards, agencies and commissions, sec
Charter of rights‘

Governor General
Letters patent, 54:106-8
See also Britain-—Legislation

Gowanloek, Ms. G\veneth (Executive Director, Canadian Association
of Social Workers)
Constitution of Canada, 292147-8

Green, Sid, see Manitoba

Greene, Mr. James (Counsel, Denominational Education Committees
of Newfoundland)
Constitution of Canada, 35:63-70, 74

Greenspan, Mr. Lawrence (The Canadian Connection)
Constitution of Canada, 32:48~9, 53, 61-2, 66-9

Grygier, Dr. Tadeusz (Member of the Committee on Legislation,
Canadian Association for the Prevention of Crime)
Constitution of Canada, 24:46, 52-8

Haidasz, Senator Stanley (Toronto-Parkdale)
Constitution of Canada, 9:1 17-9

Haig, Mr. Graeme T. (Chairman of the Constitution Reform
Committee, Canadian Chamber of Commerce)
Constitution of Canada, 8:5-18, 22-3

Halley, Mr. Raymond J. (President, Canadian Bar
Association—Newfound1and Branch)
Constitution of Canada, 9:76-80, 85-96, 99-100

Hammel, Mr. Philip (President, Canadian Catholic School Trustees’
Association)
Constitution of Canada, 19:7-24
Handler, Ms. Denyse (Coalition for the Protection of Human Life)
Constitution of Canada, 22:26, 37, 40

Hardy, Miss Alison (Historian, Club Media of Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 24:9-22

Hargrave, Mr. Bert (PC—~Mcdieine Hat)
Constitution of Canada, 27:59-60

1-lartling, Mrs. J. (Executive Director, National Anti-Poverty
Organization)
Constitution of Canada, 29:18-9, 22-4, 33
Hate literature, see Pornography

Hatﬁeld, Hon. Richard B. (Premier, New Brunswick)
Constitution of Canada, 19:46-85

Note: See page I for Dates and Issues

22 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Hatﬁeld, Hon. Richard B.—CanI.

References, see Amending procedure~Referendum——Vancouvcr
consensus (l980)——Victoria formula (1971); Language of
instruction~—“Where numbers warrant”; Linguistic and cultural
rights——Courts and 1egislatures—Ontario; Native rights;
Resolutionv-Premiers; Unilateral acti0n—Fcdcral position

Hawkes. Mr. Jim (PC—Calgary West)

Abortion, 241105-7; 49:15-6

Affirmative action, 29:145-6; 48:41-2

Alberta, 4:118; 40:23-4

Alberta Heritage Savings Trust Fund, 32:l46

Alberta New Democratic Party, 332114-5

Amending procedure, 14:11}; 24:55; 27:48-9;38:53-4, 73-6; 39:13;
40:23-5;51:102—4;52:1l1-3,117,121-3;53:63-4

Atomic weapons, 25:28-9 ,

Charter of rights, 22:13,128;24:54-5,105-6;29:17-8, 35,56,152;
34:167-70; 35:36, 77; 43:13-5; 49:47-8

Children’s rights, 21:43-5

Citizenship, 29:55

Committee, recommendations, 31:91

Committee, witnesses, 24:8; 27:46; 29:54, 151; 31:61

Conferences, 51:18-9

Constitution of Canada, 4:99, 118-21; 14:51-2, 112-4:17:17-8,
79-80, 95, 125-7; 18:25-7, 36-7; 19:32-5; 21:43-5; 22:1 5, 91-2,
127-8,151-2;23:68-70;24 11,54-5,67-70,105-7;25:26-7;
27:46-50, 74, 105-7, 141-4; 29:17-8, 34-5, 54-6, 71-3, 144-6,
151-3; 30:59; 31:15-7, 61-5, 90-1; 32:68, 87-9, 146-7; 33:90-2,
111-6, 165-7, 187; 34:7, 99, 167- , 5134-7, 77, 82-3: 38:53-4,
72-6; 39:9-10, 13; 40:23-5; 41:40, 85-8; 42:16-9; 43:13-5, 40-2,

61-4, 81-2, 86-90, 93-5: 44:20; 47:15-6, 38, 62, 68, 78-9; 48:22-4,

28-31, 35, 41-2, 79-80; 9:15-6, 28, 42-3, 47-8, 59, 75; 50 7-9,
63-6; 51:18-9, 28-9,102-4;52:l03-5, 111-3, 117, 121-3;53:62-4,
67-8, 77; 54:17-23, 26, 29-33; 55:22-4; 56:12, 22-3
Courts, 49:28
Denominational/independent schools, 29:72-3;33:114-5
Education, 24:67-70
Elections, 43:81-2, 86-9
Equalization, 27:49; 49:75
“Everyone”, 43:40-2; 47:78-9
Family, 43:40-2
House of Commons, 43:93-5
Human rights, 22:12
Jurisdiction, 27:50
Language of instruction, 41:40
Legal rights, 47:38, 62, 68
Life insurance rates, 33:90-2
Linguistic and cultural rights, 29: 144-5: 41:86-8; 42:16-8; 48:79-80;
52:1 1 1-2
Mobility rights, 4:120-1; 18:36; 19:34-5; 29:152
Monarchy, 53:62-3
Multiculturalism, 22:13-5, 92
Native rights, 17:17-8; 18:25-7, 36-7; 22:15l-2‘ 271105-7, 141-3;
29:35; 31:16-7, 61-4, 90; 32:87-9; 3311 15-6 0: ,
Natural resources, 33:166-7, 187; 39:9-10; 53:77; 54:18-23, 29-33
Oil and oil industry, 322147
Points of order
Documents, appending to minutes and evidence, 33:111
Meetings, extending hours, 30:59
Members remarks, correcting, 34:7
Ministers, availability to Committee, 4:99
Motions, mover present during debate, 54:17
Proceedings, postponing, 47:15-6
Witnesses/meetings/report deadline, M. (Senator Austin),
23:68-70
Political belief, 48:22-4, 29-30
Pornography/hate literature, 43:64
Press/media, 24:9-10

Q
‘P
V-
i{>
oo
xo

Hawkes, Mr. Jim——CanI.

Process, 32:68

Property rights, 44:20

Quebec, 23:69-70

References. see Native people»-Cultural evolution
Regulations, 49:42-3

Resolution to Queen, 23:68-9; 34:99; 35:34-6; 50:50-1; 55:22-5;

56:12, 22-3

Retirement, 4:119-20

Senate, 52:10}-5; 67-8

Social services, l9:33—4; 29:152-3

Unilateral action, 27:48; 29:54-5; 35:37

Western provinces, alienation, 32:l46-7; 33:1 13, 165-6; 56:23

Hays, Senator Harry (Calgary; Joint Chairman)

Committee, data, 32:29

Committee, staff, 56:65

Constitution of Canada, 9:75; 32:29, 99; 33:51; 35277-9, 83; 46:59;
47:29; 50:89; 56:65

Election as Joint Chairman, 1:10

References, see Procedure and decisions of the Chair:
Women—Non-discrimination rights

Head, Dr. Wilson (President, National Black Coalition of Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 22:7—23

Health, care, sec Linguistic and cultural rights
Health and Welfare Department, new horizons program, 12:24-5

Healy, Mr. Les (Indian Association of Alberta)
Constitution of Canada, 31:78-82

I-learn, Mr. Ed (Member, Canadian Bar Association—–Newl’oun(llan<1
Branch)
Constitution of Canada, 9:80-4, 92-101

Hegan, Ms. Mary (The Canadian Connection)
Constitution of Canada, 32:51-2

Henderson, Mr. George (L—-Egmont: Parliamentary Secretary to
Minister of Fisheries and Oceans)

Charter of rights, 3:66-7

Committee, proceedings, broadcasting, 1:62-3

Constitution of Canada, 1:62-3; 3:66-7; 14:45-6, 90-6; 32:89-92;

332171-2

Mobility rights, 14:45-6

Organization meeting, 1:62-3

Point of order, proceedings, radio and TV broadcasting, M. (Mr.

Epp), 1:62-3

References, see Amending procedure—-Prince Edward Island
Resolution to Queen, 14:93-5

Western provinces, alienation, 33:17]-2

Yukon, 14:45

Herbert, Mr. llal, see Prince Edward lsland-—Stalus

Hervieux-Payelte, Mrs. Céline (l.—-Mercicr; Parliamentary Secretary
to SolicitorGcnera1)
Constitution of Canada, 17:73-5, 101-3, 123-5; 27:1l3-7; 28:22-4

Hill, Ms. Karen (Canadian Council on Social Development)
Constitution of Canada, 19:31-44

I-Iiscock, Reverend Boyd (Executive Secretary, United Church of
Canada in Newfoundland, Denominational Education Committees
of Newfoundland)

Constitution of Canada, 35:54~8, 65-6

Hislup, Mr. George (Canadian Association of Lesbians and Gay Men)
Constitution of Canada, 24:26~7, 39-40

Note: See page I for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 23

Hnatyshyn, Hon. Ray (PC—Saskatoon West)

Abortion, 49:16-7, 23-4

Amending procedure, 14:60-1; 52:41-6

Charter of rights, 14:59-60; 20:14-7; 30:36-8
Constitution of Canada, 14:59-62; 19:13-8; 20113-7; 30:

49:16-7, 23-4, 27, 37, 44, 52, 60; 52141-6, 105-7; 54:
76-8, 82-7

Consultations, 14:62

Emergency, public, 49:60

Judges, 49:52

Jurisdictions, 49:27

Language of instruction, 14:61

Multiculturalism, 14:62

Natural resources, 54:49-53, 82-7

Regulations, 49:37-44

Senate, 521105

Homosexuality, see Sexual orientation

House debate
Closure, 1:84; 56:24-5
Members participation, 56:29
Progressive Conservative position, 1:24
Trudeau remarks, 1:21, 24

36-8;
49-53, 63,

House of Commons

Divisions, quorum, 43:92-5

Duration, 43:90-8, 101

House leaders, sec Committee—Quorum
Staff, collective bargaining, 43:75-6

See also Search and seizure

Proteau, Mrs. Gillrcrte (President,Socié1é franco-manitobaino)
Constitution of Canada, 10:21~3, 32-4, 44

Protestant School Board of Greater Montreal
Background, 11:7-9
Enrollment, Bill 101 affecting, ctc., 11:8, 23-4
See also Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs submitted

Provinces
Entry into Confederation, procedure, 14:32-4, 43, 50-1
See also Consultations; Linguistic and cultural rights—CourIs and
legislatures: Premiers

Public Attitude, Z7:8~10; 31:47; 32:l00, 130-1; 5l:l03-4; 56:49
See also Amending procedurevVancouver consensus (1980);
Charter of rights; Constitutional reform; Federal-provincial
conferences——Ottawa, Sept. 8-12/80; Native rights; Public
opinion polls

Public Interest Advocacy Centre, see Organizations/individuals
appearing and briefs submitted –

Public opinion polls, 27:48; 50:62-3; 56:25
Canada West Foundation, 12:99, 106-9, 112-4, 121-4,128-9, 132-3;
27:23; 33:] 17-9; 50:81-2
Canadian Unity Information Office polls, 3:34-46; 1 1:6; 23:37, 55-7,
64-5; 25:29; 38:87
Mackasey position, 3:41-3
Robinson proposal, 23155-7, 64-5, 73

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

42 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Public opinion polls-Cont.

Gallup poll, Dec. 10/80, 58% oppose federal position, 23:15, 36-7,
52, 59, 62: 27:45, 54

Gallup poll, Jan. 14/81, 64% oppose federal position, 38:7, 15, 23,
77; 41:66; 50:46, 59-60: 51:34

See also Abortion; Alberta——Separatlsm; Charter of rights; Federalv
provincial conferences—Ottawa, Sept. 8-12/80; Language of
instruction; Linguistic and cultural rights; Mobility
rig1its—Emp1oyment and residence; Unilateral action

Public Services
“Reasonable quality”, 19:30
See also Social services

Quebec ‘
Anglophoncs, 2:34-5; 3:58-9; 7:58, 66-7; 8:50; 11214-5, 18, 24: 12:10;
13:27; 52:80. 83
See also Education—Olfieial languages policy; Official languages
minoritiesv-Francophones outside Que.
Charter of individual rights and freedoms, 13:41-2
Cultural evolution, 35:16, 40
Election, Apr. 13/81, effect of Liberal victory, 38:25
Immigration, see Language of instruction
Language rights, business corporations insensitivity, 2:34
Languages policy
Bi1l22,1l:8, 12,17
Bill 101, 240-1; 6:38-40, 45-7; 10:31, 40-2: 11:10-2, 16-25; 13:36;
14:61-2, 67-8; 22:88-9, 100-1: 34:108. 114; 481105-6, 116-8
Tliorron case, 42:16
See also Protestant School Board ofGreater Montreal
See also Language of instruction; Linguistic and cultural
rights-—-Courts and legislatures
Laurin (provincial cabinet minister), see Mobility rights
Liberal Party (provincial)
Beige paper, A new Canodionfederation, 2:42; 6:25, 30; 7:66;
35:18, 33
See also Unilateral action
“Nation”, 28:40-1; 35:32-4, 40-1
National Assembly, see Britain——Legislation, Thatcher government;
Unilateral action
New Democratic Party position, 54:127-8
Progressive Conservative position, 542123-5
Solidarity petition, Clark signature, 41;120-2
Sovereignty association, May 20/80 referendum, 23:69-70: 28:29;
34:45; 35:18, 33; 52:26, 42
Canadian Unity Information Office role, 52:30, 36-41
Constitutional change, federal commitment, 11:9; 121119-20;
17:53-5; 23:14-5: 33122-3: 3-1:108; 35:16-7, 22-3; 38:11-2;
39:19-23; 40:10—l
See also Linguistic and cultural rights—Courts: Unilateral action
See also Amending procedure—Blakeney proposal——-
Referendum——Toronto formu1a—Vancouver
consensus (l980)——Victoria formula (1971); Charter of rights:
Cornmittee—Witnesses; Jurisdictions—Provincia1; Linguistic
and cultural rights; Native peop1e——lndians: Process; Resolution;
Sexual orientation: Western provinces–Alienation

Racism, European superiority, resolution entrcnching, 32:87-8

Rae, Mr. Bob (NDP——Broadview-Greenwood)
Constitution of Canada, 23:18-21

Referendums, see Amending procedure: Newfoundland-Labrador
Refugees, see Immigration

Regulations
Ministerial review, 49:37-44
See also Charter of rig1tts—Statutes

Reid, Hon. J.M. (L—-Kcnora—Rainy River)
Organization meeting. 1:41-2

Rémillard, Professor Gil (Laval University)
Constitution of Canada. 35:4-25, 28-49
References, rec Amending procedure-—Victoria formula (I971);
Constitutional reform—lmportance; Resolution; Unilateral
action—-Provinces, Statute of Westminster

Report to House, see Committee

Resolution for a joint address to Her Majesty the Queen, 29A:l 2-8
Agreed to as amended, on recorded division, 56:17
Alberta Chamber of Commerce position, 27:36-7
Alberta elected representatives position, 27:47-51
Alberta New Democratic Party position, 332119
Alberta position, 4:118
Amdts.
Federal position, 2:21, 47; 42106-7; 23249; 36:10-21: 39:6-7; 40:33;
43:20; 51:26, 534; 53247-8, 64; 5 . ,24
Chrétien promise re government members vote, 50:20; 51:78;
52:76
introducing, federal position, 30:21; 31:16, 89-93: 32:16, 19;
35:71, 75
Liberal position, 9:36-7; 4429-11
New Democratic Party position, 36:26-7; 41:90-2: 42:5-16, 20;
4 7-30
Crit isms, 47:48
Order of presentation, 42:21-3
Progressive Conservative position, 36:22-4; 38:29-32, 95, 104-5;
41:88-104; 41/\:1-5; 42:36-45; 43:13-21
Justice Department assistance, 41:92-3
M. (Mr. McGrath), 4l:104
Mackasey remarks, 41:1 13-7
Summary, preparing, 43:39
Title, 37:7-9, 12-5
Trudeau position, 41:93; 46:12-6
See also below Recommendations
Barrett positioit, 3:76-7
Canada Act
Agreed to, 55:24
Schedule A
Agreed to as amended, 55:20, 24
Clause 1
Agreed to as amended, 55:19
Amdt. (Mr. Corbin), 54:1 10, agreed to
Amdt. (Senator Tremblay), 54:1 1 1-33: 55:7-19, ncgatived on
recorded division, 3-5
Clause 2
Agreed to as amended, 55:20
Amdt.. (Mr. Corbin), 55:19-20, agreed to
Clauses agreed to without amdt., 55:20
Preamble, agreed to, 55:20
Title, long, amdt.(Mr.1rwin), 55:20-3, withdrawn by
unanimous consent
Title. short, 55:24, agreed to
Schedule B
Agreed to, 55:24
See also below Constitution Act (l980)—Provincial referral
Canada West Foundation position, 12:99
Canadian Bar Association position, 15:5
Newfoundland branch, 9:87
See also below Drafting
Canadian Federation of Civil Liberties and Human Rights
Associations position, 21:5-6, 9-10
Canadians for One Canada position, 27:12
Church oflesus Christ of Latter Day Saints position, 29:7-8

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 43

Resolution for a joint address to Her Majesty the…—Cont.
Clause by clause study, 23:45, 54-5
Witnesses appearing, 27:90
Nystrom proposal, 23:45, 53-4
C1yne,J.V., position. 14:102. 114-5; 15:24
Committee study, Justice Department officials assisting, 2:21
Constitution Act (1980)
Clause 1
Agreed to as amended. 43:55
Amdt. (Mr. Epp). 42:36-45; 43:13-21, negatived on recorded
division. 4-5
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 42:23-36, agreed to on division, 3
Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 43:21-2, 25-37, 54-5, negatived on
division, 6
M. (Mr. Epp) to stand. 43:35-7, agreed to
Clause 2

Amdt. (Mr. Crombic), 43:55-62. negatived on division, 7

Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 43:67, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 43:79, agreed to, 8

Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 43:39-55, negatived on recorded

division, 6-7

Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 43:62-6, agreed to
Part (a), 43:66, negatived on division, 7
Part (b), 43:66, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 43:68-79, negatived on recorded

division. 7-8
Clause 3

Agreed to as amended, 43:90

Amdt. (Mr, Corbin), 43:84-90, agreed to on division, 8

Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 43:79-84. negatived on division, 8

Clause 4

Agreed to as amended, 43:10]

Amdt. (Mr. Corbin), 43:90, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 43:91-8. 101
Part (a) negatived on recorded division, 10
Part (13) negatived on division, 10
Part (c) negatived on recorded division, 10-1

Clause 5
Agreed to as amended, 43:1 16
Amdt. (Mr. McGrath), 43:101-2, 116, negatived on recorded
division, 11-2
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson). 43:102-16, negatived on
division, 1 1
Clause 6
Agreed to, 46:101
Amdt. (Mr. lttinuar), 43:l21-7,4415-6;46:71-101, negatived
on recorded division, 8
Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 432116-20, negatived on division, 12
Clause 7
Agreed to as amended, 46:70-1
Amdt. (Mr. Bcatty). 44:12-31; 46:12-30, negatived on recorded
division. 3-4

M. to stand (Mr. Nystrom), 44:20-31

Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 44:6-12, negatived on division, 3

Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 46:30-45, negatived on division, 4
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. Crombie), 46:64-6, agreed to, 6
Part (a), 46:45-55, negatived on recorded division, 4-5:
Part (b), 46:62-70, negatived on recorded division, 6-7

Clause 8

Agreed to as amended, 46:8

Amdt.(Mr.1rwin),46:l0l-9, agreed to
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 46:102-8, negatived on

recorded division, 8-9
Clause 9
Agreed to as amended, 46:124

Resolution for a joint address to Her Majesty the…—ConL
Constitution Act (1980)—Com.
Clause 9——Com.
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 46:l09-24, agreed to
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. Fraser). 46:1 10-24, negatived on
recorded division, 9-10
Clause 10

Agreed to as amended, 47:28

Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 462125-7, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr, S. Robinson), 46:l27-35, negatived on recorded

division. 10-1
Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 46:l35-7; 47:21-8, negatived on
division
Clause 1 1
Agreed to as amended, 47:73
Amdt. (Mr, Corbin), 47:59-60, 64, agreed to
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 47:60-4, ncgatived on
division, 7

Amdt. (Mr. Epp), 47:57-9, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 47′
Amdt. (Mr, lrwin), 47:
Amdt. (Mr. 1rwin),47:43-4, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 47: 2-3, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. Irwin). 47:54, agreed to, 57

Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 47:54-7. negatived on
division, 6
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 47:64, 69, agreed to
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 47:65-9, negatived on
division, 7
Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 47:44-52, negatived on division, 5
Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 47:69-73, negatived on division, 7
Clause 12
Agreed to, 47:7
Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 47:73-80, negatived on division, 7
Clause 13
Agreed to as amended. 47:83
Amdt. (“ix lrwin), 47:80-3, agreed to on division, 8
Clause 14

Agreed to as amended, 47:88

Amdt. (Mr. McGrath). 47:86-7, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson). 47:83-6, negatived on division, 8

Clause 15
Agreed to as amended. 48:49
Amdt. (Mr. Corbin), 47:88; 48:35, agreed to
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr, Crombie), 47:90-1, agreed to
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 47:89-92; 48:17-34,
amended by unanimous consent, 17-8
Part (a), 48:34. negatived on recorded division, 5
Part (c), 48:34, negatived on recorded division, 5-6
Part (cl), 48:34, negatived on recorded division, 6
Part (e), 48:34, negatived on recorded division, 6-7
Amdt. (Mr. Irwin), 48:39, 45-6, agreed to
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. Epp), 48:40-3. negatived on division, 7
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. Epp), 48:45, agreed to
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 48:40, 43-5, negatived on
division, 7
Amdt. (Mr. Manly), 48:46-8, negatived on division, 8
Clause 16
Agreed to as amended. 48:81
Amdt. (Mr. Corbin). 48:60-81, agreed to
Clause 17

Agreed to as amended, 48:81

Amdt. (Mr. Corbin), 48:81, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. Corbin). 54:97-8, agreed to by unanimous consent

Clause 18
Agreed to as amended, 48:82
Amdt. (Mr. Corbin), 48:81-2, agreed to

Note: See page I for Dates and Issues

44 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Resolution for a joint address to Her Majesty the.,.—~Com. Resolution for a joint address to Her Majesty tlle…~Con1.

Constitution Act (1980)—Co/12.
Clause 19
Agreed to as amended, 48:82
Amdt. (Mr, Corbin), 48:82, agreed to
Amdt. (Mr, Corbin), 54:98, agreed to by unanimous consent
Clause 20
Agreed to as amended, 48:85
Amdt. (Mr. Corbin), 48:82-5, agreed to
Amdt. (Mr, lrwin), 54:98, agreed to by unanimous consent
Clause 21
M. to add (Mr. Crombie), 48:85-94; 52:65-8, withdrawn by
unanimous consent
Clause 23
Agreed to as amended, 482120
Amdt. (Mr. Corbin). 48:94-6, 107-20, agreed to on recorded
division, 14-5
Amdt. to amdi.(Mr.Nystron1), 48:96-107,nega1ived on
recorded division, 14
Clause 24, 49:83-4
Agreed to as amended, 49:95
Arnd1.(Mr. lttinuar), 49:84-95, agreed to on recorded division,
9

M. to add (Mr. lrwin), 481120-5, agreed to
Amdt. (Mr. S, Robinson), 482121, withdrawn

Clause 25, negatived, 50:13

Amdl. (Mr. lrwin), 50:13, agreed to

M. to add (Mr. lrwin), 50:9-12, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. Epp), 50:10-2, withdrawn by unanimous consent

Clause 26, negatived, 50:20

M. to add (Mr. lrwin), 48:12S-6; 50:14, 19-20, agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 48:16, 125; 50:14-9, negatived on
division, 4

Clause 27,49:11-2, agreed to

M. to add (Mr. McGrath), 481126, 130-I, agreed to

Amdt. (Senator Petten), 48:127-30, agreed to

Clause 28, 49:27-37, agreed to on division

M. to add (Mr. McGrath), 49:13-26, negatived on recorded

division, 4-5

Clause 29, 49:50-4, agreed to on recorded division, 6

Amdt. (Mr, Nystrom), 49:45-50, negatived on division, 6

M. to add (Mr. 1-lnatysliyn), 49:37-45, negatived on recorded

division, 5-6
Clause 30, M. to add (Mr. S. Robinson), 49:54-6, 59-64, amended
by unanimous consent, 56-9, 63, negatived on division, 8

Clause 31

Agreed to as amended, 49:82

Amdt. (Mr, lrwin), 49:71-81,agreed to

Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 49:65-71, negatived on recorded

division, 8
M. to add (Mr. lttinuar), 49:95-101, agreed to on recorded
division, 9-10

Clause 32

Agreed to as amended, 51:30

Amdt. (Senator Austin), 51:22-30, agreed to, 5

Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. Epp), 51:27-8. agreed to

Amdt. (Senator’1‘remb1ay), 51:11-22, negatived on division, 4
Clause 33. 52:108-13, agreed to on division
Clause 34, 52:1 13, agreed to
Clause 35

Agreed to on division, 521117

Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 52:1 14-5, agreed to
Clause 36

Agreed to as amended, 521117

Amdt. (Mr. 1r\vin), 52:1 16-7, agreed to
Clause 37, agreed to on division, 52:1 17

Constitution Act (l980)—C0m.
Clause 38
Agreed to as amended, 53:19
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 52:] 17-30: 53:17-9, agreed to on recorded
, division, 6
Clause 39, 53:19-20, agreed to on division
Clause 40
Agreed to as amended, 53:27
.AmdL (Mr. lrwin), 53:20-7, agreed to on division
Clause 41
Agreed to as amended, $1:115
Amdt. (Mr, Epp), 5 I 132-43, 50-108, negatived on recorded
division, 8-9 _
Amdt.(Mr.1rwin),51:109-15
Part (ii), agreed to, 51:9
Part (iii), agreed to on division, 51:9-10
Clause 42
Agreed to as amended, 52:60-5
Amdt.(Mr.lrwin),51:123-4
Amdt. (Mr. Irwin), 52: 5-60, agreed to on division, 6
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 52:10-5, negatived on
division, 5
Amdt. (Mr. Nystrom), 511115-23,negatived on division, 10
Clause 44, 52384-108, negatived on recorded division, 8
Amdt. (Mr, lrwin), 52:69-84, agreed to
Clause 46
Agreed to as amended on division, 53:35
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 53:27-9, 34-5, agreed to on division, 9
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. Nystrom), 53:29-34, negatived on
recorded division, 9
Clause 47
Agreed to as amended, 53:49
Amdt. (Mr. Corbin), 54:98-9, agreed to by unanimous consent
Amd1.(Mr.lrwin), 53:37, agreed to
Clause 48
Agreed to, 53:51
Amdt.(Mr.Epp),53:50,wi1hdrawn by unanimous consent
M. to add (Mr. McGrath), 53:38-49, negatived on recorded
division, [0
Clause 49, agreed to, 53:51
Clause 50
Amdt. (Mr. Epp), 53:55-65, negatived on recorded division, 12
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 53:65-8, agreed to on division
Amdt. (Mr. S. Robinson), 53:51-4, negatived on recorded
division, 1 1
Clause 51
Agreed to as amended, 53:71
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 53:68-71, agreed to
Clause 52
Agreed to as amended, 54:94
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 54:91-4, agreed to
Clauses 52 and 53
M. to add (Mr. Broadbent), 53:72-7; 54:80-90, agreed to as
amended
Amdt. (Mr. Corbin), 53:78-80, 84-97; 54:18-23, 27-70,
agreed to on recorded division, 10
Amdt. (Mr. Fraser), 54:70-6, negatived on recorded division,
10-1
Amdt. (Mr. McGrath), 53:81-4; 54:76-80, negatived on
recorded division, 1 1
Clause 59
Agreed to as amended, 54:96
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 54:95-6, agreed to
Clauses agreed to without amdt., 48:94; 49:12, 65; 52:68, 108;
53:51; 54:94-5

Note: See page I for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 45

Resolution for a joint address to Her Majesty the…-Com.
Constitution Act (1980)~~-Cont.
Parts land 111, M. (Mr. Epp), 50:21-2, 25-85, negatived on
recorded division. 7-8
Schedule I. 54:l05-8, agreed to as amended
Amdt. (Mr. Epp). 541103-5, agreed to
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 54:l00-3, agreed to
Technical amdts. to English version, Ms. (Mr. Irwin), 54:99-100,
agreed to
Technical amdt. to proposed Sixth Schedule to Constitution Act
1867 (A), M. (Senator Austin), 56:9-1 1, agreed to
Title, 541109, agreed to as amended
Amdt. (Mr. lrwin), 54:l08-9, agreed to
Davis position, 14:93-S
Divisive, 34:61-2, 77-8, 105-6; 5G:25~6, 30
Drafting, 2:48-50; 4:45-6; 9:68, 80, 88; 14:83-S; 15:21; 2221124;
24:55; 4 34, 85, 109; 47:33-6, 39-43, 65-7; 481101-3; 49:72,
75-6, 96; 50:16; 512113-4: 53:18
Canadian Bar Association recommendations, 15:12-3
See also Charter of righls~“Reasonable limits“: Legal rights
Federal position
Court referral, 54:85-7
Criticisms, 50:49, 73-4
Documents, tabling, 41:47, 51
Electoral mandate lacking, 122109: 35:11, 42-3; 38:10
Green, Sid, position, 38:18, 27 _
Limiting to patriation/amending formula/unanimity, 4:106-7
New Democratic Party support, 39:6
Opposition, 23:35-6; 27:72
Ryan position, comparing, 4:108-9: 38:25
Saskatchewan support, 381101-2
Federal system, affecting, 33:l32; 54:1 148; 56:18-9
Form of final presentation, 56:8
Indian Rights for Indian Women position, 17:84
Inuit Committee on National Issues position, 16:17-8
Legality/legitimacy, 4:49-52; 12:135-6; 142106; 22:16; 27:124. 105,
141-2; 34:8, 32-4, 44-5, 99-100; 35:1 1, 29, 34-6, 46
Liberal position, 36:36
See also above Amdts.
“Made in Canada“, 17:42; 22:66; 341102
See also Britain~—Legislation
Main elements, 2:20
Mennonite Central Committee position, 12:53-4
National Action Committee on the Status of Women position,
9157-8, 70, [32
New Brunswick government position, 19:72, 78-9
New Brunswick legislature, submitting to for approval, 19:72-4
New Democratic Party position, 38:75-6; 50:30-1; 56:21-2, 28-30
Beatty remarks, 23:58
See also above Amdts.; Federal position
“Newfound1and”. references, Epp proposal, 54:l03~5
Nova Scotia position, 17:28
Omissions, 54:l05-8
Postponing until court decision, 41:26
Preamble, 10:24; 13:50; 19:27; 2318-9, 11, 23, 29, 42; 29:52, 88, 124;
291132-3, 141-2
Agreed to on division, 56:13-7
Premiers position, Hatfield remarks, 19:63
Presentation to Her Majesty the Queen, M, (Senator Austin),
56:17-49, agreed to on recorded division, 6-7
Prince Edward Island position, 14:75-6, 96
Progressive Conservative Party of Sskatchcwan position, 32:100-l,
1 1 5
Provincial reference to courts
Blakeney position, 30:43
Delaying tactic, 34:88, 91

Resolution for a joint address to Her Majesty the…—ConI.
Provincial reference to courts-»—-Com.
Subjudice convention, 34:71. 88-9
Provincial referral of Schedule B under proposed amending
procedure, Epp motion, 50:21-2, 25-85
Public input, 19:26-7, 33, 36-8, 40-1; 21 :10-5, 23-4; 32:17-8;
341106-7, 112-3, 145; 35:81; 41:86-7
Trudeau position, 9:42
See also Charter of rights
Quebec political leaders position, 17:55-6: 28:36
Recommendations re, moving, 56252-3, 58
Rémillard position, 35:9-10
Scott, F.R., position, 23:68~9
Section 42, see Amending procedure—Referendum
Supreme Court reference, 4:95; 142108; 30:44; 34:72, 91-2; 35:27
Subjutlfce convention, 4:51; 17:32; 21:1 1; 23:38-9; 34142-3, 71,
88-9. I04
See also Britain—-Legislation: Native rights
Title, 56:11-5, 21
Agreed to on division, 56:17
Trudeau position, see Amending proccdure4Referendum—-—
Vancouver; Committce—Proceedings; House debate—Members
participation: Linguistic and cultural rights——Courts; Native
rights: Natural resources and see above Amdts.
United Church of Canada position, 29:79-80, 91; 29A:12-8
Vancouver Peop1e’s Law School Society position, 32:25-6
Words for an Address to Her Majesty, 56:17, agreed to on division
Words for a proposed Resolution, 56:17, agreed to on division
Yukon, affecting, 14:44-6
See also Indian Act; Social services

Retirement, compulsory, non-discrimination rights, 4:119-20; 5:1 1-3;
33:92; 34:14‘)-50
See also .lustice—-Judges

Rhéaume, Mr. Gene (Honorary President, Native Council of Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 17:l30

Richardson, Hon. James (National Chairman, Canadians for One
Canada)

Constitution of Canada, 27:7-34

References
Cabinet resignation (October 1976), 27:7-9
See also Amending procedure—Victoria formula (1971); Charter

of rights

Riis, Mr. Nelson (NDP—Kamloops-Shuswap)
Constitution of Canada, 27:50-3

Riley, Mr. Del (President, National Indian Brotherhood)
Constitution of Canada, 27:75-7, 89-114, 118

Rizzuto, Senator Pietro (Repentigny)
Constitution of Canada, 23:13-4
References, see Language of instruction——National Congress of
Italian Canadians

Rjadki, Dr. Edward (Psychiatrist, Campaign Life——Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 34: l 27

Roberts, Hon. John, see Britain~«Legislation, Thatcher government

Roberts, Mr. Stanley (President, Canada West Foundation)
Constitution ofCanada, 12:98-100, 109-23, 129-30, 136

Robertson, Gordon, see Amending procedure—Refercndum
Robinson, Mr. Svend (NDP——B\trnaby)
Abortion, 22:37-40; 241107-9; 46:70-l

Administrative abuses, 37:19~2l
Affirmative action, 48:43-4

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

46 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Robinson, Mr. Svend—CanI.

Amending procedure, 3:29-31;4:56-7, 80, 92; 5:14-5; 7:19-20; 13:16;
21:13; 29:61; 39:12-6; 40214-6, 26; 41:74, 85; 51:40-2, 79-80.
99-100, 112-3; 52:10-1, 19-21, 58, 66-8, 84-5: 53:33-5, 51-4

Britain, legislation enabling Canadian constitutional amdt., 50:49

Campbell, Miss Coline, references, 1:83

Charter of rights, 3:27-9; 4:559 86; :14-8; 7:19-22; 9:45; 11:37-8;
14:20-1; 15:17-20; 21:14; 22:115- 23:54; 29:62; 3 19-20, 23;
38 9-40, 46-8; 40:29-30; 41:14-5; 42:25-31, 34-5, 41-2; 43:30-3;
50:50-1; 54:93-4

Children’s rights, 21:36-7

Citizenship, 43:1 16-8: 46:l22

Committee

Deadline, 4:53-4; 9:44-7

Proceedings, procedural delays, 9:44-6

Sittings, 23:53

Staff, 52:56; 56:62

Travel, 1:83-5

Witnesses, 1:43-4; 7:19: 11:36-7; 14:16; 23:52-5, 76

Constitution of Canada, 1:43-4, 83-5; 3:27-31, 39, 7
92; 14-8; 7:19-22, 38-9, 48;9:44-7, 152; 11:6, 3 – ,43;
13:14-7; 14:16-21; 15:7-20; 17:58-61; 21:13-6, 19, 36-9;
22:37-40, 44, 65-7, 114-8: 23:52-7, 65, 73-80; 24:32-4, 38, 47-51,
107-10; 29:60-2; 32:19-23; 3617-8, 39; 37:18-25, 37-9; 38:39-40,
46-8; 39:12-7; 4 4-6, 25-6, 29-30; 41:6-7, 12-6, 21-2, 41,47,
73-4,84-5, 118-20, 2:5-9, 19-20, 25-31, 34-5, 41-2; 43:22-34,
38-40, 47-9, 53-4, 60-9, 73-86, 89-92, 97-8, 101-8, 114-9; 44:6-7,
10-2, 16-9, 26-30; 45:20-1, 26-7, 31; 46:14, 30-7, 44-7, 54-66,
69-71, 90-3, 99-109, 113-6, 122-9, 134-7; 47:26-31, 35, 41-6,
51-61, 64-75, 79-80, 83-6, 89-92; 48:17-23, 32-5, 40, 43-6,
104-6, 121-3, 126: 49:39-42, 53-7l;50:14-9, 48-51, 87; 51122-3,
31, 38, 40-5, 49-50, 79-80, 99-100, 112-3; 52-10-1, 19-21, 56-8,
66-8, 84-91; 53:33-5, 51-4; 54:91-4, 121-8; 55:7: 56:27-30, 52-4,
59-62

Consultations, 9:152; 14:16

Deaf, 47:84-S

Deportation, 46:1 13-6

Disabled and handicapped, 5:17; 37:21-4; 39:16-7; 49:53-4

Elections, 43:80-6

Emergency, public, 49:55-63

Environment, 49:70-1

Equalization, 49:65-71

“Everyone“, 24:1 10; 43:39-40, 48-9: 44:7, 11-2

Federal position, 50:49

Freedom of conscience, 22:1 17-8

Freedom of information, 43:102-4, 107-8, 114-6

House debate, closure, 1:84

House of Commons, duration, 43:91-2, 97-8

House 0fCommons, staff, 43:75-6

lndian Act, 54:94

Japanese Canadians, 13:15-6

Jurisdictions, provincial, 44:16-9, 28-30

Kaplan, Mr., references, 44:10

Labour unions, 43:68-9, 73-7

Language ofinstruction, 41:41; 481104-6

Legal rights, 4:57-8: 5:18; 7:21-2; 11:38-9; 14:17-9; 15:18-9;
21:14-6; 22:1 17-8 4:48-50; 37:24-5; 41:15-6; 46:30-7, 44-7, 54,
125-9, 134-7; 47:27-31, 35, 41-6, 51-61, 64-75, 79-80, 83-6;
48:12]

Liberal Party, NDP support, 46:14

Lieutenant Governors warrants, 461124

Linguistic and cultural rights, 37:37-9; 56:60

Mackasey, Mr., references, 21:19

Mobility rights, 46:90-3

Multiculturalism, 50:14-5, 19

Native rights, 11:43; 17:60; 50:17-9; 54:l25-6

New Democratic Party constitution position, 56:29-30

Robinson, Mr. Svend——Cor1t.
Non-discrimination rights, 17:61: 20:66-7; 22:1 18; 32:20-|;4| :21-2;
47:89-92: 48:17-23, 32-5, 40
Organization meeting, 1:43-4, 83-5
Parole Board, 47:68
Patriation,22:115
Points of order
Agenda and procedure subcommittee, 4:55
Divisions, recorded, 43:77-9
Documents, appending, 3:77
Documents, briefs, advertising for, M. (Mr: lrwin), and
requesting witnesses, amdt. (Mr. Nystrom), 1:43-4
Documents, tabling, M. (Mr. Beatty), amdt., 3:39
McGrath privilege, 45:20-1, 26-7
Meetings, scheduling, 36:7-8
Members, substitutes, 43:24-5
Ministers, questioning, 46:57-61
Questioning of witnesses, 36:39
Reports to both Houses, draft consideration, in camera meetings,
M., 56:52-4
Travel, M. (Mr. Epp), 1:83-5
Witnesses, appearance before Committee, 7:38-9, 48
Wimesses/meetings/report deadline, M, (Senator Austin),
23:52-6, 80
Amdts., 23:56-7, 73,76
Political beliefs, 29:62; 48:21-2
Press/media, 43:62-6
Privacy, 43:61;46:62-5, 69-70
Progressive Conservative Party, 54:121-7
Property rights, 43:60-1; 44:16-9, 26-30: 461102-7; 50:19; 56:27
Public opinion polls, 11:6; 23:55-7, 65
Quebec, 541123-5, 128
References, 41:1 18-20; 42:42; 52:92-3
See also Amending procedure-~Referendum, Charter of rights;
Committee——Witnesses; Public opinion polls——Canadian
Unity information Office; Senate—-Patronage
Regulations, 49:39-42
Resolution to Queen, 21:13; 23:53; 41:47
Amdts., 42:5-9, 20; 43:26-9; 51:23
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 46:66, 70, 108-9
Search and seizure, 46:102-7
Senate, 51:42-5, 49-50; 52:85-91
Sexual equality, 22:6 :
Sexual orientation, 2 .32-4; 39:17
Supreme Court, 22:65-6
Tassé, Mr., references, 55:7
War Measures Act, 40:29-30; 41:6-7, 12-3
Women, 4155-6; 5115-6
Writs of assistance, 41:13-4; 462108
Young offenders, 21: 8 9

Roblin, Senator Duff (Red River)
Administrative abuses, bureaucratic |.1w-making, 33:138
Age, 9:14-5
Amending procedure, 3:21-3; 4:122-7, 136-9; 9:97-8; 12:1 10; 19:54;
27:14-5; 322120-1; 33:40-1; 41:24-31, 80-2:51:65-70,112,121;
52:15-9
Capital punishment, 14:29
Charter of rights, 22:63; 24:45; 27:66: 38:41-3; 42:34
Lyon position, 51:47-8
Committee
Proceedings, broadcasting, 1:56-7, 63
Travel, 1:82-3
Witnesses, 1:30-2
Con fereuces, 51:19-20, 28
Constitution of Canada, 1:16-7, 20-1, 30-2, 56-7, 63, 82-3; 3:21-4:

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 47

Roblin, Senator Duff—Cnnr.
Constitution of CanadaA—C(mI.
45-7; 27:12-6, 124-5, 152-3; 32:1 I6-21; 33:38-42, 123-6, 138-42;
34:31-5, 56, 94; 38240-3; 41:24-31, 76-82, 118, 125; 42:34; 43:28,
35-7, 42-3; 45:27: 46:19-23, 84, 91-3; 47:18-20; 48:25-7, 84 ;
51:19-20, 28,46 65-70, 112, 116, 121: 52:15-9, 100-3, 129;
53:17-8, 49-51: 54. 3-8, 78-82: 56:37-40
Constitutional assembly, 9:15; 33:39-40
Convention/precedence, 34:31-4
Council ofthe provinces, 33:124-6
Equalization, 3:23-4; 32:1 18
“Everyone”, 43:42-3
Federal-provincial relations, 19:52-3
Freedom of information, 24:20-1
Language ofinstruction, 9:13-4; 21:12-3
Legal rights, 14:28-9; 24:46-7
Linguistic and cultural rights, 4:137-9; 19:54-5; 32:119-20
Mobility rights, 33:l39-41; 46:84
Municipalities, 9:1 1-3
Native rights, 17:76-7; 27:l52-3; 33:41-2; 46:91-3
Natural resources, 32:1 17-8; 54:53-8
Newfoundland-Labrador, 53:49
Non-discrimination rights, 21:11-2; 22:64
Organization meeting, 1:16-7, 20-1, 30-2, 56-7, 63, 82-3
Points oforder
Agenda and procedure subcommittee, quorum, 1:17
Documents, briefs, advertising for, M. (Mr, lrwin), and
requesting witnesses, amdt, (Mr. Nystrom), 1:30-2
McGrath privilege, 45:27
Members of House of Commons not Committee members, 1:20-1
Members, official record not updated, registration with Whip
sufficient to maintain eligibility, 1:16
Members remarks, 27: 1 24-5
Ministers, availability to Committee, 4:98
Proceedings, postponing, 47:18-20
Proceedings, radio and TV broadcasting, M. (Mr. Epp), 1:56-7,
63
Travel, M. (Mr. Epp), 1:82-3
Political belief, 48:25-6
Press/media, 24:21-2
Process, 33:l23-4
Property rights, 46:19-23
References, 52:103-4
See also Amending procet.lure——Refercndum; Linguistic and
cultural rights~Courts and legislatures
Resolution to Queen, l2:l09; 21:10-1; 27:12-4; 34:32; 56:38-40
Senate,12:111;32:117;33:l25;41:76-9,125;51:46-7;52:l00-3;
53:51
Sexual equality, 43:35-7
Supreme Court, 22:63
Unilateral action, 9:98; l2:108-9; 33:l4l-2; 34:32-3
Western provinces, alienation, 54:80-2

Roch, Mrs. Lucille (Director General, Société franco-manitobaine)
Constitution of Canada, 10:23-4, 38-9

Rose, Mr. Mark (NDP—Mission-Port Moody)

Amending procedure, 35:46

Constitution of Canada, 291139; 32:38-41:69-70; 33:46-9, 85-6,

93-4:34:73-7: 35:45-6; 38:105-7:39:8, 14

Denominational/independent schools, 33:85-6
Federal-provincial relations, 34:73-4

Legal rights, 34:75

Life insurance rates, 33:93-4

Native rights, 33:46-7; 34:75-6

Natural resources, 38:105-7: 39:8
Non-discrimination rights, 32:38-41

Process, 32:70; 33:47-9

Rose, Mr. Mark–Cont.
Resolution to Queen, 35:46
Unilateral action, 35:45

Rosenbloom, Mr. Donald (Legal Counsel, Nishga Tribal Council)
Constitution of Canada, 26:14-22, 25-8, 33-6

Rousseau, Senator Yvette (de Salaberry)
Constitution of Canada. 24:78-80: 42:21

Royal Canadian Mounted Police, mail interceptions and openings,
46:66-70, 108-9

Royal Commission on Bilingualism and Biculturalism (Laurendeau-
Dunton), 11:9

Royal Proclamation (1763), see Native rights
Ruby, Clayton, see Charter of rights—“Reasonab1e limits”

Rudnyckyj, Professor J.B. (Canadian Citizenship Federation)
Constitution of Canada, 29:59-60, 64-5

Rudzik, Mr. Orest (President, Ukrainian Canadian Committee,
Toronto Branch)
Constitution of Canada, 14:59-60, 67

Russell, Professor Peter (University ofToronto)
Constitution of Canada, 34:131-72
References, see Amending procedure—Referendum-~Vancouver
consensus (1980)-«Victoria formula (1971 ); Charter of
rights-Entrenchment

Russell tribunal report, see Native rights

Ryan, Claude (Que. Liberal leader). See Committee–Witnesses;
Linguistic and cultural rights—-Courts and legislatures;
Resolution»-Federal position; Unilateral action

Ryant, Mr. Joseph (Board Member, Canadian Council on Children
and Youth)
Constitution of Canada, 21:33-6

St. Denis, Mr. Yves (President, Association canadienne-francaise de
l‘Ontario)
Constitution of Canada, 8:32-5, 40, 44-53
St. Laurent, the late Rt. Hon. L.S., see Charter of rights; Jurisdictions:
Unilateral actionAProvinces

Sanderson, Mr. Sol (Chief of Federation of Saskatchewan lndians)
Constitution ofCanada, 29:l06-7, 113-4, 117-20; 31:63-78, 86-8,
93-4

Saskatchewan

Government. see Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs
submitted

Heritage trust fund, 322137

Potash/CIGOL, 30:24, 35-6; 32: 1 24-5; 53:76, 80, 85-6; 54:28-30,
43. 50

See also Natural rosources—Broadbent proposal

See also Affirmative action; Age; Charter of rights; Equalization;
Language ofinstruction; Linguistic and cultural rights; Mineral
resources——Offsl’lorcjurisdiction; Multiculturalism; Native
peop1e41ndians; Natural resources; Official languages
minorities-—Francophones outside Que.; Resolution—~Federal
position; Social services—Welfare recipients

Saskatchewan Human Rights Commission, see Charter of rights; Non-
discrimination rights; Organizations/individuals appearing and
briefs submitted

Saunders, Mr. Doug (Legal Counsel. National Indian Brotherhood)

Constitution of Canada, 27:99, 111, 115-6

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

48 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Sauvé, Hon. Jeanne, P.C., references, see Committee-—Proceedings

Savino, Mr. Vic (Legal Counsel, Native Council of Canada)
Constitution ofCanada, l7:l2l-3, l3l

Schlesinger, Mr. Frank (Canadian Jewish Congress)
Constitution ofCanada, 7:96-8

Schultz, Mr. Nick (Associate General Counsel, Public Interest
Advocacy Centre)
Constitution of Canada, 29:19-36

Sciascia, Mr. Antonio (Legal Advisor, National Congress of Italian-
Canadians (Quebec Region))
Constitution of Canada, 23:7, ll-29

Scott, F.R., see Resolution

Scott, The Most Reverend Edward W. (Primate of the Anglican
Church of Canada)

Constitution of Canada. 33:6-S0

References
New Democratic Party affiliation, 33:l6
See also Anglican Church of Canada

Search and seizure, 7:l 1-3, 89-90; l5:8; 21:7; 22:l07; 24:53-4; 29:86-7;
32:l2; 36:l I-2; 46:10l-7

Séguin, Miss Jeannine (President, La Federation des Francophones
I-lors Québec Inc.)
Constitution of Canada, l3:26-S2

Senate, 36:38

Appointments, 53:66-8

British Columbia position, 38:l00

Electing, 33:l25; 41:76, 125; 51:20, 64; 52:l00-2

Patronage,S. Robinson allegations, 51:42-50; 52:85-93, 97-l05

Progressive Conservative position, 4l:96

Reforming, l2:l30-l; 32:l04-5, H7; 3 ’43; 52:94-7, 103; 53:50-l

Regional representation, 30:28-9; 41:82-3

Report on certain aspects of the Canadian constitution, November
1980 study, 34:68-9

Supreme Court decision re Bill C-60 of 30th Parliament, 3:24-5;
4:23-6, 93-5; 35:8, 24; 4l:53-4, 76-7; 522102

Veto power, see Amending procedure

See also Committec—Proccedings; Native pcople—Reprcscntation;
Western provinces-—Alienation

Separatism, see Alberta

Sexual equality, 20:22-3; 22:66; 49:46-7, 50
New Democratic Party amdt., 43:21-2, 25-37

Sexual orientation, non-discrimination rights, 5:24-5; 24:23-5, 32-40;
32:21-2, 24; 39:17; 48:20-l, 31-2
Children/cducation, relationship, 24:29-32, 38-40
New Democratic Party position. 24:29, 34
Quebec legislation, 24:25-6, 32-4, 37

Shimizu, Dr. Art (Chairman, Constitution Committee, National
Association of Japanese Canadians)
Constitution of Canada, 13:9-I0, 14, 20-5

Simard, Ms. Louise (Deputy ChiefCommissioner, Saskatchewan
Human Rights Commission)
Constitution of Canada, 20:22-4

Simon, Mr. René (Chairman. Attikamck-Montagnais Council)
Constitution of Canada, 28:4-29

Sinclair, Mr. Jinn (President, Association of Métis and Non-Status
lndians ofSaskatchewan)
Constitution of Canada, 22:l29-43, l47—52

Skagen, Mr. Donald (Canadians for Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 34:l 10-I

Small business, family business
New Democratic Party position, 44:16, 22
See also Property rights

Smallegs, Mr. Nelson (Indian Association of Alberta)
Constitution ot‘.Canada. 31:83

Smith, Mr. Bruce (President of Toronto Ontario East Stake, Church
of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints)
Constitution of Canada. 29:7~l8

Smith, Mr. David (L~Don Valley East)
Constitution ofCanada, 12:40-3
References, see Committee —Proceedings

Smith, Mr. Elijah (Vice Chairman, Council for Yukon lndians)
Constitution of Canada, 18:23-4

Smith, Senator George I. (Colchestcr)
Constitution of Canada, 17:44-6

Smith, Mr. Michael (Legal Counsel, Council for Yukon Indians)
Constitution of Canada, l8:|6-7, 21-2

Smith, Mr. Percy (Indian Association ofAlbcrta)
Constitution of Canada, 3 1 :74

Snow, Mr. John (Chief from Treaty 7, Indian Association of Alberta)
Constitution of Canada, 29:96-lot, 122

Social Credit Party of Alberta

History, 33: l 56-8

See also Amending procedure; Britain——Legislation, “Made in
Canada”; Federalism; Linguistic and cultural rights; Native
rights; Natural rcsourccs—-Pricing; Organizations/individuals
appearing and briefs submitted; Patriation; Process; Property
rights; Western provinces——Alienation

Social security programs, residency requirements, see Mobility rights

Social services, 29:l49-50, l58-61
Access, universality, l9:3l, 38-40; 29:23, 149, 152-3. I60
Federal-provincial jurisdiction, 29:l49-60
Government service in either official language, 29:16]
Resolution effect, l9:33-4, 41-3

See also Mobility rights—~-Employment and residence

Welfare recipients, Alta./Sask., 32:|36
See also Equalization

Société franeo-manitobaine, see Organizations/individuals appearing
and briels submitted
Soonias, Mr. Rodney (Legal Counsel, Federation of Saskatchewan
Indians)
Constitution ofCanada, 29:| l4-6; 3l:70, 73
Speaker, Mr. Ray (Member, Legislative Assembly, Province of
Alberta, House Leader for the Social Credit Party ol”Alberta)
Constitution of Canada, 33:l55
Spcyer, Mr. Chris (PC—Cambridge)
Constitution of Canada, 7:38-9; ll:34-6; 21:20-2
Splnne, Dr. Richard (President, Canadian Association of Social

Workers)
Constitution of Canada, 292146-6|

Stanhury, Senator Richard J. (York Centre)
Constitution of Canada. 29:46-7

Stanﬁeld, Hon. Robert L.. see Unilateral action; War Measures Act

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 49

Stark. Mr. T. James (Director. Operation Dismantle, World
Federalists of Canada)
Constitution 01′ Canada, 25:24-8

Statute of Westminster (I931), 9:98-9; 34:9-10; 35:7; 37:1 1; 50:29, 35,
46: 55:8
See aLro Amending procedure; Ncwfoundland-Labrador—Terms of
union (1949); Unilateral action——Provinces

Steinhauer, Mr. Eugene (President. lndian Association of Alberta)
Constitution of Canada, 29:94-S, 101-4, 121; 31:60-5, 74-8, 83, 91-3

Steurat, Senator David Gordon (Prince Albert-Duck Lake)
Constitution of Canada, 54:27-8

Stevenson, Professor Garth (Alberta New Democratic Party)
Constitution of Canada, 33:1 10-1, 115, 121-3, 128, 132

Strayer, Dr. B.L. (Assistant Deputy Minister, Public Law. Justice
Department)
Constitution of Canada, 4:33, 46, 1 12-3, 117; 38:16, 45-7, 61, 85;
4l:46—7; 46:32-43, 46; 521110-1, 116-7: 53:51; 54:19-23, 29-30,
57-8, 75-6, 106-8

Sub judice convention, me Resolution-~-Provincial reference~
Supreme Court reference

Suluk, Mr. Thomas (lnuit Committee on National lssues)
Constitution of Canada, 17:22~4

Supreme Court, 29:57; 30:21; 321104: 34:23-7
Appointments, 34: 1 20-1
Women, etc., 9:60-1, 70-I: 22:51-3, 63-71; 27:64; 33:l05, 108,
I 14
Ccntralist bias, 34:24
Blakeney remarks, 30:45-6

Citizens direct appeals, 29:31

Justices, former, see Pigeon

Provinces direct appeals, 34:88-91

United States, comparing, 34:12], 171-2

See also Charter of rights—Courts interpreting; Resolution: Senate:

Unilateral action

Sussman, Professor Fred (Chairman of the Committee on Legislation,
Canadian Association for the Prevention of Crime)
Constitution of Canada, 24:43-58

Swan, Mr. Davis (Chairman, Energy Committee, Alberta New
Democratic Party)
Constitution of Canada, 33:l08-10

Sykes, Mr. Rod (Leader, Social Credit Party of Alberta)
Constitution of Canada, 33:155-S9

Sylvestre, Mr. Paul-Francois (Canadian Association of Lesbians and
Gay Men)
Constitution or” Canada, 24:25-6, 33-4

Table of cases
Calder case, see Native peop1e—-lndians, Land claims
Hogan vs The Queen (1975), see Charter of rights–—1.ega1 rights,
Right to counsel
Person’s case (1929), see Women
Thorsan case, we Quebec—~Languages policy, Bill 101

Tagoona, Mr. Eric (Co~Chairman. Inuit Committee on National
lssucs)
Constitution ofCanada, 16:4-18, 21
Tardif, Mr. Gilles (Director, Canadian Federation of Civil Liberties

and Human Rights Associations)
Constitution of Canada, 2129-10, 19, 22-3

Tarnopolsky, Mr. Walter (President, Canadian Civil Liberties
Association)
Constitution of Canada, 7:7-1 1, 15-31
References, see Charter of rights; Property rights

Tassé. Mr. Roger (Deputy Minister ofJusticc)

Constitution of Canada, 2:48-9; 3:14-5, 28-9, 78-9; 4:45-9, 85-6,
11l-3; 37:20, 45; 38:39-40, 49-51, 55, 65, 68-9; 40:19-22;
41:16—7, 21-4, 39-40; 42:17; 43:7l;46:49-50, 104-5, 116-8,
122-3:47:31-4,40-2;48:84.87,112-3:49:27-9, 43, 92-3, 96;
50:16; 51:25; 52:128-9; 53:25, 68-70: 54:92; 56:10-1

References. 55:7

Tate, Mr. Percy (Executive Assistant to the President, Nishga Tribal
Council)
Constitution of Canada‘, 26:23, 26, 30-1

Taxation. 8:9—l0, 382102
See also Charitable and educational organizations; Churches;
Natural resources

Teed, Mr. Eric L. (Past President, Canadian Citizenship Federation)
Constitution of Canada, 29:58-9

Tltériault, Senator L. Norbert (Baie du Vin)
Constitution of Canada, 48: 1 27

Thomson, Ms, Tamra (Ottawa caucus, National Association of
Women and the Law)
Constitution of Canada, 22360-1, 70

Tobin, Mr. Brian (L—Humber-Port au Port-St. Barbe)
Amending procedure, 3:72; 51:120-1
Charter ofrights, 32:137.-5 ‘
Committee, proceedings, procedural delays, 9:55-6
Committee, witnesses, 1:29-30, 33, 77
Constitution of Canada, 1:15, 29-30, 33, 68-9, 77: 2139-40; 3:20,
70-2; 9:55-6, 91-6; 32:69, 132-5: 34:50: 38:55, 59, 62-3; 46:84-5;
48:127-30:31:11?-22;52:46-8,105;54:l04-5
Linguistic and cultural rights, 32:132
Mobility rights, 46:84-5
Natural resources, 32:135
Newfoundland-Labrador, 2:39-40; 3:70-2; 9:91-6; 38:55, 62-3;
482127-30: 52:46-8
Organization meeting, 1:15, 29-30, 33, 68, 77
Peckford, Mr., references, 2:40
Points of order
Adjournment, M. (Mr. Fraser), 1:68
Agenda and procedure subcommittee, 1:15
Documents, briefs, advertising for, M. (Mr. 1r\vin), and
requesting witnesses, amdt. (Mr. Nystrom), 1:29-30, 33
Questioning of witnesses, 3:20
Witnesses, expenses, Committee paying, M, (Mr. Epp), 1:77
Process, 32:69
References, 53:44
Resolution to Queen, 34:50; S4:104-5
Senate, 521105

Tomkins, Mr. Frank (Provincial Secretary, Association of Métis and
Non-Status Indians of Saskatchewan)
Constitution of Canada, 22:134

Tooshkenig, Mr. Bill (Association of Iroquois and Allied Indians)
Constitution of Canada. 31:49-51. S5-6

Tootoosis, Senator John B. (Senator of Federation of Saskatchewan
lndians)
Constitution of Canada, 29:l05-6

Toth, Mrs. Kathleen'(President, Campaign Lil’e——Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 34:1 16, 125

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

50 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Townshend, Mr. Errol (Chief Editor of “Cultures Canada”, Canadian
Consultative Council on Multiculturalism)
Constitution ofCanada, 29:l33-41, 145-6

Transportation, see Jurisdictions
Treaty-Making power, 4:67-8

Tremblay, Senator Arthur (Les Laurentides)

Amending procedure, 2:22-5, 44; 3274-5; 7:72; 19:64~6; 27:59; 2 :46:
30:53-5; 34:19-21, 98; 36:24-6; 41:10?-8, 111-3, 122-3; 51:32-3,
56-61, 73: 52:23-5: 55:16-7

Britain, legislation enabling Canadian constitutional amdt., 4:1 10-1;
37:8-10, 16-7; 50:36-40

Charter of rights, 6:27-8; 10:42~5; 13:52; 42:35-7; 55:17

Chretien, Mr. references, 40:5

Committee

Deadline, 9:37-9
Travel, 1:81~2
Witnesses, 1:39-40; 23:66-7; 28:56-7

Conferences, 14:1 12; 51:1 13-21

Consensus, 23:18, 21-2

Constitution of Canada, 1:25, 39-40, 81~2; 2:22-6, 44; 3:72-5;
4:38-41, 110-5; 627-30; 7271- ’37-9,98-9:10:30-4,42-3;
11:16, 23-6; 13:2 -6,41-5, 51- , ,112-4,123-4;15‘26-7;
19:64- ‘22:100-2; 23:22-6, 66-71; 24:81~2‘ 7:59; 2 4-6, 56-7;
30:53-5; 3:181-2, 188; 34:18-22, 97-8 -7; 36124-6;
37:7-17. 33, 44-6; 38:81~3, 109-10; 3 :19-23;40:5,12-3;
41:lO3-8,111-3,122-3;42:35-7, 4S;43:lO6-7,114,120;44:23;
45:7, 14, 31-6; 46:34, 85-6, 109; 47:21, 33-5, 40-1, 58,66, 86-7;
48:18.40, 45.75-6,86-91,94,103-4,117-8:49:13, 29-32, 38,
47-9, 54, 59-60, 72, 76-7, 80, 86, 93-6; 50:22, 36-40; 5121 1-3, 21,
32-3, 38-40, 54-61, 73; 52223-5, 76-8, 88; 53:56, 70, 81-2:
54:45-8, 104, 111-8, 122-6; 55:16-24; 56:l1—3, 19-21

Courts, 49:29-31

Education, 11:25-6; 24:81-2

Emergency, public, 49:49, 59-60

Equalization, 412106; 49:767. 80

Federal position, 51:54-7

Federal-provincial relations, provincial boundaries, 3:72-4

Federalism, 33:l8|-2

Freedom of information, 43:106-7, 114

Jurisdictions, provincial, 4:1 1 1-5; 34120-1; 49232

Language ofinstruction, 7:71-2; 10:29-34; 23:24-6; 38:81-3, 109-10;
48:103-4, 117-8

Linguistic and cultural rights, 6:28-30; 222100-1; 37:44-6; 48275-6,
88-9|; 52:76-8

Mineral resources, offshore, 9:98-9; 53:81-2

Monarchy, 53:56

National unity, “Canada“, 42:45

Native rights, 49:93

Natural resources, 331188; 54:45-8; 56:11

Non-discrimination rights, 13:41-3

Official languages policy, 10244

Organization meeting, 1225, 39-40, 81-2

Patriation, 28:45-6; 34:22; 40:12-3

Points oforder

Documents, briefs, advertising for, M. (Mr. Irwin), and
requesting witnesses, amdt. (Mr. Nystrom), 1:39-40

McGrath privilege, 45:14, 3|-2

Proceedings, postponing, 47:21

Questioning of witnesses, 132256

Travel, M. (Mr. Epp), 1:81-2

Witnesses/meetings/report deadline, M. (Senator Austin),
23:66-8

Progressive Conservative Party constitution position, 54:116-8,
122-6: 56:20-1

Property rights, 44:23; 452356

Tremblay, Senator Artltur-M Com.

Quebec, 11:23-5; 35:16; 39:19-23; 52:24-5

References, see Jurisdictions~—»Provincia1, Quebec

Regulations, 49:38

Resolution to Queen, 34:18; 35:13-4; 3727-9; 41:103-4; 43:l20;
46:34,85-6,109;/47:33-5,40-1, 66; 49:72, 76, 96; 50:22;
541114-6; 55:21-2; 56:13

Unilateral action, 3:74-5; 4:38-41, 111-5; 37:12-6: 45:33-4

Trudeau, Rt. Hon, P.E.
Constitution position, 542128-31 «
Stevens, Geoffrey, Feb. 5/81 Globe and Mail column, 54:118
See also Committeerwitnesses; Linguistic and cultural rights;
Monarchy; Native rights; Patriation-—-Divisive; Resolution

Ukrainian Canadian Committee, we Charter of rights;

Orgauizations/individuals appearing and briefs submitted
Ukrainian Canadians, World War 11 treatment, 14:54
Unemployment Insurance Act, see Unilateral action~-—Pr0vlnces

Unilateral action, 33:l26-30
Anglican Church of Canada position, 33:21-2, 49-50
Balance of power, affecting, 34:136-7
Blakeney position, 41756: 30:57
Business Council on National lssues position, 332137, 141-2, 145-7
Canadian Bar Association, Newfoundland Branch, position, 9:98
Canadian Citizenship Federation position, 29:51, 54-7
Chrétien position, 4:76-7, 106-110;50:47, 82
Clark remarks, 3:84; 4:76; 38:12-4
Cohen position, 35:45
Declaration ofindependence, without recourse to Britain, 34:28-4);
35:12, 16
Denominational Education Committees of Newfoundland position,
35:70
Divisive aspects, 17:32-4; 22:14; 23:70; 27:14, 48, 89-90, 97; 30:7, 17
During provincial appeal to courts, 41:67
Economy, affecting, 8:10-1; 332145-51
Federal position, 3:74- 4:38-40; 6:40 8:35-6; 12:108-9; 13:31-2;
l4:l07; 30:30-1; 31:89; 36:22; 45:3 -4; 54:|32; 56:33, 48
Committee witnesses, 80% approval, Mackasey remarks, 34:l4S-7
Hatfield remarks, 19:51, 56, 66-7, 70- 1, 83-4
Union Nationale position, 28:32-5
French-English animosity, kindling, 8:42
Legality, 142101-2; 15:25-6; 21:43
Canadian Bar Association position, 15:6—7, 14-5, 23,26
Liberal (Que.) position, 9:46-13, 51
National Congress of Italian-Canadians (Quebec region) position.
23:15
Necessity, 41:85; 50:44; 55:12-6
Official languages commissioner position, 6:41-4
Pigeon position, 4:93-4
Progressive Conservative position, 41:94, 120- 1; 43: 1 03-4
Provinces, consulting, 27:37, 40; 34112-6, 32-3, 83; 35:10; 50:60-1
Bill C-60 of 30th Parliament, 34237-8, 41
British North America Act amdts., 27:37-9, 61-2: 34:24-5, 32,
38-40; 35:8-1 1, 26
Newfoundland entry into Confederation, 34:15l, 154
St. Laurent position, 17:29; 27:39; 34:l36-7; 35:8; 37:1 1-4
Saskatchewan, 12:12-3
Statute of Westminster/BNA Act (1949) amdt., Rémillard
position, 34:13-5, 26-8, 35-8, 72-4
Unemployment insurance Act, comparing, 37:13-4
White paper (1965), 17:29, 48; 27:40, 62; 28:33; 30:5; 50:45
See also Natural resources
Public opinion polls, 322107; 34:70
Quebec, forcing towards separation, 28:39-40, 44
Quebec National Assembly motion, 28:31, 50

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

CONSTITUTION OF CANADA 51

Unilateral aCtion—ConI.

Quebec referendum relationship, 4:95-6, 105-6, 110; 3143: 28:37~8

Ryan, informing, 4:96-7

Stanfield position, 19:71

Supreme Court decisiion re Bill C-60 of the 30th Parliament,
relationship, 4:93

Union ofOntario Indians position, 31:41-2

See also Amending procedure; Jurisdictions—-Provincial, Federal
encroachment

Unilateral Declaration of Independence (UDI), 2:30-l

Union Nationale Party
Background, 28:29
See also Amending procedure——Vancouver consensus (1980):
Charter of rights; Organizations/individuals appearing and
briefs submitted; Unilateral action—Federal position
Union of New Brunswick Indians, see Organizations/individuals
appearing and briefs submitted

Union of Nova Scotia Indians, see Organizations/individuals
appearing and briefs submitted

Union of Ontario Indians, see Native rights:
Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs submitted:
Unilateral action

Unitary state, 27:45, 63

United Church 01’ Canada, see Organizations/individuals appearing
and briefs submitted; Resolution

United Nations, see Pcnitentiarics

United States, we Fedora|ism—Decentralization; Native rights;
Supreme Court

Vancouver Pcople’s Law School Society, 32:5-6
See also Charter of rights; Committee—Witnesses;
Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs submitted

Vian, Mr. Jacques (Beitonnier, Past President, Canadian Bar
Association)
Constitution of Canada, 15:16, 28
Viekers, Mr. David (Vice President, Canadian Association for the
Mentally Retarded)
Constitution of Canada, 10:8-19

Victoria Formula (1971), see Amending procedure

Waddell, Mr. Ian (NDP—Vancouver-Kingsway)
Constitution of Canada, 17:l20-3; 26:46-9; 54:17, 28-9, 36-7, 40-1,
73-4

Wadds, Mrs. .l.C., see Britain

Walker, Mr. Regan (Executive Director, Toronto Stake, Church of
Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints)
Constitution of Canada, 29:14-6

War, we Freedoin of conscience
War criminals, see Charter of rights

War Measures Act, 47:72; 49:58-9
Legal opinion, tabling, 40. 8-31: 41:6-7. 12-3. 16
Stanfield position, 43:36
See also Amending procedure—Referendum; Charter of rights

Warner, Mr. Malcolm (President, Hamilton Stake, Church of.lesus
Christ of Latter Day Saints)
Constitution of Canada, 29:l3~4

Watt, Mr. Charlie (Co-Chairman, lnuit Committee on National

Issues)
Constitution of Canada, 16:4, 19-30; 17:7-25

Watters, Dr. Wendell W. (Honorary Director, Canadian Abortion
Rights Action League)
Constitution of Canada, 241101-13

Watts, Mr. George (Chairman, Nuu-Chah-Nulth Tribal Council)
Constitution of Canada, 27:l26-8, 135-49

Wawatie, Mr. Salomon (Algonquin Council)
Constitution of Canada, 31:9, 19

Welrlting, Mr. Edwin (Chairman, Canadian Federation of Civil
Libertics and Human Rights Associations)
Constitution of Canada, 21:5-6, 11-27

Western provinces
Alienation, l2:l00, 114-5, 124-5, 132-4‘ 7:59-60, 71-2; 322130-1,
146; 33:1 13; 34:36, 105-8, 115; 54. 8, 80-2 6:23
Alberta New Democratic Party position, 33:10 -7
Quebec. comparing, 1:85-6
Senate role, 51:64-5
Social Credit Party of Alberta position, 33:158-62, 165-6, 171-4,
177-9
See also Amending procedure—Referendum-—Victoria formula
(1971); Natural resources; Progressive Conservative
Party—Constitution position, Broadbent allegations; Public
opinion polls–~-Canada West Foundation
Separatism, 12:1 13-4, 132; 32:9, 17, 33:165-6
See also Amending procedure—-Ontario/Que. veto—Referendum,
Regional majorities

Whalcn, Mr. Norman (Vice Chairman, Canadian Federation of Civil
Liberties and Human Rights Associations)
Constitution of Canada, 21:6-9, 14-17, 20

Whclan, Mr. Patrick (Treasurer, Federation of independent Schools

in Canada)
Constitution of Canada, 29:73-4

Wildlife, endangered species, protecting. 24:95

Williams, Senator Guy (Richmond)

Constitution of Canada, 13:21-2; 26:29-30; 27:l38-41; 31:18-9,
54-6; 32:28, 96-8; 33:126- .34:35-6

Native i’ights, 26:29-30; 271138-40; 31:18-9, 54-6; 32:28, 96-81
33:12_6-7; 34:36

Western provinces, 34:37

Williams, Mr. Paul (Union of Ontario Indians)
Constitution of Canada, 31:28-42

Willson, Mr. Robert (Chairman and Chief Executive Officer,
Canadians for Canada)
Constitution ofCanada, 34:100-4, 107, 110-15

Witnesses, see Committee; Organizations/individuals appearing and
briefs submitted; Procedure and decisions of the Chair

Women
Discrimination, historical, 9:62-3
Non-discrimination rights, 4:55-6; 5:9; 9:65; 172102; 21:24-5; 22:53;
29:10, 13
Business Council on National Issues position, 33:l43-4
Consultations, 9:136-7, 148-9, 152
Hays remarks, 9. 5:21:29
Judicial interpretation, 5:15-6; 9:58-60, 66, 72
Maternity benefits, legal cases, 20:7-10, 22:27:64
Military service, 29:9; 32:13
See also Sexual equality

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

52 CONSTITUTION OF CANADA

Women—~Com.
Person’s case (1929), 9:l36
See also Affirmative action: Native people; Native rights; Supreme
Court—Appointments

Wood, Mr. Charles (Chiefs Constitution Committee for Alberta.
Indian Association ofA|berta)
Constitution of Canada, 29:96

Woodward, Mr. Jack (Legal Counsel, Nuu-Chah~Nulth Tribal
Council)
Constitution of Canada. 27:l26-38. I42-53

World Federalist: of Canada, see Organizations/individuals appearing
and briefs submitted

Wright, Mr. Bill (PC—-—Calgary North)
Constitution of Canada. 27:72~4

Writs of assistance, effect of charter, 4] :13-4; 46:l08

Wyss, Barbara (Treasurer. Indian Rights for Indian Women)
Constitution of Canada. l7:86-9!, 95

Yalden, Mr. M.F. (Commissioner of Official Languages)
Constitution or‘ Canada. 6:10-47

Young, Mr. Francis (Legal Counsel. New Brunswick Human Rights
Commission)
Constitution ofCanada. ll:32~3, 39

Young, Mr. Neil (NDP—Beaches)
Constitution of Canada, 10:14-5: 12:34-6

Young offenders, legal rights. 2l:30~l, 38-9, 45-8

Yukon Territory
Development, pipeline, resources, etc.. 18:8. 12-3, 16-8, 31-2
Government
Councillor Yukon Indians, relationship, 14:49-50; 18:8, l3~7,
30-1
Letters, tabling, 14:34,/12,51
Legitimacy. recognizing, Epp remarks, i8:2l-3
See also Organizations/individuals appearing and briefs
submitted
Indians, self-government. l8:l2
Legislative Assembly, l4:30~l
Council for Yukon Indians position. l8:2l-2
Indian representation. 18:21, 24, 27
Natural resources, 26:6-7
Population, native/white, 14:49; l8:l7. 23-4
Provincial status, l4:32-3, 43-7. 50; l7:l7-8; 26:8; 41 :55-7
Natural resources, ownership/control. relationship, 14:33, 43-4.
47
See also Amending procedure; Council ofthe provinces; Federal-
provincial conferences: Mobility rights–Employment and
residence: Native people—~—Land claims; Resolution

Yuzyk, Senator Paul (Fort Garry)
Constitution ofCanada, 43:l0O, I16

Zsolnay, Mr. Nicolas (President. Canadian Citizenship Federation)
Constitution oi” Canada, 29:50-7. 61-3

Note: See page 1 for Dates and Issues

K
r lmprimerie du gouvernemenl canadien.

Canada Ponies
I * Post Canada
Postage paid Port nave
Third Troisiéme
‘ class classe

MA 087
HULL

II undelivered, return COVER ONL Y to.
Canadian Government Prlnllng Otlice, 1
Supply and Services Canada.

45 Saere-Coeur Boulevard.

Hull, Quebec, Canada. KIA OS7

En cas de non-Iivraison,

reiourner celte COUVEF? TUBE SEULEMENT 6.’

Approvisionnemenis et Services Canada.
45. boulevard Sacre-Coeur,
Hull, Quebec. Canada. K1A 087

Available from the Canadian Government Publishing Centre, Supply and Services Canada, Hull, Quebec, Canada KIA 0S9

(

ya .1

Read less

Other Issues:

Index	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9
10	11	12	13	14	15	16	17	18	19
20	21	22	23	24	25	26	27	28	29
30	31	32	33	34	35	36	37	38	39
40	41	42	43	44	45	46	47	48	49
50	51	52	53	54	55	56	57

Committees, Government Documents, Votes and Proceedings Special Joint Committee on the Constitution of Canada (1980-81)

PrimaryDocuments.ca

Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Special Joint Committee of the Senate and of the House of Commons on the Constitution of Canada, 32nd Parl, 1st Sess, Index (13 February 1981)

Like this:

1 Comment »

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Minutes of Proceedings and Evidence of the Special Joint Committee of the Senate and of the House of Commons on the Constitution of Canada, 32nd Parl, 1st Sess, Index (13 February 1981)

Share this:

Like this:

1 Comment »

Leave a ReplyCancel reply